'exercise calories'

barbiex3
barbiex3 Posts: 1,036 Member
edited September 2024 in Food and Nutrition
I know there are a lot of threads about this, but how much of them are you really supposed to eat back. Is it really that bad to not eat them all back? I burn around 750 calories a day, so I feel that if I don't eat most of them back it could be really bad for my body, but at the same time, i have a lot of energy and I'm losing weight, so is it really that bad? Today I had a net of about 380 calories, but I still ended up eating 1350. Is this like okay to do? i donno

Replies

  • 6heatherb6
    6heatherb6 Posts: 469 Member
    I don't....eat them back that is....
  • maryd4love
    maryd4love Posts: 164 Member
    _ I do not eat them back. I mean, as long as ate my starting calories before exercise, that is. I just do not see the point in eating the calories you just work hard to lose. It is just stupid in my opinion.
  • chevy88grl
    chevy88grl Posts: 3,937 Member
    It really depends on your body. However, keep in mind too large of a calorie deficit will work in the short term for weight loss. However, you may find that you struggle in a few weeks or months. I personally eat back all my exercise calories. After 18 months in this journey, I've learned that my body wants and needs me to eat them back. Not eating them back causes me to actually gain weight (and stopped my weight loss in its tracks when I was still losing - I'm in maintenance now). If you want to try the "not eating them back" way of this journey - it's fine. But, be aware -- if you stop losing weight you may have to up your calories to see a loss again.
  • chevy88grl
    chevy88grl Posts: 3,937 Member
    _ I do not eat them back. I mean, as long as ate my starting calories before exercise, that is. I just do not see the point in eating the calories you just work hard to lose. It is just stupid in my opinion.

    Unlike most other programs, MFP assumes you aren't going to exercise when you put in all of your information. So, the daily calories it gives you already includes a deficit meant to help you lose the amount of weight, in the amount of time you put into the site.

    So, if MFP tells you to eat 1200 calories a day - 400 calories you burn during exercise = 800 NET calories. This is how many calories you are REALLY eating + 400 calories eaten back after exercise = 1200 which is the original goal MFP set for you. Now, it will show that you ate 1600, but you didn't since you burned 400 during exercise.

    Too big of a calorie deficit - while effective at first in weight loss doesn't tend to last long term. Eventually your body thinks it is starving to death and stops losing weight. It'll begin storing fat and burning muscle for fuel because it isn't getting enough food. You don't want this to happen - you want your body to be comfortable enough that it burns the fat and builds muscle. Muscle burns more calories on a daily basis. Fat burns none.
  • DevanEve
    DevanEve Posts: 130 Member
    I don't eat back my calories. I burn around 500 - 700 calories during workouts and everything has still been coming off just fine. No low energy, etc. :)
  • barbiex3
    barbiex3 Posts: 1,036 Member
    It really depends on your body. However, keep in mind too large of a calorie deficit will work in the short term for weight loss. However, you may find that you struggle in a few weeks or months. I personally eat back all my exercise calories. After 18 months in this journey, I've learned that my body wants and needs me to eat them back. Not eating them back causes me to actually gain weight (and stopped my weight loss in its tracks when I was still losing - I'm in maintenance now). If you want to try the "not eating them back" way of this journey - it's fine. But, be aware -- if you stop losing weight you may have to up your calories to see a loss again.

    i;ve seen you post on here before, and I kinda agree with you, but I also don't think I should eat them back every day.
    I don't know really. I've been zig zagging my calories, so some days i'll be eatin 1300 and others 2100. It just depends on how my body feels and stuff. I'm not really sure what the right answer is. I just didn't want to be doing anything stupid to my body by only eating NET 350 because that sounds really bad to me, but a lot of people seem to think it's okay
  • maryd4love
    maryd4love Posts: 164 Member
    It really depends on your body. However, keep in mind too large of a calorie deficit will work in the short term for weight loss. However, you may find that you struggle in a few weeks or months. I personally eat back all my exercise calories. After 18 months in this journey, I've learned that my body wants and needs me to eat them back. Not eating them back causes me to actually gain weight (and stopped my weight loss in its tracks when I was still losing - I'm in maintenance now). If you want to try the "not eating them back" way of this journey - it's fine. But, be aware -- if you stop losing weight you may have to up your calories to see a loss again.

    i;ve seen you post on here before, and I kinda agree with you, but I also don't think I should eat them back every day.
    I don't know really. I've been zig zagging my calories, so some days i'll be eatin 1300 and others 2100. It just depends on how my body feels and stuff. I'm not really sure what the right answer is. I just didn't want to be doing anything stupid to my body by only eating NET

    The zig zagging of calories, i read somewhere, is a good thing. It keeps your body confused so it doesn't get use to the same thing everyday/
  • ShinyFraga
    ShinyFraga Posts: 132 Member
    Unlike most other programs, MFP assumes you aren't going to exercise when you put in all of your information. So, the daily calories it gives you already includes a deficit meant to help you lose the amount of weight, in the amount of time you put into the site.

    So, if MFP tells you to eat 1200 calories a day - 400 calories you burn during exercise = 800 NET calories. This is how many calories you are REALLY eating + 400 calories eaten back after exercise = 1200 which is the original goal MFP set for you. Now, it will show that you ate 1600, but you didn't since you burned 400 during exercise.

    Too big of a calorie deficit - while effective at first in weight loss doesn't tend to last long term. Eventually your body thinks it is starving to death and stops losing weight. It'll begin storing fat and burning muscle for fuel because it isn't getting enough food. You don't want this to happen - you want your body to be comfortable enough that it burns the fat and builds muscle. Muscle burns more calories on a daily basis. Fat burns none.

    This is what I have been taught as well.
  • Josephine237
    Josephine237 Posts: 72 Member
    I eat most of them back, I wasn't losing for a month...it was suggested to eat them back and try to eat some of them as protein. I started losing, Im new to this, but its helped me, Sometimes Im short a 100 or so, but I give myself some flexability.
  • kr3851
    kr3851 Posts: 994 Member
    I can't always eat all mine back - but I aim for half. Sometimes I think I'll just have a chocolate or something to make it up, but that's kinda counter-productive, so I don't. If I'm hungry, I'll try to fill up with steamed veg or some grilled chicken, or some nutrient-rich snacks, but I'm not going to eat just for the sake of eating.

    I like to use the weekly tool on the iPhone too - it gives you an average for the week. Some days I'm slightly over, some days I'm slightly under, but as long as it's under for the week I don't worry too much.
  • sarah307
    sarah307 Posts: 1,363 Member
    I DO eat my exercise calories back and it has worked fine for me :) but I don't burn as much as you do... Sometimes I don't eat them back, but most of the time, I do!

    But, if I burn over 500 calories that day from exercise..then I make sure I eat over half of that back.. I just always make sure my net is up. This has HELPED me tremendously. I think before, I was eating too little and not losing. Now I'm eating more, and losing.

    :)
  • LorinaLynn
    LorinaLynn Posts: 13,247 Member
    I eat most of them back most of the time, and that's what works best for me. I've lost weight before, but this is the first time I've really lost FAT, and I credit that to fueling my body properly.

    I know the online body fat percentage calculators aren't the most accurate way to judge, but according to my measurements, in the last pound I lost, my lean body mass went up two pounds. So if that's correct, I lost three pounds of fat and gained two pounds of muscle... and that just ROCKS!
This discussion has been closed.