Yoga history - what is yoga?

Options
hi all! I don't mind discussing the history of yoga and hope to find out more from your perspectives, using historical documentation, to discuss what exactly yoga is and where it came from.

I believe that yoga is a great physical exercise, and when paired with mindfulness of the postures, an excellent low impact exercise that can be used to gently instruct and rehabilitate with.

here's my research. If you wish to use any of this research please make sure to credit teresa buckman.


The history of yoga, major teachers, theories, chronology by Yogini Teresa Buckman

The earliest documentation of yoga
In the practice of Indian yoga, teachers passed down meditations based loosely on sitting postures (asanas) and breathing exercises documented to the 2nd C. Clearly, five sitting postures (asanas) are listed. Yoga Sutra poetry, the basis for meditation in Hindu spiritual meditation, instructs students on the use of breathing, chanting the poetry, while in a seated asana.# This is clearly not the yoga of the Modern age.

Yoga in the Middle Ages
Pradipika created a 14th C. Hatha yoga manual, documenting some simple asanas in a seated position. Fifteen seated variations expanded on the 2nd Century poetry of the Yoga Sutra. # This was the same time that Hindu temple dancing became a popular form of entertainment in Indian courts, later outlawed once the British ruled due to the deteriorated state of such “spiritual“ practices.# This method of merging the physical and the mental exercises to control the “five impulses” of the body are the closest thing to modern day yoga I can document. The temple dancers, devadasis, practiced postures (karanas) to express their worship to their gods and their own urges. The karanas were gracefully complex and required years of practice to expertly flow into and out of. Originally, the karanas were simple, but modern day dancers who revitalized Indian dance culture created extremely large range of motion balances and postures that yoga for exercise adopted by the late 20th C. Such practice is known as Natyam yoga. #

Earliest documentation of Modern day yoga postures
The Chinese martial arts of the Wutang Kung fu system (and later Zen Buddhist systems) have clearly been documented to 4000 years ago using physical and meditative exercises to increase strength and range of motion, unlike Indian yoga which is documented to the 20th C.# Kung fu postures expand and included postures no yoga master from India ever performed until the 20th C. Splits, backbends, large and powerful stances were commonly trained and were the height of a master of Ch'i Kung's repetoire, something kungfu training demanded for health to round out the high impact training of the martial art. Funny enough, 11th C. kung fu has stances, postures and circle walking footwork eerily similar to 11th C. Hindu temple dancers. #

It is clearly documented that Modern yoga stems from 700 year old Hatha yoga sitting asanas and breathing meditations that were altered in the 20th C. to include influences of kung fu, British acrobatics, and Hindu dance postures (karanas).

With the new India ruling itself independent of its colonial oppressor, a revitalization of its native arts blossomed. Yoga lineages of hatha, ashtanga, and natyam were further divided as masters appeared out of nowhere. In order to promote the yoga, schools and competitions were encouraged. The top lineages suddenly created postures and exercises never before documented in order to compete and win at these new sport yoga competitions.

Yogi Bikram believes that the best way to train the body for large postures is to practice in an environment that is as hot as the body. Suppleness and strength with bodily control is his goal for his disciples, and he created a primary and secondary series that all practitioners world wide follow to this day. # Bikram won many yoga competitions in the middle of the 20th C. and greatly influenced Modern yoga practice with extreme range of motion postures that go far beyond functional range of motion needs. He does encourage complete control and a good foundation of strength in all aspects of his students' practice.

Ashtanga vinyasa yoga was created by Pattabi Jois, a young man who was educated by a British gymnastics coach which played a huge role in the creation of the first, second and third series in Ashtanga practice. Similar to the focus of mental exercise in natyam yoga, ashtanga also focuses on intense upper body strength and dynamic flow to generate strength and fitness.# This school of yoga is the first lineage to incorporate backward bending and rolling in the flow of the vinyasas.

Devoid of locking and strenuous tensions in the body, Hatha yoga focuses on emptying the mind while breathing and releasing muscle tension. The basic asanas concentrate on opening up the pelvic region while sitting or laying down. This yoga is documented to the 11th C. Buddhist text Vimalaprabha, and Indian Yogi Swatmarama made it popular in the 15th C. # As the oldest and most "Indian" yoga, Hatha has developed into many lineages and styles, yet the main focus of traditional Hatha yoga is to always passively stretch, never actively stretch.


# http://www.yogajournal.com/wisdom/466

http://www.ashtangayoga.info/philosophy/

# http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qigong_history

#http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Devadasi#Ancient_and_medieval_history

Sifu I-Shih, lineage disciple of of orthodox wutang pa kua chang - Chinese Wutang kung fu and ch’I kung

Dan Miller of Plum Flower Press and the pa kua chang journal

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baduanjin_qigong

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apsara

# http://www.yogajournal.com/wisdom/2208

# http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Devadasi

# http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bharata_Natyam

# http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bikram_Yoga

http://bikramyoga.com/

# http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ashtanga_Vinyasa_Yoga

http://www.ashtanga-yoga-canada.com/ashtanga-yoga-postures.html

# http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hatha_yoga

http://www.abc-of-yoga.com/styles-of-yoga/hatha-yoga.asp

Replies

  • MonkeeBob
    Options
    that was pretty interesting to read, thanks :flowerforyou:
  • yoginimary
    yoginimary Posts: 6,783 Member
    Options
    I would include Patanjali and his "Yoga Sutras" as a major player in yogic history.

