We are pleased to announce that as of March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor has been introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

defense mechanisms

pa_jorg
pa_jorg Posts: 4,404 Member
edited December 2024 in Social Groups
Ok, please don't tar and feather me for this, but there have been some threads lately where one person will make extremely negative, broad sweeping generalizations about the other gender. If you want to talk about a specific person you know who did something crappy to you, that's one thing, but to assume every male or female will be the same is not accurate. So, that got me wondering, are these negative generalizations simply defense mechanisms to help someone justify or feel better about why they are still single?

Replies

  • christine24t
    christine24t Posts: 6,063 Member
    Thank you! I agree! Just because one incident happened to you doesnt mean it's indicative of a whole gender.
  • Meghan0116
    Meghan0116 Posts: 1,263 Member
    I think sometimes it is just venting, i.e. all men are dogs. Blah blah blah. I have said men suck, or other things but I really mean the men in my life. I think it comes from a place of pain for most people but there are those where it comes from a place of bias.
  • La_Amazona
    La_Amazona Posts: 4,855 Member
    Def venting... I don't think it's fair to assume all guys are cheaters like my ex was. I think it's good we have a sound board here. It's safe. But hey, I'd someone is generalizing women, I don't care. I'm not dating them so it doesn't affect me.
  • pa_jorg
    pa_jorg Posts: 4,404 Member
    Oh, I totally get the venting thing... but sometimes it seems like more than that to me, but I could be wrong.
    Def venting... I don't think it's fair to assume all guys are cheaters like my ex was. I think it's good we have a sound board here. It's safe. But hey, I'd someone is generalizing women, I don't care. I'm not dating them so it doesn't affect me.

    It's interesting you say that... have you read the Cheaters thread from yesterday? It seems that several guys here assume all women ARE cheaters, and that does change how you are seen by them.
  • La_Amazona
    La_Amazona Posts: 4,855 Member
    No, they don't know me personally. It's a public forum.

    Some guys have said things about how they feel about women who give it up too fast or not fast enough. Again, doesn't affect me as I'm not dating them. If they walk around generalizing women, they're the ones being affected.
  • pa_jorg
    pa_jorg Posts: 4,404 Member
    No, they don't know me personally. It's a public forum.

    Some guys have said things about how they feel about women who give it up too fast or not fast enough. Again, doesn't affect me as I'm not dating them. If they walk around generalizing women, they're the ones being affected.

    I get your point about anyone here knowing you personally... But I think you are missing the fact that many people you encounter in your daily life have opinions that are similar to those in this Single Peeps microcosm.


    And I'm still wondering about my initial question - although venting may be the answer - but some of this seems deeper rooted than that to me at least.
    are these negative generalizations simply defense mechanisms to help someone justify or feel better about why they are still single?
  • julesboots
    julesboots Posts: 311 Member
    I think sometimes it is just venting, i.e. all men are dogs. Blah blah blah. I have said men suck, or other things but I really mean the men in my life. I think it comes from a place of pain for most people but there are those where it comes from a place of bias.



    I agree with your statement about those ideas coming from a place of pain (and bias-probably to a lesser degree).

    My last relationship was a good example :ex- wife sabotaged the relationship with infidelity, thus he was super suspicious of everything I did, and assumed everyone I knew was trying to sleep with me. It had nothing to do with me, but was like a lens of pain that he viewed all female actions through.

    He also assumed that my ex husband cheated on me though, so maybe it changed his entire schema related to relationships. Who knows, but it was hard.
  • MissingMinnesota
    MissingMinnesota Posts: 7,486 Member
    I get my hackles up reading some of the stuff, I will start typing a reply and then deleted it thinking "I feel sorry for them if they think all women/men are that way"
  • TheKitsune6
    TheKitsune6 Posts: 5,798 Member
    I get my hackles up reading some of the stuff, I will start typing a reply and then deleted it thinking "I feel sorry for them if they think all women/men are that way"

    Yeah, this.

    I generally avoid the boards that say "Do men like XYZ?" "Are women ABC?" because my answer is the same every single time.

    People are individuals. There is no one answer, no broad stroke of the brush that is going to make life easier if you just "understand" more.

    I do have my moments where I sulk and say "boys are stupid" but I don't hold on to that. I roll my eyes and move forward and the next person is a new experience.
  • farmers_daughter
    farmers_daughter Posts: 1,632 Member
    I agree that some of the posts are simply people having a place to release that pent up frustration with a situation that they were hurt in.
    However to assume all of that gender will do the same actions lays on thier own shoulders, they have chosen to hold onto that pain for whatever reason instead of learning from it and letting it go.

    If you can't learn from the sitation and move on, then you are only hurting yourself. Sometimes it takes a while to get thru the pain, and that is understandable, no matter what the relationship I feel like people should mourn/grieve it then move on, it's ok to cry. :)
    THat process isn't the same for everyone, so you have to be patient with others.

    I will also throw my two cents worth into the fire.... in that both parties in the relationship need to to take responsibility for it ending. Whether it was their fault or not. I know, bold statement but true.
  • julesboots
    julesboots Posts: 311 Member


    I will also throw my two cents worth into the fire.... in that both parties in the relationship need to to take responsibility for it ending. Whether it was their fault or not. I know, bold statement but true.

    Very wise; I totally agree.
  • VTXJOCKEY
    VTXJOCKEY Posts: 362 Member
    I just read the cheaters thread from yesterday. I'm keeping my thoughts and opinions to myself but find it interesting that none of the guys from that thread have anything to say on this thread. ???
  • DMZ_1
    DMZ_1 Posts: 2,889 Member
    I'll defend what I said in the Cheaters thread. I don't believe that I made broad, sweeping generalizations. When I write, I often use phrases like "more than likely" to get a point across to indicate something that is common but not universal. I try to use measured language.

