Carbs and Weight Loss Q

Options
threeohtwo
threeohtwo Posts: 153 Member
Ok lady friends,
Quick question for you. I've read some of the previous posts so I've got an idea but wanted some help.

I've got classic PCOS. Increased body hair, trouble losing weight, all belly fat, blah blah blah :) For the last month I've been busting my booty running. Ran my first 5K became super active, kept within my calorie budget and I've GAINED 3 pounds. I'd like to say it's increased muscle but its not. I think I've been eating too many carbs. I got put on 1500 mg of Met and I'm working my way up to the full dose. I'm thinking of dropping my carbs to 108 or 25%.

QUESTION:
How many of you ladies noticed an increase in weight loss when you dropped your carb intake? Will 100 be sufficient? I was probably eating double that daily.

Thanks so much. Trying to not get discouraged but it's so hard!

Replies

  • teddiebare
    teddiebare Posts: 46 Member
    Options
    I lost 58 pounds, and then last year started steadily re-gaining weight. Nothing changed. I was more active, and ate even better - I ended up gaining like 16 of it back in about 10 months. I FINALLY got my PCOS diagnosis in December, and started with a specialist in January.

    I was eating 1775 calories and 150g of carbs, and was GAINING
    I now eat 1775 calories and <50g of carbs and I've lost 18 lbs since January.

    My doctor recommended <50g of carbs, 100g of protein (moderate) and the rest in fat. He's not so concerned about calories, but I adjust it to like 1600 + some exercise about a week ago. Every body is different, and it's definitely worth experimenting with, but I have to eat much lower carbs in order to see consistent weight loss. And even then it's slower than what a "normal" person would see. I can only stomach 1000mg of Metformin a day, but my doc is OK with that.
  • Alliwan
    Alliwan Posts: 1,245 Member
    Options
    Everyone is different and it will take some time to find the 'sweet spot' for your weight loss.

    There are some PCOS women who can do a Low GI diet, meaning higher level of carbs but they are from whole grains paired with protein and fat to help slow the digestion of said carbs and prevent a blood sugar spike. Many of us cant do that, as we gain weight with a higher carb amount, whether or not its paired with protein and fats. So many of us have to do a low carb diet, and that is different for each person too. My low carb also has to be below about 50g net a day for me to lose weight, but for some, they can go as high as 100g of carbs a day and still lose. I also take 1000mg of metformin a day right now, so too high of a carb limit and it lets me know.

    You really have to tweak things till they are right for you, your weight loss goals and your lifestyle. It is a 'diet' you'd have to be ok with doing pretty much for the rest of your life, as PCOS doesnt go away. BUT weight loss and a healthier lifestyle can be achieved even with PCOS, it just takes more time than non-pcos women and takes you knowing your body and how it reacts to carbs and other lifestyle changes.
  • smbsantacruz
    smbsantacruz Posts: 4 Member
    Options
    I can totally empathize! I did Weight Watchers for six months, was RELIGIOUS about my points and exercising regularly, and only gained weight. It wasn't until I was diagnosed, on Metformin and averaging 100g carbs/day that I started losing. That formula gave me a solid 2 pound/week weight loss ... I'm sure if I exercised I could get more.

    Interestingly, I went off my medications for about a month and started eating high carb again (well, moderately high carb) ... and still managed to lose 3 lbs.

    I think it's the focus on low carb that does it, honestly. Try it and see.
  • moreradthancrack
    moreradthancrack Posts: 1 Member
    Options
    The only time I didn't have "issues" losing weight was when I cut calories to be under 1600, cut carbs big time, and exercised. Right now I am doing Atkins as my doctor recommended along with starting Metformin. I started Atkins Induction almost two weeks ago and I have lost ~6 pounds. Its not a stellar amount, but something is better than nothing. The only thing we PCOSers can do is keep up our good work and wait.
  • astylla
    astylla Posts: 118 Member
    Options
    I lost about 18 lbs last year before I let myself back into bad habits. I've been back on MFP for 18 days now and some days I let my carbs go a bit high to 150+ then remembered..I did so well keeping under 100 most days that I tailored my goals. I did that about a week ago and have noticed the pounds are melting off and more importantly the inches are ! I now eat very few processed foods. My normal intake is high protein/complex carbs and have eliminated any bread or white starchy carbs for the most part.

