Coffee
emilyrippe
Posts: 3 Member
Good morning. Wondering where coffee fits in? I drink Folgers Black Silk, scanned the barcode and it is 0 everything. But my big question is do I get to count it in my water intake?
TYIA Emily
TYIA Emily
1
Replies
-
Short answer, yes.
Longer answer - everything with water counts as water. Coffee, tea, soda, juice, cucumbers, soup, etc, etc. I leave alcohol out of that list, though. The eight cups of water thing is outdated. If your urine is light straw-colored to clear, you're getting enough water.10 -
Thanks!
0 -
Lol I was hoping to get the long answer too. Thanks! This makes me a very happy lady. Merry Christmas!1
-
Coffee is a diuretic, meaning it actually dehydrates you. I would not consider it water since it does not play the same role. Same with coffee, juices, etc. If you are wanting to track water intake, buy a water bottle with numerical measurements, and keep track of the amount you drink. Water is water! There are no substitutes.17
-
Sambo_fitness wrote: »Coffee is a diuretic, meaning it actually dehydrates you. I would not consider it water since it does not play the same role. Same with coffee, juices, etc. If you are wanting to track water intake, buy a water bottle with numerical measurements, and keep track of the amount you drink. Water is water! There are no substitutes.
This is a myth. While caffeine is a diuretic, the water in coffee will still hydrate someone.
Juices also wouldn't dehydrate anyone, I'm not even sure what you're basing that on.
People who drink coffee are able to count it as meeting their overall hydration needs (along with things like water, soda, juice, and the water content in the food they eat).
Water is water. It's still water if it's in coffee or juice. It's not a substitute for water. It literally *is* water.14 -
janejellyroll wrote: »Sambo_fitness wrote: »Coffee is a diuretic, meaning it actually dehydrates you. I would not consider it water since it does not play the same role. Same with coffee, juices, etc. If you are wanting to track water intake, buy a water bottle with numerical measurements, and keep track of the amount you drink. Water is water! There are no substitutes.
This is a myth. While caffeine is a diuretic, the water in coffee will still hydrate someone.
Juices also wouldn't dehydrate anyone, I'm not even sure what you're basing that on.
People who drink coffee are able to count it as meeting their overall hydration needs (along with things like water, soda, juice, and the water content in the food they eat).
Water is water. It's still water if it's in coffee or juice. It's not a substitute for water. It literally *is* water.
This. Coffee is mostly water, so I count it as water. I don't count juice or soda, but I can see why people would.5 -
Sambo_fitness wrote: »Coffee is a diuretic, meaning it actually dehydrates you. I would not consider it water since it does not play the same role. Same with coffee, juices, etc. If you are wanting to track water intake, buy a water bottle with numerical measurements, and keep track of the amount you drink. Water is water! There are no substitutes.
Coffee is a mild diuretic. The effects of which are greatly overshadowed by the hydrating effects of the water. It takes 250-300mg after days to weeks of caffeine deprivation to actually feel the diuretic effects. So yes, coffee does count as hydration.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/1977475411 -
Sambo_fitness wrote: »Coffee is a diuretic, meaning it actually dehydrates you. I would not consider it water since it does not play the same role. Same with coffee, juices, etc. If you are wanting to track water intake, buy a water bottle with numerical measurements, and keep track of the amount you drink. Water is water! There are no substitutes.
If I have a glass of water with breakfast as well as my (really strong) coffee, doesn't it all get mixed up in my stomach as coffee that's average strength or a little weak? Does the water still count as water then?
Yes, water is water. It doesn't stop being water because you mix it up with other things, whether you do the mixing by brewing coffee, or mother nature does it by combining it with vitamins and minerals in a fruit that you then squeeze to get juice.1 -
Sambo_fitness wrote: »Coffee is a diuretic, meaning it actually dehydrates you. I would not consider it water since it does not play the same role. Same with coffee, juices, etc. If you are wanting to track water intake, buy a water bottle with numerical measurements, and keep track of the amount you drink. Water is water! There are no substitutes.
I find it interesting that you think coffee doesn't count because it's diuretic, but - by implication - you wouldn't count sports drinks even though they specifically include electrolytes that can encourage water retention, because 'there are no substitutes'.3 -
emilyrippe wrote: »Good morning. Wondering where coffee fits in? I drink Folgers Black Silk, scanned the barcode and it is 0 everything. But my big question is do I get to count it in my water intake?
TYIA Emily
I don't count it at all. some things like this seems so trivial.0 -
The coffee is a diruetic myth dates to 1928. And it is just that a myth that will not go away. If a drink contains water count it as part of your daily water intake.3
-
To be honest. IRISH COFFEES RULES lol4
-
MrWeather_81 wrote: »To be honest. IRISH COFFEES RULES lol
Mmm. Irish Coffee. I like the way you think.
1
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 391.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.4K Getting Started
- 259.7K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.6K Food and Nutrition
- 47.3K Recipes
- 232.3K Fitness and Exercise
- 387 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.4K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 152.7K Motivation and Support
- 7.8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.2K MyFitnessPal Information
- 22 News and Announcements
- 897 Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.2K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions