Ammonia Smell

fallonrhea
fallonrhea Posts: 388 Member
Hey guys,

Lately I've been eating between 1600-1800 calories a day (according to my BMF I'm between a 300-500 calorie deficit) while doing P90X2 and supplemental cardio. I'm following the macros 25% carbs, 50% protein, and 25% fat, as suggested by the P90X2 diet guide. This allows me to hit the minimum fat and protein requirements that you guys suggest. Although admittedly, I usually end up eating closer to 30% carbs by the end of the day to get rid of this ammonia smell I've been getting.

After I work out I've been smelling ammonia. Now I know this is because the nitrogen is getting stripped off amino acids when my body is using them for energy - but does this necessarily mean that I'm burning lean muscle instead of fat?

Admittedly, I haven't been drinking enough water the past two days which I know can play a role in this. But I'm pretty concerned.

I'm retaining water right now due to my cycle and the fact I haven't been drinking enough, but yesterday I weighed in at 125.8 (gained some on my vacation apparently) if that's necessary information.

Thank you!

Edited to include:
The ammonia smell is something I experience when I breathe out through my nose. I've heard of people smelling like ammonia through their sweat - but I don't think I have that problem...I hope, haha!

Replies

  • SideSteel
    SideSteel Posts: 11,068 Member
    Entirely opinion:

    This answer might not satisfy you, but oxidizing protein for fuel is not necessarily the same as losing muscle mass.

    That being said, moving some protein to carbohydrate could (in theory) help this. Your CHO intake is rather low and your protein intake is very high (way more than you need but this isn't necessarily a bad thing if it meets your preferences). I would expect that this is contributing to the problem.

    (At some point when CHO gets low and protein gets high, you oxidize more protein for fuel)
  • darkguardian419
    darkguardian419 Posts: 1,302 Member
    Do you work out before your first meal of the day?

    Being that you're eating around 135g of carbs a day (1800 cal, 30%=540/4 cal per G = 135G) throughout the night and into your workout you may be burning off the carbs/glycogen and be in the beginning stages of ketosis [not a bad thing]. An ammonia smell, and/or a fruity breath smell are common from this type of thing.

    But, that's the first thing that came to mind... it might be a concentration due to not enough water, and maybe increased salt... and could be worse if it's your ToM.

    ETA: For safety reasons, if you're diabetic, ketosis = ketoacidosis (mostly) and can be deadly.
  • SideSteel
    SideSteel Posts: 11,068 Member
    Do you work out before your first meal of the day?

    Being that you're eating around 135g of carbs a day (1800 cal, 30%=540/4 cal per G = 135G) throughout the night and into your workout you may be burning off the carbs/glycogen and be in the beginning stages of ketosis [not a bad thing]. An ammonia smell, and/or a fruity breath smell are common from this type of thing.

    But, that's the first thing that came to mind... it might be a concentration due to not enough water, and maybe increased salt... and could be worse if it's your ToM.

    ETA: For safety reasons, if you're diabetic, ketosis = ketoacidosis (mostly) and can be deadly.

    Regarding the above and my previous reply, Lyle makes mention of it here:
    http://www.bodyrecomposition.com/fat-loss/ammonia-smell-during-exercise-on-ketogenic-diet-qa.html
  • nexangelus
    nexangelus Posts: 2,080 Member
    Oooh, I thought this was normal, as in sweat smells like ammonia after a bit anyway...hmmm...Mine always seems to and my carb levels are not that low. Or maybe they are? Oops!
  • SideSteel
    SideSteel Posts: 11,068 Member
    Oooh, I thought this was normal, as in sweat smells like ammonia after a bit anyway...hmmm...Mine always seems to and my carb levels are not that low. Or maybe they are? Oops!

    Yours don't look that low to me.

    I'm not convinced that the ammonia smell is cause for concern, but that's somewhat uneducated opinion on my part. I've not looked into it much. At the surface though, I don't see why it's cause for immediate concern.

    I'll look into it a bit more and see what I can find.
  • fallonrhea
    fallonrhea Posts: 388 Member
    Entirely opinion:

    This answer might not satisfy you, but oxidizing protein for fuel is not necessarily the same as losing muscle mass.

    Okay, cool. That's what I wanted to make sure. I didn't think oxidizing protein for fuel necessarily meant I was losing muscle mass...but my fiance read a bunch of crap on the internet and was trying to convince me otherwise this morning.
  • fallonrhea
    fallonrhea Posts: 388 Member
    Do you work out before your first meal of the day?

    Being that you're eating around 135g of carbs a day (1800 cal, 30%=540/4 cal per G = 135G) throughout the night and into your workout you may be burning off the carbs/glycogen and be in the beginning stages of ketosis [not a bad thing]. An ammonia smell, and/or a fruity breath smell are common from this type of thing.

    But, that's the first thing that came to mind... it might be a concentration due to not enough water, and maybe increased salt... and could be worse if it's your ToM.

    ETA: For safety reasons, if you're diabetic, ketosis = ketoacidosis (mostly) and can be deadly.

