Should I Change my Goal Weight?

I realized recently that my "goal weight" is less than my current lean body mass. Maybe that explains why I feel so much stronger now than I did when I was at that goal weight 27 years ago. I was "skinny-fat" then. Yet I still struggle with the concept of raising that goal, I've crunched the numbers, double checked them, and know that the goal is unrealistic unless I plan on loosing a lot of muscle along with fat. I'm just not sure what to set the new goal at. If I was able to keep my current lean body mass, and lose only fat, then I'd be in the "athlete" range of body fat % if I increased my goal weight by 25-39 pounds. To lose anymore would begin to lose "essential fat", which is not good. So why does the idea of changing my goal seem so unsettling for me? I don't need to lose as much as I thought... I know that my projections could change, as I will likely lose some muscle while I lose weight no matter how hard I may try to hang on to it, but still, I think its clear that my current goal weight is too low, but I am hesitant to change it anyway.

Replies

  • ThriceBlessed
    ThriceBlessed Posts: 499 Member
    Okay, for now I decided to change it by the lowest amount indicated by the numbers... so I added 25 pounds to my goal weight. So instead of 144 pounds I plan to try to reach 169 pounds. As I get closer to that range I'll continue checking my bodyfat percentage and adjust as needed.
  • kawookie
    kawookie Posts: 813 Member
    It sounds like you made a wise decision to me. You will look smaller at 169 pounds than you did last time you were down that low if it is mostly lean mass. No one but you will know how much you weigh; everyone will know how good you look. :drinker:
  • you should change your weight so your bodyfat % is at a "healthy" number...

    say.. 28%

    as you get closer to your goal weight and bodyfat% , if you work out, you will see your lean mass increase because of increased muscle mass. good choice raising your goal weight. bodyfat percentage is a much better number to measure your health by.
  • endoftheside
    endoftheside Posts: 568 Member
    I suspect that it will be difficult to lose only fat and no muscle, even eating ideally and strength training, but as long as you are keeping tabs on your body fat % you will be able to reassess based on what actually happens re: distribution of losses as you get closer to a potential goal weight.
  • 10manda86
    10manda86 Posts: 229 Member
    Hey, I just read a blog and used the calculator on it to set myself mini goals....
    Rather that rewriting ityou can view my blog, I have a link to the site I used on it...
    I plan on setting goal weights based on desired body fat composition without losing lean mass...

    http://www.myfitnesspal.com/blog/10manda86/view/setting-goals-604252

    Best of luck