    It has made my energy level go through the roof. I personally try using high protein every meal like greek plain yogurt , tuna fish , peanut butter ( if you like it) , chicken ,lean ground turkey , black beans , shrimp just for a few ideas,

    I'm not perfect..had a few fast food meals (Taco bell) but still stayed within my calorie range and didn't let it conquer me.
    I allow myself organic frozen yogurt once a week before my carpal tunnel therapy appointment but I also take the long way to get there and back so I get some extra exercise in.

    Like others said tweaking things will be key but you can do it !
  • madambutterfly91
    madambutterfly91 Posts: 31 Member
    Options
    Everyone is different so be patient as you figure out what your body needs. If you aren't already you should probably talk to a dietitian if not IRL at least friend on on here for questions like this. I know when I was getting started with the low carb thing one of the ones on here said 30-35% is probably a better range because if you go to low your brain starts to starve. Just make sure you are going with the more complex carbs because when they process them they take out the major part that slows your digestion of them so it's practically like eating straight sugar. Both of the ladies I've talked to also advocate more whole foods and making stuff yourself. The preservatives and other crap they stick in the processed foods are particularly hard for PCOS. Not to mention most of the processed foods that I can find are way high in crappy carbs and not worth it.
    Good luck. :happy:
  • Cocotrendy
    Cocotrendy Posts: 20 Member
    Options
    Wow! I am so glad I found this group. I was diagnosed with PCOS about 11 years ago. I never really paid it any attention and just resigned myself to the fact that my husband and I would never have any children, and I am okay with that. I will be 50 years old in November and am really making an effort to lose weight because I want to be heathier. Reading all the information here has really opened my eyes and explained so much for me.

    I have gained the weight around the middle and have thinniing hair. Cycles have always been crazy and now, I am almost menopausal. I really have nothing to add but just wanted to say thank you....I am not crazy. I could never put my finger on what the issue was for me and now I can. I can learn some things and make the necessary changes to have the healthy lifestyle that I want. You guys rock!
  • Cocotrendy
    Cocotrendy Posts: 20 Member
    Options
    How does one focus on low carbs? What are good carbs to eat?
  • melodymedlin
    melodymedlin Posts: 254 Member
    Options
    As someone else stated no two people are alike. I was eating around 150 + carbs daily and was staying the same weight. My doctor recommended an Atkin's related carb goal. (google Atkins) anywho I tried the stricter version of Atkin's last month and did okay but found it wasn't completely with my liking. After tweaking things to my way I've found staying under 40g of Carbs per day is ideal. I've managed to loose 11lbs and 15" in 7wks. Yes it took work and yes some days were harder than others but its works for me. My best advice is to start cutting carbs where you feel comfy. Even dropping them by 50g a day will make a difference. :) Good luck and you've got this!!!!!
  • Dragonwolf
    Dragonwolf Posts: 5,600 Member
    Options
    How does one focus on low carbs? What are good carbs to eat?

    You focus on low carbs by basing your meals around protein and fats. Good carbs are the ones that come primarily from non-starchy vegetables and, in moderation, fruit (especially berries, which are lower in sugar than most fruits). Some can do whole grain products, though they tend to be pretty carb-heavy and there's a high cross over between PCOS and gluten sensitivity.

    So, your meals would look something like this: a 4oz ribeye steak with buttered asparagus and a salad with avocado, sunflower seeds, mixed greens, carrots, and oil and vinegar dressing.

    If you're used to a low-fat diet, it probably seems like heart attack on a plate, but I assure you, it's not. Fats aren't bad. They don't make you gain weight and they don't clog your arteries. In fact, decreasing your carbs, and increasing your fat can actually reduce your risk for heart disease. This is because it's carbs that raise triglycerides, not fat.

    When you decrease your carbs, you must provide your body with another source of fuel. Most people, thanks to the anti-fat propaganda, mistakenly turn to protein, but that's a dangerous misconception. Low carb and low fat deprives the body of nutrients and fuel that it needs, and the act of converting protein to a usable fuel is hard on the liver and kidneys, especially if it's doing it full time. Therefore, if you're decreasing your carbs, that leaves one fuel source -- fat.

    Additionally, the fats in the above meal aren't just fat, but also essential vitamins. High-quality animal fats are actually a mix of fats (not just saturated), and are also high in vitamins such as B, D, and K.
  • melodymedlin
    melodymedlin Posts: 254 Member
    Options
    How does one focus on low carbs? What are good carbs to eat?

    You focus on low carbs by basing your meals around protein and fats. Good carbs are the ones that come primarily from non-starchy vegetables and, in moderation, fruit (especially berries, which are lower in sugar than most fruits). Some can do whole grain products, though they tend to be pretty carb-heavy and there's a high cross over between PCOS and gluten sensitivity.