    No, I don't :-/ I usually workout around 6 pm or so. By then I've only consumed probably around 85 g of carbs throughout the day though

    I'll also clarify I almost never make 1800 calories. The average is closer to 1700. :).
  • SideSteel
    SideSteel Posts: 11,068 Member
    Entirely opinion:

    This answer might not satisfy you, but oxidizing protein for fuel is not necessarily the same as losing muscle mass.

    Okay, cool. That's what I wanted to make sure. I didn't think oxidizing protein for fuel necessarily meant I was losing muscle mass...but my fiance read a bunch of crap on the internet and was trying to convince me otherwise this morning.

    I'm going to see what I can find on this. Treat all of my answers as speculative opinion for now and not advice please -- but suffice it to say that I don't see this as "you're losing muscle" when looking strictly at the fact that you're smelling ammonia.

    Whether this is normal, ideal, or problematic for other reasons is something I need to learn about, apparently.
  • nexangelus
    nexangelus Posts: 2,080 Member

    I'm going to see what I can find on this. Treat all of my answers as speculative opinion for now and not advice please -- but suffice it to say that I don't see this as "you're losing muscle" when looking strictly at the fact that you're smelling ammonia.

    Whether this is normal, ideal, or problematic for other reasons is something I need to learn about, apparently.

    I never really thought to research it, as after all my hard workouts all my life I have had the strong ammonia whiff. Now I see someone else post about it, it reminded me and made me think about it again. It has never worried me as such as I am used to it now. And have never felt badly after workouts or felt my health was failing in any way. Would be interesting to see the full scientific and hopefully not-too-scary explanation, though (curiosity and all that).
  • fallonrhea
    fallonrhea Posts: 388 Member
    Thanks so much, SideSteel! I'll be looking forward to seeing what you can find :)
  • darkguardian419
    darkguardian419 Posts: 1,302 Member
    Do you work out before your first meal of the day?

    Being that you're eating around 135g of carbs a day (1800 cal, 30%=540/4 cal per G = 135G) throughout the night and into your workout you may be burning off the carbs/glycogen and be in the beginning stages of ketosis [not a bad thing]. An ammonia smell, and/or a fruity breath smell are common from this type of thing.

    But, that's the first thing that came to mind... it might be a concentration due to not enough water, and maybe increased salt... and could be worse if it's your ToM.

    ETA: For safety reasons, if you're diabetic, ketosis = ketoacidosis (mostly) and can be deadly.

    No, I don't :-/ I usually workout around 6 pm or so. By then I've only consumed probably around 85 g of carbs throughout the day though

    I'll also clarify I almost never make 1800 calories. The average is closer to 1700. :).

    That throws a wrench in my thoughts then :( People rarely hit ketosis when they eat above 50g of carbs/day, was just thinking that between the "fast" from sleep, followed by a workout, you may be starting it, but I doubt it if it's after 2-3 meals. I'm not sure then... you have SideSteel curious, so I'm betting you'll get a good answer soon :bigsmile: I'll ask my wife (paramedic) if she can think of anything that would cause that when she gets home.

    If you're curious, you could try ketostix, but honestly, the more I think about it, I'm doubting it's that.
  • fallonrhea
    fallonrhea Posts: 388 Member

    That throws a wrench in my thoughts then :( People rarely hit ketosis when they eat above 50g of carbs/day,

    Hmmm...okay. Maybe it is the water then. I'll try to drink more today and see if it makes a difference. Also, I should probably add that a large portion of my carbs that I consume come from fiber. I try to get 30+ g in a day...I'm not sure if that matters.
  • Sarauk2sf
    Sarauk2sf Posts: 28,072 Member
    Just tagging to follow along. I am in agreement with SideSteel so far in that it is does not mean any muscle loss but is worth looking into further for other reasons.
  • professorRAT
    professorRAT Posts: 690 Member
    tagging to follow
  • SideSteel
    SideSteel Posts: 11,068 Member
    Update:

    1) I couldn't find anything that suggests that this is problematic. That does not mean that this is not problematic, it just means that I couldn't find anything showing that it is cause for concern. (It COULD mean that I suck at finding things).

    2) That being said, I'm willing to bet that rearranging your macronutrients and increasing your hydration will remove this problem.


    You're consuming hefty amounts of protein and I'm convinced that you're just oxidizing a lot of protein.

    I would increase carbohydrate and reduce protein rather significantly and see what this does to the problem and ALSO see what it does to your gym performance (I would expect it to improve).
  • Sarauk2sf
    Sarauk2sf Posts: 28,072 Member
    I know this is a little old but I did some homework on this and confirmed there is nothing to be concerned about. This write up is the best I found (from what I could tell anyway):


    The chemical make-up of ammonia is NH3. This means that there is one Nitrogen atom bound to three Hydrogen atoms. Ammonia can be a weak acid or a weak base, depending on what type of chemical it is suspended in. Ammonia has a strong, pungent odor that is easily recognizable in cleaning products, cat urine, and, for some people, sweat!

