deciphering between "moderate" and "light" effort

chelso0o
chelso0o Posts: 366 Member
I suppose this would be easier if I used a HRM, but when you don't have one what is the best way to figure out whether it is moderate or light effort? I figured that hard effort was similar to my 2K effort, but what about that gray area?

Replies

  • BrianSharpe
    BrianSharpe Posts: 9,248 Member
    HRMs can fool you too as different exercises will have variation in HR compared to perceived effort.

    My triathlon coach loves to use your ability to talk as a measure of effort.........at a light or recovery effort you can sing, at a moderate effort you can speak in full sentences, approaching the top end of your aerobic threshold you can speak but would rather not & hitting your anaerobic threshold you're pretty much panting and can only sustain the effort for a brief period of time.

    If your 2K pace is hard then probably moderate would be your 10K pace which has to be sustainable over a longer period.
  • mrspeterson
    mrspeterson Posts: 54 Member
    Someone asked a similar question below (see "Calculating effort" thread) a while back. I wear a HRM when I erg, and I find that even if I'm rowing fairly hard (sweating, HR 145-155, yelling at the kid NOT NOW when he asks how to build a ender portal in minecraft), my calories are generally 20% lower than what MFP gives me for "moderate" rowing. I have a PM4 and I switch display to calories (which shows average cal/hour), divide by 60, multiply by minutes. So I record moderate, then enter actual calories. I should probably just enter light, but I know I worked to hard to call it light!

    Which is to say, I think MFP may overestimate calories burned.