Skip to content
  • Register

    • keto

    Join
    We are pleased to announce that as of March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor has been introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

    Intermittent Fasting

    Posts: 78 Member
    edited November 2024 in Social Groups
    I've posted a few times here before trying to understand why I cant seem to lose weight. Basically I've been Keto for a solid 2 months and lost less than 5lbs. Its been driving me nuts for quite some time. Although I love the other benefits of Keto, such as higher energy, less aches and pains, better sleep, etc, lets be honest: I really want to lose weight!!!

    Last week I was scheduled to have a laproscopic surgery, so for 2 days I only ate liquids (broth with butter, jello, etc) and one meal. The surgery ended up getting canceled (for other reasons) but I realized when I got home that I'd lost 2 lbs. Remarkably, they didn't come back when I ate normal keto for the rest of the week. So this week I decided to try intermittent fasting to see if I could lose more. Low and behold, I've lost another pound this week!!!

    I'm so incredibly excited! It has felt awful to work so hard at this diet and see the same number on the scale over and over every morning. I have PCOS and a very slow resting heart-rate so losing was never going to be easy for me, but even tracking calories and Keto wasn't cutting it.

    So now I have a new plan, keto plus IF. I just wanted to put this out there to all the women with PCOS who are struggling to lose on keto. I wouldn't have thought to try IF if it hadn't been for the surgery prep, but now I feel confident that this is what my body needs to actually lose.

    Welcome!

    It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.
    Sign In
    Register

    Replies

    • Posts: 149 Member
      I have only tried IF once - and I thought I was going to starve to death. LOL (Probably all mental....I love to eat.) I have considered the egg fast (I have a bal gown to get into next month) but I have also heard that you quickly gain back what you lose when you return to "normal" food.

      I too have a slow moving scale but I don't let it bother me because I feel so much better. I know I'm shrinking in inches (both from a tape measure and loose clothing) so I really don't worry about pounds. I do workout too. In the month of November I only lost 2 lbs - but then this month I'm already down another 3. It's just a screwy little thing I have noticed with this WOE.
    • Posts: 47 Member
      Low carbing definitely makes IF easier. From what I know about IF, it is much (better?) (healthier?) for guys then gals. It may be worth a google search.
      http://www.marksdailyapple.com/women-and-intermittent-fasting/#axzz3LakH0kGZ

      But just like with anything, YMMV and listen to your body. It does seem to work for some women, just not all.
    • Posts: 78 Member
      I would be happy to have a slow moving scale, unfortunately I had a non moving scale!

      I've never heard the thing about it being better for men than women. Since this is only my second week trying it I will have to see. It definitely takes some willpower on the fasting days.
    • Posts: 644 Member
      I just read an article yesterday that said it's more effective and improves health conditions more for men than women. Not that it's necessarily bad for women.
    • Posts: 333 Member
      I'm also thinking of trying IF (the scale moves vvveerrrryyy slowly for me too). How long have people fasted at a time? 2 days every week? 3 days every 10-14 days?

      Not sure of where to go from here (more googling required) but feel free to add me as a friend (we can be fasting buddies!)

      I'm such a dork sometimes... B)
    • Posts: 86 Member
      My scale is psychotic! Last night I was 309. This morning I was 306. Tonight I'll probably be 310. Each time I have to tell myself that the scale is not important. I am creating a healthy lifestyle.

      What's this about not hurting? My joints still hurt. I have a touch of sciatica and I don't expect anything to improve that or my knees that crunch when I bend them. I just want to lose the weight.
    • Posts: 18 Member
      I started IF about three weeks into keto and I think it helped avoid the normal stall after the first few weeks of water loss. My version of IF is only eating from noon-8pm (because we usually eat a late dinner). I'm not big on coffee, so I only drink water from waking-noon. I find that this allows me to eat bigger meals because I'm squeezing the same amount of calories into a shorter period of time. It only took a few days for my stomach to get used to the idea of not eating breakfast, and then I wasn't even hungry until noon anyway. I have been cheating like crazy lately because of Thanksgiving, my birthday, and Christmas coming up, but when I was on track I lost about 22 lbs in 6 weeks with keto and IF. I'll get back to it hardcore after New Year's, but for now I'm just trying to be good day-to-day and not get down on myself too bad when I slip up at a party or family gathering.
    • Posts: 1,041 Member
      I've had very good results combining IF eating protocols and LCHF. I'm not too strict, though, since I want to exercise A LOT.
    • Posts: 86 Member
      I would really like to try this but as a disordered eater, I'm afraid that once I stop eating, it's over. I can go a whole day on water and coffee and maybe a can of tuna. For me, regular eating feels like a slip up. I would love to be able to manage something like IF without completing falling back into the rabbit hole. It has taken a LOT for me to eat so much every day. I'd love to just not eat at all and maybe live off of heavy whipping cream for a few days. Would that count as IF?
    • Posts: 47 Member
      Two common approaches are only eating during a small window during the day (maybe 12 noon - 6 pm) or 1-2 days a week skipping two meals a day (I skip breakfast and lunch one day a week)
    • Posts: 1,850 Member
      Instead of typing everything again, look at my comments on fasting on my MFP Blog:

