Low protein

Bob314159
Bob314159 Posts: 1,178 Member
edited November 26 in Social Groups
My protein goals are 100, but ending up more like 60. Fat and carb are usually close to target. If I increase protein I have to cut fat to stay within a 1445 kcal limit.

Goals are carb 25g=7%, fat 105g=35%, protein 100g=28%

What are the potential problems of having my protein low?

I'm 244 lbs, down from 270 in May - on Keto 3 months

My exercise is low, I walk 5k a day, do kettlebells 20 mins 2 or 3 times a week





Replies

  • wabmester
    wabmester Posts: 2,748 Member
    The only potential problem is loss of muscle mass. It happens with all weight loss, but the goal of exercise and protein consumption is to minimize the loss.

    At 25g carbs, you will also burn protein to make up for a glucose deficit, so your 60g are equivalent to maybe 45g for somebody eating more carbs.

    I had trouble making my protein goal, too. And I was eating 3 eggs for breakfast, for example. I needed to add some cheese. Nuts and meat help. I refuse to eat protein powder or protein bars.
  • This content has been removed.
  • Mistizoom
    Mistizoom Posts: 578 Member
    The simple solution is to cut the fat a bit if you want to increase protein and keep calories and carbs the same.

  • Bob314159
    Bob314159 Posts: 1,178 Member
    edited November 2015
    I'm doing Keto primarily for brain effects of consuming MCT/Coconut oil, so I won't rush to decrease the 5 tbpspoons I have a day, until I do further research - it's possible 3 per day will still work, but I don't think that give me much more grams of protein.

    I'm not discounting the importance of weight loss - I need to lost at least 50 more lbs.

    As my physical/exersize status improved, I might get to a point where I actually can burn more cals - my trainer says I'm not near that level yet.

    My main protein source is cheese, also eggs and fish, meat is harder to fit in since the rest of family eats meat dishes with lost of carbs.
  • Dragonwolf
    Dragonwolf Posts: 5,600 Member
    Why are your calories so low? 1400 is low even for a rather petite woman. A man -- even one the height of petite woman -- should be able to run another couple hundred, at least, even before exercise.

    Also, something isn't right if your fat and carb macros are right and your calories are right, but you're 40g shy on protein. Either something isn't reporting its nutrients correctly, or something's off on your totals more than you're letting on. The way MFP calculates the goals, it's impossible to be 40g under on anything when the other macros and calories are on point.

    Trade the cheese for meat. Learn to make meat dishes that don't require a ton of carbs or don't have the carbs built in -- steak, pork chops, etc. Pinterest is your friend on that front. Cheese is actually a rather poor source of protein, relatively speaking.

    Also, check out Andrew Scarborough's stuff. He does a strict, animals-only, ketogenic diet (to deal with brain cancer that he used to have) and has a bunch of creative stuff for it.
  • FIT_Goat
    FIT_Goat Posts: 4,224 Member
    I am a short man. Like really short (163 cm). I started at a lighter weight than you currently are. I tried to average 1800+ calories a day, and I lost a good amount each week doing that. Even when I stopped setting a calorie goal, I averaged around 1900-2000 calories a day and still lost consistently.

    It might be a lot easier if you upped your calorie goal a bit. I doubt you need it so low.
  • SamandaIndia
    SamandaIndia Posts: 1,577 Member
    Bob314159 wrote: »
    I'm doing Keto primarily for brain effects of consuming MCT/Coconut oil, so I won't rush to decrease the 5 tbpspoons I have a day, until I do further research - it's possible 3 per day will still work, but I don't think that give me much more grams of protein.

    I'm not discounting the importance of weight loss - I need to lost at least 50 more lbs.

    As my physical/exersize status improved, I might get to a point where I actually can burn more cals - my trainer says I'm not near that level yet.

    My main protein source is cheese, also eggs and fish, meat is harder to fit in since the rest of family eats meat dishes with lost of carbs.

    Meat with carbs is a great meal to deal with if it is not integral. Granted lasagne is a no go but steak and chips or chicken and mashed spuds is easily substituted for meat with veggies. Proteins help me feel full but agree with above, eggs and nuts are my new friends!
  • Dragonwolf
    Dragonwolf Posts: 5,600 Member
    Also, regarding the calorie limit and ketosis, Andrew happened to mention that he changed his caloric intake so that he could gain a little weight, so I asked him how much he normally eats, and he said he tries not to intentionally go below 1600, to give you a point of reference.



This discussion has been closed.