Advice to offer?
msnucerity
Posts: 333 Member
Hi All,
I'm looking to lose some serious inches get healthy and am really drawn to LCHF. (Finally got off my buns and have been reading some good reads on why carbs/grains/starches are the devil!) I find myself attracted to this method bc Diabetes, types 1 & 2, can be found running rampant throughout my family from my lovely elders to VERY HEAVY SET aunts and uncles. (to be fair I'm heavy but have since slimmed down from 200 to 176 and as I research low carb, I see that the way to continue to lose and then maintain without being perpetually hungry is to really keep carbs out)
As I continue to read, get familiar, learn the science/logic (or lack there of with "conventional wisdom") I thought I'd ask some LCHF pro's for their advice, instead of trying to reinvent the wheel myself!
I'm wondering:
1- did you find its better to go hard on LCHF, deal with induction flu right off the bat and move on OR ease in to it? (I'm usually a "go hard or go home" person but also know that doesn't always serve to be the best way)
2- what's your stance on dairy? I've read differing opinions from "our ancestors didn't eat it, we shouldn't either" to, "if it's high fat then have at it". Dairy doesn't bother me tummy/allergy-wise, I don't have much short of sour cream with my salsa chicken or a slice of melted cheese on an egg in the morning, but I do enjoy it!
3- what's your stance on Quinoa/beans/legumes? Some say they have lots of protein so it's not so bad. Other reading suggests "NO! It's grain, or it's starch, it's not something to have regularly or at all!"
4- what did you do to help deal with carb cravings? My house doesn't have much in the way for carbs, but as I get rid of them entirely (ie donating unused bag of rice to shelters and what not) I wonder what do people do to help with carb cravings? Drink water? Eat something? Take up cross-stitching?
5- what got you through induction flu, through carb cravings, through the transition to loving LCHF?
6- what do you set your carb/fat/protein macros to?
7- any other advice? Advice on food? On shopping? On handling people who can't keep their noses in their own business and say things like, "What's this health kick? The body NEEDS grains!" (shy of pretending to be on the phone or intermittent deafness)
Thanks everyone; have a wonderful Saturday! (hopefully you won't have to dress up and shovel snow today like I do!)
I'm looking to lose some serious inches get healthy and am really drawn to LCHF. (Finally got off my buns and have been reading some good reads on why carbs/grains/starches are the devil!) I find myself attracted to this method bc Diabetes, types 1 & 2, can be found running rampant throughout my family from my lovely elders to VERY HEAVY SET aunts and uncles. (to be fair I'm heavy but have since slimmed down from 200 to 176 and as I research low carb, I see that the way to continue to lose and then maintain without being perpetually hungry is to really keep carbs out)
As I continue to read, get familiar, learn the science/logic (or lack there of with "conventional wisdom") I thought I'd ask some LCHF pro's for their advice, instead of trying to reinvent the wheel myself!
I'm wondering:
1- did you find its better to go hard on LCHF, deal with induction flu right off the bat and move on OR ease in to it? (I'm usually a "go hard or go home" person but also know that doesn't always serve to be the best way)
2- what's your stance on dairy? I've read differing opinions from "our ancestors didn't eat it, we shouldn't either" to, "if it's high fat then have at it". Dairy doesn't bother me tummy/allergy-wise, I don't have much short of sour cream with my salsa chicken or a slice of melted cheese on an egg in the morning, but I do enjoy it!
3- what's your stance on Quinoa/beans/legumes? Some say they have lots of protein so it's not so bad. Other reading suggests "NO! It's grain, or it's starch, it's not something to have regularly or at all!"
4- what did you do to help deal with carb cravings? My house doesn't have much in the way for carbs, but as I get rid of them entirely (ie donating unused bag of rice to shelters and what not) I wonder what do people do to help with carb cravings? Drink water? Eat something? Take up cross-stitching?
5- what got you through induction flu, through carb cravings, through the transition to loving LCHF?