    Also Krishnamacharya should be included, the teacher of Pattabhi Jois, BKS Iyenagar, Desikachar, and Nedra Devi - Jois and Iyengar who developed Ashtanga and Iyengar yoga and Desikachar who inspired others to start Viniyoga.
  • verptwerp
    verptwerp Posts: 3,659 Member
    Options
    Bumping ..... have to get to work, will read later ..... thanks !
  • busywaterbending
    busywaterbending Posts: 844 Member
    Options
    I would include Patanjali and his "Yoga Sutras" as a major player in yogic history.

    hmm, yogini mary, I see Patanjali as the teacher of a part of Hindu religion, not as a contributor of Modern Yoga.

    How do you see him as a contributor? I mean, females did not do modern yoga or even spiritual exercises of sutras and asanas because the Hindu religions teach that asanas were for men only! The earliest type of yoga that females performed were the hindu temple dances. And that is clearly dance and art in a religious ritual, not what we consider Modern yoga...

    you have me confused as to what you mean about Patanjali. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yoga_Sutras_of_Patanjali his yoga is about achieving spiritual states in a religious practice while in a seated asana, not in a disciplined physical exercise to unite the mind and body. I thought the (Patanjali) 2 BCE Sutras were used to eliminate thinking about the body at all, and completely freeing the spirit by eliminating all thought and mindfulness? with bodily stillness?
  • busywaterbending
    busywaterbending Posts: 844 Member
    Options

    Also Krishnamacharya should be included, the teacher of Pattabhi Jois, BKS Iyenagar, Desikachar, and Nedra Devi - Jois and Iyengar who developed Ashtanga and Iyengar yoga and Desikachar who inspired others to start Viniyoga.

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tirumalai_Krishnamacharya#Approach_to_yoga

    no doubt that Krishnamacharya contributed to the creation of modern day yoga with keeping meditations linked to the new postures! I do have to say that he was pretty traditional about keeping to the main hatha yoga sitting asanas. He didn't get into the handstands until mid 20th century, when the Modern Yoga craze and competitions took off.
  • yoginimary
    yoginimary Posts: 6,783 Member
    Options
    I would include Patanjali and his "Yoga Sutras" as a major player in yogic history.

    hmm, yogini mary, I see Patanjali as the teacher of a part of Hindu religion, not as a contributor of Modern Yoga.

    How do you see him as a contributor? I mean, females did not do modern yoga or even spiritual exercises of sutras and asanas because the Hindu religions teach that asanas were for men only! The earliest type of yoga that females performed were the hindu temple dances. And that is clearly dance and art in a religious ritual, not what we consider Modern yoga...

    you have me confused as to what you mean about Patanjali. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yoga_Sutras_of_Patanjali his yoga is about achieving spiritual states in a religious practice while in a seated asana, not in a disciplined physical exercise to unite the mind and body. I thought the (Patanjali) 2 BCE Sutras were used to eliminate thinking about the body at all, and completely freeing the spirit by eliminating all thought and mindfulness? with bodily stillness?

    I refer to him because of the Sutras - the philosophical component to yoga. Most serious practitioners I know study the sutras at some level. Even if it's just to refer to the yama and niyama (stuff like non-harming, non-stealing, cleanliness, etc.).
  • yoginimary
    yoginimary Posts: 6,783 Member
    Options

    Also Krishnamacharya should be included, the teacher of Pattabhi Jois, BKS Iyenagar, Desikachar, and Nedra Devi - Jois and Iyengar who developed Ashtanga and Iyengar yoga and Desikachar who inspired others to start Viniyoga.

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tirumalai_Krishnamacharya#Approach_to_yoga

    no doubt that Krishnamacharya contributed to the creation of modern day yoga with keeping meditations linked to the new postures! I do have to say that he was pretty traditional about keeping to the main hatha yoga sitting asanas. He didn't get into the handstands until mid 20th century, when the Modern Yoga craze and competitions took off.

    We'll have to disagree here. Krishnamacharya taught Iyengar and Jois - who, through their students and themselves, brought yoga to the west. Krishnamacharya taught plenty of non-sitting asana - there is video proof from the 1930s (mostly of Iyengar). While handstand isn't in there, there are sun salutations and plenty of stuff still done today. Even your first reference, credits Krishnamacharya quite a bit.
  • busywaterbending
    busywaterbending Posts: 844 Member
    Options
    mary,

    oh. I see where you are coming from. Yes, modern yoga is documented to the 1920s. As for the sutras, I personally see those meditations as a Hindu practice.

    There seems to be two types of yoga: the spiritual practice of Modern Yoga, and the exercise practice of Modern Yoga (with mindfulness occasionally thrown in). I'm leaning towards the exercise practice Modern Yoga in my discussions and research of yoga. That's why I don't focus on the two influences that you speak of.

    :ohwell:
  • pedraz
    pedraz Posts: 173
    Options
    Bump er baby
  • yoginimary
    yoginimary Posts: 6,783 Member
    Options
    mary,

    oh. I see where you are coming from. Yes, modern yoga is documented to the 1920s. As for the sutras, I personally see those meditations as a Hindu practice.

    There seems to be two types of yoga: the spiritual practice of Modern Yoga, and the exercise practice of Modern Yoga (with mindfulness occasionally thrown in). I'm leaning towards the exercise practice Modern Yoga in my discussions and research of yoga. That's why I don't focus on the two influences that you speak of.

    :ohwell:

    As far as the Sutras go: Hindus and yogis are separate, though they share some of the same text. Think of Jews, Muslims, and Christians - they share some of the same texts but they are different philosophies/religions.

    I'm curious, if you are only interested in the physical practice, why are you researching the history?
  • busywaterbending
    busywaterbending Posts: 844 Member
    Options
    mary,
    because 90% of what people consider yoga is exercise not spiritual. Like I said, it's a history of Modern age Yoga, which is a practice for exercise not spiritual ritual.

    Even Yoga Journal agrees that there are two distinctions in what many consider yoga practice; one for exercise, the other for spiritual/religion.