    The key to ammonia in urine and sweat is the nitrogen. The only macronutrient in your body that contains nitrogen is amino acids, the building blocks of protein. In fact, many bodybuilders are always seeking a "positive nitrogen balance" meaning that less nitrogen leaves their body than enters their body. Since nitrogen is in every amino acid, and amino acids are the building blocks of muscle, someone in positive nitrogen balance is more than likely gaining muscle mass.

    Your body uses amino acids for energy every day. There is no way to avoid this. Your body constantly goes into catabolic (tissue breakdown) and anabolic (tissue building) phases. When you accumulate mass (lean or fat), your anabolic phases exceed your catabolic phases, but you still experience both phases. When your body uses an amino acid for energy, it must convert the amino acid to a useable form of energy.

    It does this by stripping the nitrogen atom off of the molecule. The skeleton molecule that is left behind is then further converted into glucose and used as fuel. In order to get rid of the excess nitrogen, your body typically processes the nitrogen in your kidneys and forms urea, CO(NH2)2 - basically, a carbon dioxide molecule bound to nitrogen and hydrogen. Urea is then excreted in the urine. If your kidneys cannot handle the load of nitrogen, then the nitrogen will be excreted as ammonia in your sweat.

    One other factor to consider is water intake. The methods used for getting rid of excess ammonia, such as urine and sweat, all require water as a transport mechanism. If you are not getting adequate fluid, then the solution (ammonia + water) will not be diluted. Therefore, water plays a definite role. If you are not drinking enough fluids to have at least one or two clear urinations every day, you should drink more.

    Based on this explanation, it is clear that your sweat will smell like ammonia only if an excessive amount of amino acids are being used for energy, or you are not receiving adequate water. This helps us find a solution to the problem.

    Doesn't That Mean My Protein Intake Is Inadequate?

    Many people mistakenly believe that ammonia sweat means that their protein intake is not high enough. The body will only utilize protein for energy when it does not have a sufficient supply of fats and carbohydrates. Muscles can use glucose and fat for energy, but your brain requires glucose. Since there is no direct metabolic pathway from fat to glucose, your body will use amino acids instead. If your protein intake is high, there is a chance that the amino acids that supply energy will come from ingested food and not your hard-earned muscle tissue - but why take that chance?

    Let's look at an oil lamp. If you fill that lamp with Citronella oil, it will have a distinct odor when you light it. To eliminate that odor, do you add more Citronella? No! That's just fanning the flames. You'd use a different type of oil instead. The same goes for the ammonia smell - this is just the smell of amino acids being "burned" in your body. You don't solve that by adding more amino acids. Instead, you need to supply the fuel that your body prefers - the fuel that can be easily broken down to glucose in order to supply energy to your muscles and your brain - carbohydrates!

    The key to avoiding that ammonia smell is to ingest sufficient carbohydrates. If you eat an ample amount of carbohydrate with every meal, then you should have plenty to fuel your exercise activity. Even people who work out on an empty stomach should have some glucose in their bloodstream upon rising - unless they subscribe to the myth that cutting out carbohydrates before bed helps you lose fat. If you find that the ammonia smell persists (even when you consume carbohydrate with every meal), try having a low glycemic carbohydrate before you workout.

    A little oatmeal, a small apple, or even a piece of sprouted grain bread can provide the fuel that your body needs. Remember, your body requires fuel to burn fat! So don't think that providing some carbs before cardio is going to eliminate the fat burning process. In fact, most of my clients who consume a light meal before working out report that their energy levels go through the roof, and they have an incredible workout. If adding 80 calories in the form of a slice of sprouted grain bread kicks your energy levels into high gear and helps you burn 100 more calories during exercise (while sparing your muscles from being used as fuel), there is no reason to worry about dropping fat!

    Learning Your Body

    Your body can only process a certain amount of food at each meal. Therefore, it may not be possible to avoid that ammonia smell during prolonged activities. The smell is common, for example, amongst marathon runners, who are engaging in continuous cardiovascular exercise for hours at a time. In that situation, it is advisable to consume "sports drinks" or other sources of energy during the activity to fuel your body (and especially your brain) and prevent your amino acids from being burned for energy.

    The next time you smell ammonia, don't worry. It doesn't mean that your muscle tissue being broken down, and it doesn't mean that you're doomed to stink for the rest of eternity. Consume a nutritious meal immediately after exercising - a balance of lean protein and whole, unprocessed carbohydrates - and then increase your carbohydrate intake throughout the day, or add a small "snack" prior to your next workout. An apple a day can help keep the ammonia smell away!

    http://www.bodybuilding.com/fun/ammonia.htm
  • Shen191
    Shen191 Posts: 86 Member
    tag to follow
  • Sarauk2sf
    Sarauk2sf Posts: 28,072 Member
    Locking as I think (hope) you have got some decent input and to help us track open/active threads better. If you want to add anything, please PM either myself or SideSteel, including the link, and we will reopen.
This discussion has been closed.