Thank you for that.

Hopefully you are all taking progress pics as well. I know it's corny and I didn't take them back when I did P90X, but I'm taking them this time around and I see improvement between my week 1 and week 6 pics that I didn't see on the scale or in the mirror.

BTW Guitarguy. . . Fender or Gibson?

It didn't take us 60-90 days to get in the position we are in now, so we shouldn't expect the same on the reverse side. I remind myself of this simple fact every single day.

It's a lifestyle change and every day I feel better, stronger and have more energy. Slow and steady wins the race.

I totally agree in the keep going part, but keep going doesn't mean keep going with THIS exact thing.
Honestly I do not understand how is switching from one hard core program to an other can ever be considered quitting, wimping out or expecting instant results???

Tony constantly saying on every single workout, that you need to challenge YOURSELF. Do what works for YOU. If this means modifying movements, or even workouts so be it. For beginners it may means to use resistance bands instead of pullup bar. For more advanced people, this may means substitute P90X3 strength training workouts with harder iron pumping, or trade some cardio days for running for others. There is nothing wrong with any of that. It may happen that this particular program turn out not good fit for you, go try an other one, nothing is wrong with that either.

I am doing P90X3 , but I didn't buy it; my friend did. She did one week, she hated it, injured herself doing it, and gave it to me. As an exchange I gave her my collection of Jillian Michaels DVDs .Now she is happily working out for those DVD 5 times a week. It is nothing wrong with that! Exercising should be fun too. The best exercise what YOU actually like , because if you like it, you will keep doing it and it becomes a lifelong habit.
If it is p90x3 , that is great. If it is an other program, that is great too. Keep going ! on YOUR way!

I absolutely agree Redheadmommy, but I see a lot of people on this forum say "Its been four weeks..." and its important to not get discouraged, but have the correct mindset. Ive been doing this for TWO YEARS, and I still modify some movements, its just important for people to be realistic about their goals, capabilities, and honest with themselves.

My Mom always said she hated working out, I always encouraged her to try new things belly dance, zumba, yoga, walking, ANYTHING. Anything is better than nothing.
But I see people constantly say, "Oh this isn't working for me" and instead of switching to a different program, they slow down, and eventually quit. Everyone needs to do what makes them happy and healthy!

Well, P90x3 is not even 2 month old program, so nobody is doing it for 2 years In this group nobody talked about quitting their weight loss program altogether, only changing this particular workout program was discussed. Not the same thing!

I also think the fact the program is brand new is part of the discouragement. There is not a whole lot of experience with this particular program out there. Yes, there is the test-group and 9 or 10 before/after was released , but normal folks never going to have those ideal conditions as the test group had.

If you google any other beachbody program like T25,P90x, insanity etc you see thousands of before /after pictures from everyday joes with detailed description on what they did. P90x3 is new, and there is literally not a single normal( non-test group) person who ever finished the program yet. So when you do not see result, and keep reading the same thing from others both here and on the beachbody message board, of course you start to wonder. It is not a cult, people are allowed to question it.

There are a couple of people on my friend list who are doing lean schedule, and they are the only ones who really dropping the pounds doing P90x3. While the best result I have seen people following the classic is to see some definition. This making the schedule switch really appealing.

I meant doing P90X for two years. I saw people post the same thing about that program too.

That said, 30 minutes a day isn't a ton of calorie burning time. I would certainly encourage and extra 15-20 minutes of cardio for people using this program to really kill fat. For me, it's perfect, but I also spend 4+ hours running every week. I got skinny on the original P90X and Insanity, this stuff works. In fact, I still contend that a P90x/Insanity hybrid is the best way possible to get from flabby to fit in the beachbody catalogue. But, if you're short on time, I think P90X3 will get you a long way down the road, it's a good program.

I think you are right. I do believe the program is great to get fit, no question about that! It is just maybe the 30 minutes is not enough time by itself to burn enough calories. Especially the yoga and the dynamics day burns very little, and the strength training days also burn less than the cardio days. Again this maybe an other reason why the lean is more suitable for people aiming for more fat loss.

I think the other problem is that the nutrition guideline suggestions are way too generous in term of calories for a 30 minutes program. I am 206 lb ( started the program at 204 lb) female, want to lose weight. The nutrition guide suggests plan D (2400 calorie) for over 200 lb , and plan C( 2100 cal) for under 200 lb. Since i am close to the cut-off, I picked the lower one and set my calorie goal to 2100, but I think it is still too much to lose the fat. The difference between female and male in the P90x3 nutrition guide is only one point, which translate to 300 calorie difference. I think the difference in calorie expenditure is way more than 300 cals between a man and a women at the same weight.

Anyway, I started transition week, and I lowered my calories with 100 cal , and in 2 weeks I re-evaluate again. I maybe lower an other 100 calorie if there is still no weight loss.