    My first post on that thread involve links to outside articles about ratio of male to female cheaters. How many people read those articles?

    I also posted on why I think the early stage dating model is broken for both sexes.

    I did acknowledge validity in a statement about "cheaters and players". The word validity means that there is soundness. I felt that there was soundness to that one sentence, more in the fact of players than cheaters. Top tier women (20s, attractive, no children) can have a iPhone list of potential options that if printed out on paper, you'd be printing many sheets of paper. I would say that the typical woman has more options for boyfriends/sex than a comparable to her male. This fact allows women to be bigger players should they choose. If a woman decides to cheat, I think it easier to execute. But not all women will choose this course. Many times, when a woman breaks up, there's already another man in the picture (http://nyc.barstoolsports.com/random-thoughts/top-10-reasons-men-and-women-get-dumped/ ).

    Incidence of female cheating has risen in recent decades. The old standard was that the male was the serial philanderer. The linked articles at the top of that thread demonstrate that is no longer the case. Working outside the house and technology have fostered female cheating.

    I think it is important for all men to look for a woman who is reliable, dependable, and one who keeps her word.
  • Katefab26
    Katefab26 Posts: 865
    I think the point PJ is trying to make is more that people have been hurt by cheaters/liars/whatever, so they tend to make broad, sweeping generalizations about the opposite gender to either push the other gender away, thereby not hurting them to begin with, or to get themselves in a position where they just expect whoever they are dating is going to hurt them in some way, so when this expectation turns into a self-fulfilling prophecy, it won't hurt quite as much.

    I agree with PJ's assessment. So many people on here post about past relationships or are upset that they can't get into a meaningful relationship, but almost every post is dripping with bitterness toward the opposite gender. You are not going to attract a decent person when you have this mindset. We all really need to stop looking at the opposite gender as an enemy to be conquered and realize that although there are people who are just not worth the time or energy, there are many wonderful, kind people who really deserve your respect. Once you start treating the opposite gender with respect and looking for their positive qualities, you will lose that bitter overtone and allow yourself to open up enough to be loved, and to love in return.
  • pa_jorg
    pa_jorg Posts: 4,404 Member
    I think the point PJ is trying to make is more that people have been hurt by cheaters/liars/whatever, so they tend to make broad, sweeping generalizations about the opposite gender to either push the other gender away, thereby not hurting them to begin with, or to get themselves in a position where they just expect whoever they are dating is going to hurt them in some way, so when this expectation turns into a self-fulfilling prophecy, it won't hurt quite as much.

    I agree with PJ's assessment. So many people on here post about past relationships or are upset that they can't get into a meaningful relationship, but almost every post is dripping with bitterness toward the opposite gender. You are not going to attract a decent person when you have this mindset. We all really need to stop looking at the opposite gender as an enemy to be conquered and realize that although there are people who are just not worth the time or energy, there are many wonderful, kind people who really deserve your respect. Once you start treating the opposite gender with respect and looking for their positive qualities, you will lose that bitter overtone and allow yourself to open up enough to be loved, and to love in return.

    Kate, You said it much better than I did, but yes, that is exactly what I was trying to get at! Thank you! :flowerforyou:
  • DMZ_1
    DMZ_1 Posts: 2,889 Member
    We all really need to stop looking at the opposite gender as an enemy to be conquered and realize that although there are people who are just not worth the time or energy, there are many wonderful, kind people who really deserve your respect. Once you start treating the opposite gender with respect and looking for their positive qualities, you will lose that bitter overtone and allow yourself to open up enough to be loved, and to love in return.

    Those few sentences were quite moving. Yes, even I have feelings! :laugh: :blushing:
  • kerrymh
    kerrymh Posts: 912 Member
    I am not sure how I come off on the forums but I do hope I do not generalize men as all the same. If I do I apologize.
    My personal experiences in dating haven't been fantastic..but I blame that on my self esteem, my weight and being a little too naive. I picked the wrong people to date. That was my mistake. But I have a large family and many friends who are shining examples of the opposite sex and I hold out hope that I'll meet my match one day. I don't want to go into something anymore thinking about all the bad things that have happened in my past..I am cautious but hopeful now.
  • christine24t
    christine24t Posts: 6,063 Member
    I just read the cheaters thread from yesterday. I'm keeping my thoughts and opinions to myself but find it interesting that none of the guys from that thread have anything to say on this thread. ???

    Yes, very interesting. I never wanted to be so angry in the thread, but it was just such sweeping generalizations that I had to say something.
  • castadiva
    castadiva Posts: 2,016 Member
    We all really need to stop looking at the opposite gender as an enemy to be conquered and realize that although there are people who are just not worth the time or energy, there are many wonderful, kind people who really deserve your respect. Once you start treating the opposite gender with respect and looking for their positive qualities, you will lose that bitter overtone and allow yourself to open up enough to be loved, and to love in return.

    Beautifully said, Kate :flowerforyou: I think there's a difference between generalisations made from wider observation, generally introduced with measured language or vocabulary; tend to, seem to, a trend towards..., and generalisations that are born out of specific events and individual experiences within a narrow pool. It's very difficult to avoid the former when talking about the types of issues we discuss here. Gender/Sexual politics is inevitably going to throw up both. The latter probably are, in some degree, defense mechanisms and justifications. The former can be as well, but are generally less vituperative and take in a broader sphere of reference.
This discussion has been closed.