We are pleased to announce that on March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor will be introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the upcoming changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!
Questions on Intermittent Fasting (IF)
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4ecde/4ecde0409232b1b8d9107ba2ed8046c4460a7028" alt="danamariers"
danamariers
Posts: 155 Member
Hi All,
So I've been reading through as much Paleo material as I can get my greedy hands on and there seems to be a lot of support about why IF is a great tool in the Paleo belt, and then reviews that it's not so great (esp. for ladies).
So I'm wondering for all you IF'ers:
1- How long do you go between meals? (including sleep)
2- What kinds of progress have you seen in weight loss/muscle defn?
3- Ladies, do you find this interferes and/or causes curious symptoms with your "lady time"
4- How long have you been IF?
5- Advice for those new to/considering incorporating IF?
Thanks everyone!
So I've been reading through as much Paleo material as I can get my greedy hands on and there seems to be a lot of support about why IF is a great tool in the Paleo belt, and then reviews that it's not so great (esp. for ladies).
So I'm wondering for all you IF'ers:
1- How long do you go between meals? (including sleep)
2- What kinds of progress have you seen in weight loss/muscle defn?
3- Ladies, do you find this interferes and/or causes curious symptoms with your "lady time"
4- How long have you been IF?
5- Advice for those new to/considering incorporating IF?
Thanks everyone!
0
Replies
-
bump.0
-
IF is just a fancy term for 'skipping a meal'.
Personally I don't eat breakfast anymore. This means my last eating is done around 7 or 8 pm in the evening and then I don't eat again until lunch the next day (11 am), so that means I go 15-16 hours typically for my 'fast'.
I will say that some days I go get a little hungry around 9 or 10 and then I just eat a hard boiled egg or two that I was going to have as part of my lunch.
As far as your questions go:1- How long do you go between meals? (including sleep)2- What kinds of progress have you seen in weight loss/muscle defn?3- Ladies, do you find this interferes and/or causes curious symptoms with your "lady time"4- How long have you been IF?5- Advice for those new to/considering incorporating IF?
I've also heard that sometimes when you feel hungry what your body may really need is more water. So in the morning when I get up I do drink plenty of water.
I think you may need to ease into it by going longer and longer between meals until you have an IF time frame that makes sense for you.
I did try to IF during the day at work eating only breakfast and dinner but I found that much harder to stick with than just eating a lunch around 11 am and then dinner around 6 or 7.
Please note that when eating this way my lunch and dinners are generally bigger than they used to be when I ate three meals a day. My calories eaten during a day are pretty much the same although on some days I can be quite a bit under if what I've eaten has filled me up particularly well.0 -
I have a six-hour eating window, usually between 12:00pm and 6:00pm. I typically eat two meals within these two times and try to make them as close together as possible. I don't snack in between. Has this done anything for me? I haven't noticed any real differences.
Fasting isn't anything magic. At least it hasn't been for me. I've been doing it for months but the only progress I ever see is when I do straight-up caloric restriction.
As for getting into it? I have no real advice. I just started doing it. I may be anomalous though, in that even when I was eating SAD, I could go for days without eating anything and not be screwed up. Super hungry, yes, obviously. But I have never had flagging energy levels because I missed a meal (or two, or whatever).0 -
I usually eat from 11am until 5pm. Its difficult for me to eat in the morning because I am busy with an infant and try to do all my housework so IF works great for me and that is how it started, I have been doing it for probably about 5-6 weeks. I have lost 20lbs and would have lost more if I didn't cheat or include chocolate and dairy on a pretty much daily basis. I have not had a change in my cycle and no weird symptoms, I think IF makes me feel better in general. If you want to give it a try I would recommend just skipping breakfast for a couple days and see how it makes you feel. Also I believe some people drink a bullet proof coffee in the am when they are fasting and that keeps you from being hungry until well into the afternoon.0
-
1- How long do you go between meals? (including sleep)
2- What kinds of progress have you seen in weight loss/muscle defn?
3- Ladies, do you find this interferes and/or causes curious symptoms with your "lady time"
4- How long have you been IF?
5- Advice for those new to/considering incorporating IF?
Thanks everyone!
1) Depends on the day. Typically go from around 8-9PM to 5-6PM most days, with the exception of a few when I feel peckish for chocolate or eat a small lunch so my friends don't feel uncomfortable - these exceptions are around 1-2PM.
2) I can actually eat all my food and not feel miserable doing so... I hate eating throughout the day, and struggle to eat the same equivalent of food in several meals as I can in one. So it's allowed me to not lose weight quite effectively.
3) Um...
4) Six months? Yeah, about that time.
5) Yes:
-Brush your teeth, a lot, Your breath can smell really bad from the amount of food being digested in larger meals.
-Do strength training. I advise that to everyone, anyway.
-Ensure you actually eat all your calories in your feeding window, don't use it as an excuse to undereat.
-It *may not be for you*, but that's okay, doesn't make you any "lesser" despite what some nutters out there may rave about.
-Don't overthink it. IF isn't magic. It's just giving you a smaller amount of time to eat your food.0 -
Well, I fasted 12 hours today between breakfast and dinner, not intentionally, it just worked out that way. And funny thing, I wasn't even really hungry for dinner, but figured I'd better eat as otherwise I'd have been below 1000 calories for the day.0
This discussion has been closed.