Hi Kristen!

I personally have had the best luck with longer sleeve coats at either New York and Company or JCPenney. My coat last year was only $75 and it is extremely long, a purple Worthington peacoat. I tried one on at NY and CO for $140 that I may go back and buy, they have ridiculous sales all of the time and I can probably get it for under $100 no problem with a sale.

I have a couple of awesomely warm winter coats from LL Bean.

I have this one in brown:

http://www.llbean.com/llb/shop/42359?feat=610-GN1&page=ultrawarm-coat-long

and this one in purple orchid:

http://www.llbean.com/llb/shop/70420?feat=610-GN1&page=mountain-laurel-down-jacket

I got them on clearance last February for cheaper than what is listed on the site. I had to get an XL because of my weight, and the sleeves are a bit on the long side, not that I mind. What I really like about both of them is that although they are down or puff filled, neither one makes me look fatter than I actually am, and the second one (the mountain laurel jacket) is nicely cut so that it is actually kind of flattering!

Another nice thing about the LL Bean site is that there are loads of reviews. One thing about the reviews: some people say that the warmth ratings are baloney, but the ratings are based on not only the outdoor temperature, but also what else you're wearing and what you're doing at the time. Here's what they say about the temperature range:

"Our comfort ranges are based on tests simulating a 28-year-old man of average build wearing appropriate layers. When a range is shown, the first temperature indicates the product's comfort rating during light to moderate activity, such as walking slowly. The second temperature indicates the comfort rating during moderate activity, such as jogging a short distance or snowshoeing. When selecting outerwear or footwear, please consider your personal response to cold, your activity level and local weather conditions."

I hope you find a jacket that you like!