    So, your meals would look something like this: a 4oz ribeye steak with buttered asparagus and a salad with avocado, sunflower seeds, mixed greens, carrots, and oil and vinegar dressing.

    If you're used to a low-fat diet, it probably seems like heart attack on a plate, but I assure you, it's not. Fats aren't bad. They don't make you gain weight and they don't clog your arteries. In fact, decreasing your carbs, and increasing your fat can actually reduce your risk for heart disease. This is because it's carbs that raise triglycerides, not fat.

    When you decrease your carbs, you must provide your body with another source of fuel. Most people, thanks to the anti-fat propaganda, mistakenly turn to protein, but that's a dangerous misconception. Low carb and low fat deprives the body of nutrients and fuel that it needs, and the act of converting protein to a usable fuel is hard on the liver and kidneys, especially if it's doing it full time. Therefore, if you're decreasing your carbs, that leaves one fuel source -- fat.

    Additionally, the fats in the above meal aren't just fat, but also essential vitamins. High-quality animal fats are actually a mix of fats (not just saturated), and are also high in vitamins such as B, D, and K.



    ^^^^^love this because its the truth! My cholesterol went from 234 to 126 in 7wks just by cutting carbs and increasing fat. Most days I try to keep protein under fat level as well! ;)
  • Cocotrendy
    Cocotrendy Posts: 20 Member
    Options
    How does one focus on low carbs? What are good carbs to eat?

    You focus on low carbs by basing your meals around protein and fats. Good carbs are the ones that come primarily from non-starchy vegetables and, in moderation, fruit (especially berries, which are lower in sugar than most fruits). Some can do whole grain products, though they tend to be pretty carb-heavy and there's a high cross over between PCOS and gluten sensitivity.

    So, your meals would look something like this: a 4oz ribeye steak with buttered asparagus and a salad with avocado, sunflower seeds, mixed greens, carrots, and oil and vinegar dressing.

    If you're used to a low-fat diet, it probably seems like heart attack on a plate, but I assure you, it's not. Fats aren't bad. They don't make you gain weight and they don't clog your arteries. In fact, decreasing your carbs, and increasing your fat can actually reduce your risk for heart disease. This is because it's carbs that raise triglycerides, not fat.

    When you decrease your carbs, you must provide your body with another source of fuel. Most people, thanks to the anti-fat propaganda, mistakenly turn to protein, but that's a dangerous misconception. Low carb and low fat deprives the body of nutrients and fuel that it needs, and the act of converting protein to a usable fuel is hard on the liver and kidneys, especially if it's doing it full time. Therefore, if you're decreasing your carbs, that leaves one fuel source -- fat.

    Additionally, the fats in the above meal aren't just fat, but also essential vitamins. High-quality animal fats are actually a mix of fats (not just saturated), and are also high in vitamins such as B, D, and K.

    Thank you for this information. I am pretty clueless when it comes to eating the right foods, hence, the weight gain. But this info is great.
  • apriljackss
    apriljackss Posts: 96 Member
    Options
    I feel like no one ever really wants to hear this but the only way that I've been able to lose weight, reduce acne, and regain somewhat of a normal cycle is by going gluten and dairy free. I do try to minimize carbs but I don't focus on the number of carbs so much as making sure that if I do eat carbs, I accompany them with an equivalent amount of fat or protein to slow absorption. Granted, I eliminated a lot of refined carbs from my diet when I eliminated gluten, so that's part of it, but I can't go with out my daily dose of dark chocolate either :)


    (edited for spelling)
  • macchiatto
    macchiatto Posts: 2,890 Member
    Options
    I've had PCOS for years. I have done a lot of yoyo-ing weight-wise. 2.5 years ago I got a prediabetes Dx. (I have a major family history of it.) At the time my BMI was about 23-24, so I wasn't even technically overweight. I do have a small bone structure and my body fat percentage was probably in the "overweight' category (33-35% or so). At that time, I really struggled to lose weight. I finally had to go lower-carb (around 75-100 gm/day) and lost about 12 lbs. I managed to reverse the prediabetes. Since then I have lost another 7-8 lbs. it seems like now I can get away with eating 100-120 gm carbs/day and still lose weight. I also try to eat around 100-110 gm protein/day and fat is around 60-70 gm/day. It seems like as I have lost more weight, I've been able to gradually increase my carb intake and still do OK but I had to get fairly thin to get to that point.