Curiousity Question regarding food documenting

monicalosesweight
Posts: 1,173 Member
Out of curiosity, I always check my calories but I know there is a column for carbs, fat and protein. Do you guys notice a big difference in weight loss if you make sure the last three columns are always at the right levels? I suddenly realized I may need to consider those columns but thought I'd ask to see if anyone else diligently watches those.
0
Replies
-
I don't watch anything but calories in vs. calories out. Trying to meet all of the magic numbers leads to me obsessing and eventually giving up.
You need to keep in mind that some of MFP's recommendations are minimums. Protein, for example, is a good thing.0 -
I try to keep my percentages at 40-40-20 (as in 40% carbs, 40% protein, and 20% fat). That is the recommended nutrition plan accompanying the workout I'm doing (the Insanity program). I agree with Skylark94 that protein is a good thing. However, I've read from many sources that your body can only absorb a maximum of around 30 grams of protein per day, so choking down more than that is unnecessary.
Overall, I suggest making good decisions (salad instead of a cheeseburger, no fast food or processed junk), eat lots of fresh fruits and veggies, stick to whole grains instead of white flour, and listen to your body.0 -
I watch the carbs b/c I'm diabetic and too many carbs is bad for diabetes and raises your blood sugar. In addition to my calories, I also watch my fiber b/c that helps with a lot of things. Protein is also very important. I should be paying more attention to that and getting more of that in order to not loose muscle mass when I exercise.0
-
However, I've read from many sources that your body can only absorb a maximum of around 30 grams of protein per day, so choking down more than that is unnecessary.
The average recommended protein intake is about 1 gram per pound of body weight. Way more than 30. I think you are thinking that you can't absorb more than 30g per MEAL, rather than per day.
http://www.livestrong.com/article/480054-how-much-protein-can-we-absorb-per-meal/0 -
I don't watch anything but calories in vs. calories out. Trying to meet all of the magic numbers leads to me obsessing and eventually giving up.
You need to keep in mind that some of MFP's recommendations are minimums. Protein, for example, is a good thing.
So what your saying is the other columns arent that important to keep an eye on ( meaning specifically sugar and sodium in my case) I find that i obsess about all these columns except the cals and protein and i usually keep the cals low and the protein is always over.
Also, do you eat all your daily calories AND your exercise ones back too and still lose? I'm not questioning your life just trying to understand how to make mine easier lol.0 -
I don't watch anything but calories in vs. calories out. Trying to meet all of the magic numbers leads to me obsessing and eventually giving up.
You need to keep in mind that some of MFP's recommendations are minimums. Protein, for example, is a good thing.
So what your saying is the other columns arent that important to keep an eye on ( meaning specifically sugar and sodium in my case) I find that i obsess about all these columns except the cals and protein and i usually keep the cals low and the protein is always over.
Also, do you eat all your daily calories AND your exercise ones back too and still lose? I'm not questioning your life just trying to understand how to make mine easier lol.
They're only important if they are something that YOU are concerned about. I watch protein because I am trying to build lean muscle and fiber because since I am a protein eater I am sometime short on fiber and have to supplement.
If you have high blood pressure, you may want to watch sodium. If you're diabetic, you may want to watch sugars.
If you're concerned about bone density, watch calcium. You get the picture. A lot of fruit eaters freak out because they go over on sugar, when the benefits of the fruits far outweigh the sugar content. If you are overall a healthy person, I suggest maybe keeping an eye on your macros (protein, carbs, fat) and not worrying too much about the rest. I have my macros set at 40/30/30.
As to my calories, I am in the "eat more to weigh less" camp. I do not believe super low calorie (1200) diets yield lasting results. I have my goal set to 10% below my sedentary TDEE (total daily energy expenditure) and I eat back 2/3rds of my exercise calories to make sure I net at least my BMR (basal metabolic rate)
If you want to learn more and learn what all of this means, check out this thread. It has step by step instructions for figuring out your numbers.
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/654536-in-place-of-a-road-map-2-0-revised-7-2-120 -
Thank you! That makes alot of sense to me. I was worried about the fruit sugar but, i love my fruit. I will check out that link . There is so much information out there and it gets confusing and at times seems a bit overboard just to lose weight.0
This discussion has been closed.