      Fasting & Keto

      And:

      Fasting, Diabetic ~ Glucose/Sugar Levels

      Since I wrote these early on, I have fasted several more times. I am thinking about doing another this weekend. I usually do a 24 hour fast at minimum, and the longest was 4 days. If you are adapted, it is much harder in YOUR MIND than the actual fast.

      Dan the Man from Michigan


    • Posts: 86 Member
      Thanks Dan. I read both and then decided to fast instead of eating dinner last night. I probably shouldn't have done it so soon into starting but I wanted to see what would happen. The scale moved a little. I'm going to throw it out.
    • Posts: 422 Member
      I was doing the 16/8 IF for a number of months earlier in the year and really liked it. I am not sure if I lost any weight that I wouldn't have in the first place, I just really liked what felt like a powerful feeling of not being tied to needing to eat all the time, and I enjoy bigger meals. I was eating between ~1pm-8pm most of the time, but I'm having to change that. While its true from a nutritional perspective that it doesn't matter when you eat, it appears that I really need the morning meal to stimulate normal/healthy bathroom habits. For now I'm just not doing IF anymore, the idea of eating from 9am-4pm or and not eating in the evening is far less appealing to me.
    • Posts: 1,850 Member
      TheTrophyWife wrote: »
      Thanks Dan. I read both and then decided to fast instead of eating dinner last night. I probably shouldn't have done it so soon into starting but I wanted to see what would happen. The scale moved a little. I'm going to throw it out.

      It never hurts to do a fast. It actually will help in your Keto adaptation. It trains your body to rely on your stored fuel (fat).

      Look at the section on "Fasting" on my blog #11:

      Really Good Keto Websites

      I hope this helps,

      Dan the Man from Fasting Land



    • Posts: 1,082 Member
      If I have too many carbs, I will IF the next day and then stick to high fat the rest of the day with little carbs. This always resets my diet and lessens my bloat. I also have PCOS and am very sensitive to carbs. Most days I'm under 10 total carbs.
    • Posts: 86 Member
      Dan,

      Thanks for putting that together! I really appreciate the abbreviations too. Now I know what everyone has been saying! LOL!

      So, I'm considering drinking my fat shakes until I feel like I need solid food. I can usually make a 16 oz shake last for a couple of hours plus I drink my BPC with it for breakfast. I'm also thinking about changing my numbers again even though I said I wasn't.
    • Posts: 2,530 Member
      peabean26 wrote: »
      I've posted a few times here before trying to understand why I cant seem to lose weight.


      What kind of deficit were you running?

    • Posts: 41 Member
      edited January 2015
      TheTrophyWife wrote: »
      My scale is psychotic! Last night I was 309. This morning I was 306. Tonight I'll probably be 310. Each time I have to tell myself that the scale is not important. I am creating a healthy lifestyle.

      What's this about not hurting? My joints still hurt. I have a touch of sciatica and I don't expect anything to improve that or my knees that crunch when I bend them. I just want to lose the weight.

      @TheTrophyWife‌
      Try adding this to your diet....
      http://www.amazon.com/dp/B005KG7EDU/ref=sr_ph?ie=UTF8&qid=1420815625&sr=1&keywords=great+lakes+gelatin

      It should really help with sore joints and crunching knees. I put it in my coffee in the morning, but you can put in whatever. It just dissolves and has no flavor!
    This discussion has been closed.

    Welcome!

    It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.
    Sign In
    Register

    Quick Links

    Categories