(How) Does Exercise Effect Ketosis?

cathy120861
cathy120861 Posts: 265 Member
edited November 15 in Social Groups
I know that staying in ketosis is mostly about what you eat, but i have read three different things about whether exercise effects ketosis:
1. long periods of moderate exercise is best for ketosis
2. intense exercise for shorter periods is best for ketosis
3. exercise does not effect ketosis one way or another.

What do you guys think? i would be interested in knowing both about reliable research and about your personal experiences.

Replies

  • wabmester
    wabmester Posts: 2,748 Member
    The few studies I've seen looked at the effect of ketosis on exercise performance, not vice versa.

    If you're ketogenic due to a low-carb diet, then your glycogen stores are depleted (or at least reduced). Your ability to do intense exercise should be impaired, I would think. But if you can do intense exercise, then that would further deplete glycogen, and you'd need more ketones.

    Just about any exercise will try to burn some glucose, but intense (i.e., anaerobic) burns more.
  • sweetteadrinker2
    sweetteadrinker2 Posts: 1,026 Member
    I've heard that HIIT brings some people to a deeper ketosis. I've hit my stride and can do either intense short or moderate long exercise, moderate exercise doens't seem to do anything one way or another. HIIT makes me have keto breath the next day.
  • wabmester
    wabmester Posts: 2,748 Member
    HIIT makes me have keto breath the next day.

    I think 99% of the people who think they have keto-breath really have protein-breath.

    Intense exercise needs glucose. Your body will make it by burning protein (gluconeogenesis). The result of burning protein is ammonia breath (and ammonia sweat), not acetone.

  • GrannyMayOz
    GrannyMayOz Posts: 1,051 Member
    Professor Tim Noakes is a wonderful guy to listen to about exercise and ketosis/LCHF. He's in his 60s and still runs marathons (and I believe ultra-marathons too). He wrote a book years ago saying marathoners need to carb up before running. He now starts his talks by telling everyone how totally wrong he was. He states facts about current ultra-marathoners, ironmen etc who are outperforming their younger selves because they are now on a keto/LCHF diet. He does very short podcasts through talkfeed.co.za/lchfpodcast/ and on one of those he mentioned that keto/LCHF athletes really came into their own and performed at their best for the middle and end of races when glycogen-dependent athletes had hit the wall. The LCHF athletes just kept powering through and, if anything, were stronger as the race progressed. He runs marathons in a fasted state, taking in only water and a little fat during the race. YouTube has many, many interviews and presentations that he's given around the world and he has a really easy-listening style, but is very authoritative.

    For myself, a 58 year old overweight woman, I go on a treadmill for around 35 minutes 2 or 3 times a week. I play a video with music and alternate walking one song, jogging one song until I've jogged 4 times, then I alternate sprinting flat out, and walking a couple of times before I cool down. I do know that I was an idiot keeping up my exercise while I keto adapted. Admittedly it was mid-summer and very hot, but I was so breathless walking even short distances outdoors during that time and ended up with heart palpitations and all sorts of interesting things. I took a couple of weeks break and am now back to prior health/fitness/performance. It's too early yet to say if I will gain additional fitness.

    As far as there being such a huge range of conflicting ideas, I got confused by all of that for a while and then decided to just pin my trust on one person and got with that until I knew what my own experience was.
  • Yogi_warrior
    Yogi_warrior Posts: 5,464 Member
    wabmester wrote: »
    HIIT makes me have keto breath the next day.

    I think 99% of the people who think they have keto-breath really have protein-breath.

    Intense exercise needs glucose. Your body will make it by burning protein (gluconeogenesis). The result of burning protein is ammonia breath (and ammonia sweat), not acetone.
    SMH. Glucogenesis is slower and can't provide energy at high intensities. Your liver can make glucose (ATP) for high intensity in addition to the ATP from lactic acid. But again, everything changes with time, your body can use fat even at higher intensity if it gets enough time to adapt.
  • Dragonwolf
    Dragonwolf Posts: 5,600 Member
    wabmester wrote: »
    Intense exercise needs glucose....

    While technically true, the body's definition of "intense" changes with keto-adaptation and time.

    In Dr. Peter Attia's case, his aerobic base (the point at which you start burning 50% of your fuel from glycogen) had double the VO2 capacity. The glycogen requirements for his marathon pace went from 95% (needed nearly all glycogen) to 22% (used more than 3/4 fat).

    In other words, he needed less glycogen (glucose) for the same activities at the same intensities after he was keto-adapted than before. However, he did have to sacrifice a little top end (VO2 max) in order to get these other results, which does suggest that if you want all out power for a 100m sprint or some such (where you would be well into glucose burning territory and are basically like a street racer burning NOS), then a carb-up might be a good idea.

    http://eatingacademy.com/how-a-low-carb-diet-affected-my-athletic-performance
  • middleagedmeh
    middleagedmeh Posts: 104 Member
    Hello...
    I find that if if pop out of ketosis which happens from time to time due to life I can get back in much quicker with some HITT.
    I can understand this as helping my body get rid of glycogen stores quicker and forcing the liver to do its job and start producing. It just helps create the right conditions for quicker entry in ketosis.
    It does not seem to affect adaptation... I still get hungry.
    It does not seem to help with weight loss. I lose the same water weight with or without it.

    FYI
    it takes me 3 to 4 days to show anything above traces of ketones. With exercise I can get readings in 48 hours.
  • wabmester
    wabmester Posts: 2,748 Member
    Glucogenesis is slower and can't provide energy at high intensities.

    I've read that the GNG happens at rest to restore glycogen, but I'd like to learn more about the alternate pathways. Especially since I just got back from lifting weights, and my butt is kicked. :)
  • cathy120861
    cathy120861 Posts: 265 Member
    i am not worried about performance. i am just trying to figure out what i can do to make ketosis more easily attainable for me. and, since i enjoy exercising, i was thinking i could tailor my routine in whatever way is most effective.
  • DonPendergraft
    DonPendergraft Posts: 520 Member
    My (limited) understanding is that being thoroughly fat adapted (nutritional ketosis) is great for endurance, but not as important for short explosive exercises.
This discussion has been closed.