6- what do you set your carb/fat/protein macros to?
7- any other advice? Advice on food? On shopping? On handling people who can't keep their noses in their own business and say things like, "What's this health kick? The body NEEDS grains!" (shy of pretending to be on the phone or intermittent deafness)
Thanks everyone; have a wonderful Saturday! (hopefully you won't have to dress up and shovel snow today like I do!)
0
Replies
-
1 and 5. I started about a week ago, so I'm no expert! I was eating a pretty well-rounded relatively LF diet before. I tried not to over-do carbs but I wasn't restricting them at all. I started keto full-force, following my macros. I was pretty fuzzy earlier this week, but I followed the advice I read a lot about avoiding the "flu"- lots of water and increasing salt intake. I didn't have any aches, nausea, anything like that. But maybe I'm just lucky!
2. I do dairy but not much. Granted, I've just begun so the weight is coming off easy right now, but dairy seems to be fine for me right now. I know some people try to cut it out when they plateau.
3. I would eat Q/B/L if it fit my macros for the day, but for that to happen there would have to be very little of any of those.
4. I haven't had any carb cravings until last night, while my friends were eating pad thai next to me! I also purged my pantry. Again, only a week in, so I'm sure the cravings will pop up somewhere. There's just so much amazing food that I'd been denying myself in trying to be "healthy" that I can eat now! CARBS SHMARBS
6. http://keto-calculator.ankerl.com/
7. I caught some flack out at dinner last night and people shut up pretty fast when I told them I've lost 6 lbs in less than a week
Hope this helps! I'm sure there are more experienced keto-ers who have more/better advice!0 -
Keto Flu: I haven't had it. I had a bad day and quickly figured out I was low on salt and potassium. So it may depend on how well you manage your vitamins/minerals/electrolytes. I find that most people seriously lack sodium and potassium. Low potassium can make you feel like your heart is racing, or skipping beats. Kinda like a panic/anxiety attack. So don't underestimate it!
Carb cravings: I haven't had them, unless you count emotional ones. I craved pasta today, but only because it's such a family thing to eat a big pasta meal. And today we finally decorated for christmas, so the emotional need for pasta was there. I didn't cave in, and I'm glad I didn't because I would be dealing with personal disappointment for that. You need to figure out the reason you crave certain foods. If you have emotional attachments (I'm italian american, so of course pasta is a huge thing for me lol) then acknowledge it. It may be easier to overcome and move on from that moment. If your carb cravings are associated with salty foods like chips, then it may be salty foods you're really craving (so eat more salt). As long as you can identify the reason for the cravings, it should be easier to navigate beyond them.
Beans: It's not worth the calories for me right now to eat them. Too many carbs, and it takes away from the fat and protein I need to consume in my 1200 calorie allowance. When I get to point where I can increase my carbs, it won't be for beans lol. I'm going for the pasta! :-D
Ratio: for now, 75-80% fat, 5% carbs, and the rest protein. You need to be just as careful with the protein as you are the carbs. Get enough to maintain muscle mass. Too much, and you're back at breaking them down into pieces which includes glucose and therefor defeating the purpose of resisting type 2 diabetes. My whole family on my mothers side have it. I refuse. But I do have increased insulin levels, so to decrease them, I keep protein down to what is needed. I have years of success in this area!
Other folks: tell them the usda recommendations actually go against science, even the data that was available at the time they made those recommendations (I found this out in college). Also, ask them to look around. Is it merely a correlation that with the recommendations of low fat diets, that america got really fat? No. Sweden has now come out against low fat, and recommends their citizens eat a higher fat, low carb diet. How cool is that? Also, when you start feeling the positive changes, other peoples perceptions will not affect you as much. I told one person that when my "fad" diet failed, I'll try theirs (they were morbidly obese). They didn't say another word about it.
