So my opinion isnt super credible as I JUST started protein powder yesterday, but in trying to decide I did a couple of hours research last week. I got the North Coast Naturals 100% Whey in Chocolate and have Optimum Nutrition in Cookies n Cream on it's way.

Both are supposed to be delicious with water, which was a major interest of mine. I dont dislike the chocolate (it would be GREAT with milk) but it wasnt amazing or anything. Definitely tolerable.

I drink Premier Protein. 30g of protein. I get it at Sam's or Costco.

I like Optimum Nutrition Protein Energy Cinnamon Bun mix

It tastes like a cinnamon bun Quest bar

Premier protein strawberries and cream! I love that stuff. Doesn't stall me out, comes premixed, and is tolerable not straight out of the fridge. 30 g protein, 2 g net carbs(4 total), not much for fat. 160 cals per 11 0z. Goes on good sales at costco and stores well in it's tetrapaks.

I order from proteinfactory.com I like that there are premixed formulas if you're in a hurry or don't know what you need, but you can also customize a formula with protein of choice (whey, egg, etc.) sweetener, vitamins, etc. I've tried a number of different ones. Some are better than others, but none have been bad. Also, I like his ideas on nutrition, weight loss, building muscle, etc. He's got some good articles.
See http://proteinfactory.com/dropping-calories-makes-you-fatter
I don't agree with him 100%, but then I don't agree with anyone 100%, LOL.

lodro wrote: »

auntstephie321 wrote: »

I do wish the low carb ones had a higher fat percentage. I haven't seen one yet that is lc hf

Add some double fat cream, or even MCT oil or coconut oil, and you're sorted.

I was going to say the same thing. I like to mix with coconut almond milk blend and I'll add some HWC if I have room for the extra fat and calories. It makes it creamy and smooth.
I picked up mine at Walgreens. It's bodylogix natural whey from grass fed cows sweetened with organic stevia. Has 26, 1 scoop servings. 120 calories, 24g protein and 3G carbs. It does say it contains soy also... I haven't done any research about protein powders though I understand there are some inferior quality ones to stay away from, I don't really know what they are. I haven't had any issues with the one I've been using but I would like to know for sure that I'm buying a good quality on my next purchase.
I was interested in one someone in our group uses that is hemp protein. I can't remember who it was. But they seemed to have been well informed when it came to good vs junk protein powders. I thought they may have posted in here, but it doesn't appear so.

I'm looking for a new one myself. I got an unflavored one. Blurg. It's "unflavor" shined through regardless of what I added.

The powder was supposed to be unflavored. The idea was that I could add whatever flavors I wanted, instead of being stuck with a whole container of just one flavor all the time. No matter whether I added cocoa powder, peanut butter, or berries, there was still that "taste" and it wasn't all that pleasant, breaking through. That flavor of the "unflavored" protein powder was unappetizing.

InADarkRoom wrote: »

I use PhD diet whey, Belgian chocolate or banana flavours are nice. I blend it with water and double (heavy) cream. Turn out pretty nice. Mine are 5.5g carbs so actually quite high compared to some others here. But I have that for breakfast and i'm full until lunch or after most days now. Was a case of trial and error for me to find one that agreed with me

If you are splitting your carbs close to even at meals and just for ease of calcs say 21 total, so 7 each for breakfast, lunch, and dinner if you're no snacks. It's at 5.5 grams of carbs, so you're still easily in keto meal range. Just to offer perspective, because if you're using it as a meal replacement and not a supplement, I would expect that this level is totally fine. You'd just have to pay more attention to macros when adding it to something, but IMO, anything under 10 grams is doable if you're working it in to the rest of your dietary plan. More if you're not as carb restricted.

I have been using this: http://www.greatlakesgelatin.com/consumer/CollagenFAQ.php I find it's works very well in any liquid, has no carbs and seems to be helping my joints and skin condition. Which is why I chose it. I've been using it for about 3 months.

I drink quest protein powder every morning for breakfast, with water and one serving of peanut butter for extra fat and a little fiber. I mix it up in my nutribullet. It tastes awesome and fills me up until lunch.

baconslave wrote: »

I'm looking for a new one myself. I got an unflavored one. Blurg. It's "unflavor" shined through regardless of what I added.

Mine is 'unflavoured' also. It's revolting, but only has half a gram of carbs per 100g of powder. It is a whey isolate made here in New Zealand and our cows aren't fed growth hormones etc. Supposed to be a pretty good powder.

A great unflavored protein powder is Genepro, found on Amazon. The serving size is about a tablespoon and gives 30g protein and I think only 1-2g carbs

I also use inspire protein powder from bariatriceating.com
They have many flavors as well as unflavored. Around 90-100 cals w 20 G protein and 1-3 grams carbs. Just caution if you put a large order in... Last time I had 5 items they only shipped one and their customer service is the WORST! It took 6 weeks to get the rest of the order. I never had that problem in the past with them. But now I'm hesitant to order again.