We are pleased to announce that on March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor will be introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the upcoming changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!
Do you eat your calories from exercise?
AmIhealthyyet
Posts: 361 Member
Okay friends! Please help me decide if I should, or shouldn't, eat the calories I gain from exercise. I am not talking about my daily activity that burns things, I am talking about my work outs! Just want to know what is working or not working for others! Thank you!!
0
Replies
-
I have always eaten my cals back and I have lost about 40 pounds. I say go for it!0
-
I did NOT eat my calories back when losing weight. (I now don't log so I have no idea).
I DID eat to satiety but noticed my caloric intake was no where near the amount if I had added back calories back in.
I tried to explicitly eat high protein and add some fat and that helped tremendously with my workouts and my satiety.0 -
I eat if I'm hungry, If not I don't .0
-
Just starting paleo, so I have been counting calories since Christmas. Lost little until I stopped eating back my exercise calories. I think I probably underestimated what I was taking in, though.0
-
I eat if I'm hungry, If not I don't .
For me I am not to that point, I eat regardless and feel the need to count! Would love to become normal and JUST eat when I need to!0 -
This question came up on the MFP facebook page and someone from the MFP team (and by this I don't mean a user) but someone actually from MFP explained the importance of eating your workout calories to prevent your body from going into starvation mode and hanging on to fat. I am not an expert but my experience has been that if I am working out a lot or at high intensity and I don't eat back most of those calories, I don't lose weight plus I feel really tired and sluggish making it harder and harder to workout.
I think I am like you in that I can't go entirely on whether I'm hungry or not. I'm not quite there yet (although well on my way I think)! As a general rule I eat back most or at least some of my workout calories. Don't forget your body needs these nutrients to recover after a workout.
Anyone else agree?0 -
I believe in Calorie Cycling. I think that above all else will keep your metabolism "guessing" and working high. So one day I might eat 2000 cals, the next day only 900, the day after that 1500 etc. At the moment I am letting how I feel determine what kind of caloric day I'm going to have, but if weight loss stalls I will do serious calorie cycling using a plan.0
-
I do kind of cycle, go for an average over the week as opposed to the daily totals. I do appreciate everyone helps. I do eat a big protien meal after my work outs but struggle to find a 'perfect' system. Haha like there really is one . It makes me nervous to eat more just because I burned 500 calories in a work out.0
-
This question came up on the MFP facebook page and someone from the MFP team (and by this I don't mean a user) but someone actually from MFP explained the importance of eating your workout calories to prevent your body from going into starvation mode and hanging on to fat. I am not an expert but my experience has been that if I am working out a lot or at high intensity and I don't eat back most of those calories, I don't lose weight plus I feel really tired and sluggish making it harder and harder to workout.
I think I am like you in that I can't go entirely on whether I'm hungry or not. I'm not quite there yet (although well on my way I think)! As a general rule I eat back most or at least some of my workout calories. Don't forget your body needs these nutrients to recover after a workout.
Anyone else agree?
I did just get a heart rate monitor that also counts calories so I think it will help me keep better track of things. I think I will also start logging my food to see if that helps me.0 -
I don't right now, BUT that's because I set my calorie goal to maintenance for now. Being short and lazy, my TDEE is only about 1560ish, so I needed a break from eating at a deficit since I haven't been working out to earn more calories. I used to eat my workout calories routinely though, for the reasons outlined above. It helped me feel stronger, and I never once hit a plateau or felt like I was getting deprived or unhealthy.0
-
I always gain weight back if I eat my exercise calories back and when I don't I lose. I try to keep it above 1200 calories at a minimum net. Hope that helps. Of course I can't eat beef, dairy from a cow, drink alcohol because I am allergic and bread products make me sick so I don't really have problems eating this way if I am behaving myself.0
-
if you are going over your range on a regular basis by eating those calories i would think differently, but if you are not going over, and your hungry, eat those calories back, but i don't believe you have to even when your not hungry. i didn't intend that to come off as talking about eating in general, just when considering eating those earned calories, so i am sorry if that came off as dismissive.I eat if I'm hungry, If not I don't .
For me I am not to that point, I eat regardless and feel the need to count! Would love to become normal and JUST eat when I need to!0 -
[/quote]if you are going over your range on a regular basis by eating those calories i would think differently, but if you are not going over, and your hungry, eat those calories back, but i don't believe you have to even when your not hungry. i didn't intend that to come off as talking about eating in general, just when considering eating those earned calories, so i am sorry if that came off as dismissive.
[/quote]
That does help,mic I am HUNGRY and want some healthy protien I should go for it, but not have those "extra's just to eat them!0 -
if you are going over your range on a regular basis by eating those calories i would think differently, but if you are not going over, and your hungry, eat those calories back, but i don't believe you have to even when your not hungry. i didn't intend that to come off as talking about eating in general, just when considering eating those earned calories, so i am sorry if that came off as dismissive.
[/quote]
That does help,mic I am HUNGRY and want some healthy protien I should go for it, but not have those "extra's just to eat them!
[/quote]yes0 -
I don't make it a point to eat back my calories. If I find I'm hungry for them, I'll eat but I don't force myself to eat them back. I've had incredibly active days where I've netted negative calories, but I wasn't hungry.0
This discussion has been closed.