Dairy: I'll never give it up! And I'll be going to raw dairy soon for the best benefits. Most adverse reactions people have come from pasteurized dairy products. Do your research, but most of all, do what feels good for you.
Your body is the best judge for all of your questions. Listen to it. If you feel good, keep it up. If not, troubleshoot, and tweak your diet. If you need more Keto buddies, add me! I always welcome more support :-)0 -
I've been eating low carb and keto for nearly four years now - can't recall if I suffered any keto flu back in the beginning. I would recommend jumping in completely- following the Atkins Induction Phase is a really good way to start, imho. That eliminates a lot of the - should I, shouldn't I - questions from the start. It really helps with insulin resistance and any climbing blood glucose levels too.
Carb temptations are very few and far between at this point and as Ninanator said, usually connected to emotional issues. There are so many amazing keto-adapted recipes for substitutes that there is no real need to deny yourself an alternate version of a carby favorite.
I would never eat beans, legumes, etc., but that is because I am diabetic.Non-diabetics will have more leeway for these starchy protein sources. I do eat dairy in the form of whole cream (double-cream for you Europeans), real butter, full fat sour cream and various high fat cheeses. Cream cheese is the foundation of many of my recipes.
You also have a lot of leeway on your macros. I began with about a 60F - 30P - 10C ratio way back when and kept changing the ratios around. I was at 85F - 10P - 5C for a long while but recently switched back to an 80-15-5 because my body seems to crave a bit more protein in winter.
I will say that at my age (over 60), I am not very active and I do not lose weight quickly. I have lost 30 pounds over the years but I think that younger people will have more dramatic responses. Weight loss is not my goal - controlling blood glucose, cholesterol and blood pressure are my goals. And keto works very well in this regard. I also believe that because keto lowers your overall body glucose load it is protective against developing cancers and dementia.
Grocery shopping can prove a bit on the expensive side on those first few trips, as you must start building a new staples list. Once you have your pantry set up, though, I find keto to be quite reasonable to maintain, financially. My shopping cart will be full of things like cream, butter, eggs, fresh salad greens, fatty (cheaper) cuts of meat. I also believe that eating a true keto plan requires a lot of food prep and cooking. Ready-made foods are a huge no-no.
There is no need to justify your health choices to anyone else, except perhaps a doctor or a parent. I laughed at a smoker who berated me with 'you're going to have a heart attack with all that cream and butter'.
Oh, and definitely drink lots of water!
I'm a firm believer that keto is a way of life, not a temporary diet plan.0 -
In regards to carb cravings, i don't experience them in the way that when I'm hungry, I suddenly want carbs. When I'm hungry, I just want to eat, something. At lunch, I often find myself craving e a Rib Eye with a small side of stir fry vegetables. Which isn't available anywhere close to my office. So I often end up with a salad plus a bit of chicken, egg, or turkey. For breakfast, I also crave big cheesy omelettes with mushrooms and tomatoes. I seem to only get that on sunday.
However, at my house, my wife is now baking dozens and dozens of Christmas cookies. Now that is not a craving problem. it is in-your-face temptation. That is difficult to overcome.
I get Keto Flu if I don't pay attention to salt & water intake for 3 or 4 days. For me, it is like all over body ache, with the worst being in my calves and biceps. I drink salty water and then it's gone in 15 minutes.0 -
Hi there, and welcome to the lovely world of Keto
1- did you find its better to go hard on LCHF, deal with induction flu right off the bat and move on OR ease in to it?
Just do it. Sit down for half an hour and plan ahead some days (I always plan ahead in order to get my macros right) and start – not everyone gets an induction flu. I didn't know it existed when I started Keto and can't remember any discomfort at all.
2- what's your stance on dairy?
I've always been unsure whether milk is good for us as adults, so I've stopped drinking milk when I started Keto. I drink my coffee with almond milk now and milk now tastes sour to me. I do however now take Calcium supplements as I used to drink a lot of milk. I do however eat cheese every day. I love and it's great to shove up the fat...
3- what's your stance on Quinoa/beans/legumes?
I am not totally crazy about my carbs (I stay under 40 because otherwise I can't go on the toilet on less than 20..) so I do eat some Heinz beans occasionally, usually mixed with mince and cheddar, wrapped in lettuce..
4- what did you do to help deal with carb cravings?
Depends on what you're craving really.. there are some great alternatives for pasta etc, but if it's sweeties you are missing I recommend home made fat bombs! I was never sure about artificial sweetener but now that I've lost some weight, I'm sure the occasional artificial sweetener is not as bad for me as my ridiculous weight I used to have was!
5- what got you through induction flu, through carb cravings, through the transition to loving LCHF?
Can't say, as I don't think I went through induction flu..
6- what do you set your carb/fat/protein macros to?
10% carbs (though I usually stay under that), 65% fat and 25% protein. I recommend this website for getting started. http://cavemanketo.com/ As you can see tomorrow there's “Getting started on MFP” or something like that.
7- any other advice? Advice on food? On shopping?
Plan ahead, check your macros and you'll get used to Keto in no time – there is an abundance of pages on the internet (one I've already linked to), make friends on MFP and nose through their diaries, I'm sure you'll enjoy Keto!0 -
The best....0 -
1- did you find its better to go hard on LCHF, deal with induction flu right off the bat and move on OR ease in to it?2- what's your stance on dairy? I've read differing opinions from "our ancestors didn't eat it, we shouldn't either" to, "if it's high fat then have at it". Dairy doesn't bother me tummy/allergy-wise, I don't have much short of sour cream with my salsa chicken or a slice of melted cheese on an egg in the morning, but I do enjoy it!
Either way, wouldn't hurt to either introduce it slowly into your regimen, or cut dairy out as the first thing if you stall.3- what's your stance on Quinoa/beans/legumes? Some say they have lots of protein so it's not so bad. Other reading suggests "NO! It's grain, or it's starch, it's not something to have regularly or at all!"4- what did you do to help deal with carb cravings? My house doesn't have much in the way for carbs, but as I get rid of them entirely (ie donating unused bag of rice to shelters and what not) I wonder what do people do to help with carb cravings? Drink water? Eat something? Take up cross-stitching?5- what got you through induction flu, through carb cravings, through the transition to loving LCHF?6- what do you set your carb/fat/protein macros to?7- any other advice? Advice on food? On shopping? On handling people who can't keep their noses in their own business and say things like, "What's this health kick? The body NEEDS grains!" (shy of pretending to be on the phone or intermittent deafness)
-Have a cheat meal after a couple months. Heck, have a whole cheat day. You'll feel bloated and gassy and think "oh god, was I always like this?" The next day you'll wake up retaining 8 pounds of water, and your pants are tight, and you'll get even more resolve to be healthy again... for a couple months.
-You don't NEED vegetables. They're nice. They provide variety and flavor... but you CAN get all your nutritional needs met through nothing but eggs fried in butter for breakfast, bacon cheeseburgers for lunch, and a handful of almonds before bed (because you probably won't be hungry enough to cook dinner, haha).
-On that note, a lot of people feel more comfortable on keto by pre-planning their daily meals or making a weeks' worth of food and freezing it. Soups, salads, no-bean chili, scotch eggs, whatever.
-PRINT OUT YOUR FAVORITE RECIPES. Keep them in a three-ring binder!
-Make a list before you leave the house. Write down nutritional info from MFP for everything. DO NOT DEVIATE FROM THE LIST. It makes shopping a lot easier.
-BUY A CROCK POT if you don't have one! And maybe a Powercrisp (http://www.amazon.com/Presto-05100-PowerCrisp-microwave-cooker/dp/B00006IUWC) and a microwave egg poacher (http://www.amazon.com/Chef-Buddy-Microwave-Egg-Cooker/dp/B004SJUGPI).0