December 21 Sign In
RangerRickL
Posts: 8,469 Member
Did I exercise for at least 20 minutes?
Did I stay within my calorie budget for the day?
Did I keep track of everything I ate and drank?
Did I stay within my calorie budget for the day?
Did I keep track of everything I ate and drank?
0
Replies
-
I know that the Santa and reindeer in the snow images don't work for @craigo3154 and @Dory_42 , but here is a vintage indoor Santa workshop scene.
@craigo3154, we look forward to your carbohydrate and metabolism treatise.
5 -
December 21
Exercised?: Yes (3 km in 24 mins - hills)
Calories?: Yes
Tracked?: Yes
Late walk today after lunch with friends. Great to catch up.
Just before walking, my daughter requested to come walking, so I split into two walks, my 3km power walk (short circuit), then a further 2km with daughter at her pace so we could talk (well her talk and me listen ). When my daughter asks to walk, I know it's mainly to talk, so I will not let that pass unless COMPLETELY unavoidable. She knows I walk to help with my mental state, so she did not want to interfere with that.
@RangerRickL.
Metabolism repost (by request)
---
Have not soap boxed for a while but inspired to do so today.
Summary:
- Carbohydrates WITHOUT fibre spike blood sugar VERY rapidly
- The body switches to use FAT, ONLY when carbohydrate is depleted
- The QUICKEST way to burn FAT is to proportionally limit CARBOHYDRATE intake in your diet
This is what science has worked out on carbohydrate metabolism on a normal person.
When carbohydrate enters the digestive system it is broken down into glucose for absorption through the small intestine into the blood stream. Fibre slows down the absorption by moderating the speed at which carbohydrate leaves the stomach and disrupting the smooth flow of nutrients though the membranes in the small intestine. High blood sugar is detected by the pancreas and promotes the release of insulin from the beta cells. The pancreas alpha cells stop producing glucagon.
Insulin:
- ushers glucose into cells for immediate use
- signals the livers glycogen store to store excess glucose
- signals the body to combine the glucose molecules into fat from storage in the fat cell stores (adipose tissue) if unable to be used or stored in the livers glycogen store.
Glucagon:
- signals the livers glycogen store to release glucose into the blood stream.
- signals the fat cells to start releasing stored fat from the fat cell stores and breaks the fat into fatty acids for consumption by the cells for energy.
There are other back up systems (like ketosis) to get energy to the cells, but the insulin/glucagon system is the primary one to work and the quickest to change. (It takes multiple days on REALLY LOW insulin to switch the body into ketosis. Essentially the liver glycogen stores must be empty).
When glucose is consumed, the MAIN byproduct is CO2 and Water. BOTH are expelled with every breath.
When reducing FAT normally, it is converted to fatty acids then into acetyl CoA molecules that are consumed by the cells. This can ONLY occur once the blood sugars are low enough for the pancreas to produce glucagon to do it's magic (this is a GROSS over-simplification, but the nett affect is the same).
When acetyl CoA molecules are consumed, the MAIN byproduct is CO2 and Water. BOTH are expelled with every breath. (note the similarity with glucose).
You only need to breath (exhalation) to get rid of the waste products. Perspiration and urination are the other means of eliminating water.
Keeping the brain fuelled is the PRIMARY job of the digestive system. For most people, well over half the calories they burn in a day are consumed by the brain.
Why is all this important:
1) It is the excess calories CARBOHYDRATES, FATS and PROTEINS that make you gain weight.
2) CARBOHYDRATES are metabolised FIRST. Only when depleted does fat get metabolised.
3) FAT is metabolised as fatty acids and do not require insulin to get through the cell walls.
It takes time for the fat burning process to kick in. Lots of small meals per day (snacks), can slow down the fat burning process as the insulin levels remain high and the glucagon levels are not allowed to rise.
Processed carbohydrates (with fibre removed or reduced) hit you twice.
1) It is fibre, protein and fats that makes you feel full.
2) A large excess of glucose in the blood is more likely to be stored as fat in adipose tissue if the livers glycogen stores become full.
Reducing the frequency and proportional amount of carbohydrate (particularly processed carbohydrate) in your diet, you will lose weight faster.
The problem with processed carbohydrate is that they are:
- Traditionally comfort food
- Less filling so you are tempted to eat more
- Subsidised to produce (makes them cheap)
- Have a long shelf life (less loss in getting to market - makes them cheaper)
Long, high levels of insulin also lead to insulin resistance (Type 2 diabetes). There should be no mystery as to why the prevalence of processed food coincides with the Obesity/diabetes epidemic.
If you are struggling to lose weight. Look at your diet. How much do you eat (MFP tracking)? Is too much coming from carbohydrate that is not filling you up?
CICO works. However, it's hard to measure the output. But by measuring the input and tracking your weight a good estimate of the output can be derived.
Soap box away.
(I hope you learned something today )10 -
@craigo3154: great post! It exactly sums up my dieting experience. It is possible to lose weight eating anything & tracking calories (or WW points as I did in the past) but I was hungry, white knuckling the entire process. Eating whole foods, low carb, focusing on protein makes the whole thing easier, but harder socially. The science of why it works keeps me coming back to it as a healthier way of life. I also believe the science behind adequate protein in order to not lose lean muscle mass while eating at a calorie deficit.
I have not been posting because I had an early business trip that I allowed to kick me out of the winners circle as it was too hard to track. I will be with the resolution-ers & January will be my month!6 -
I had an unplanned pass day yesterday and today is the family Christmas get together... I have 1 pass left and I really do not want to use my last pass so I'm going to do an "IF" maneuver until dinner and eat selectively later exercise, drink tea, yada yada yada. I certainly have lots of reserve fuel from yesterday's outing.... I'm not hungry. 😊
Good luck to everyone!5 -
Did I exercise for at least 20 minutes? Yes, 60 minute easy walk.
Did I stay within my calorie budget for the day? Yes
Did I keep track of everything I ate and drank? Yes
4 -
I eat mostly unrefined carbs. No problem hitting my fibre goal each day. Monitor CICO by logging everything consumed, and balancing macros. Keeping active gives me a cushion for inaccuracies in calorie values. It seems to work the majority of the time. But it’s not an exact science. 😂
Over 20 mins exercise? ✅ 91 active Fitbit minutes (walking + Physio)
Under Calorie Gaol? ✅
Tracked? ✅
Remaining Pass Days? 2️⃣ out of 3️⃣
5 -
ECT all good for me. No so much yesterday. Today's exercise was walking with a friend and not too cold.4
-
Dec 21
Exercise: Yes, 40 minutes of hip therapy here at home plus on my feel all day cooking. Got in 6,000 steps and never left the house.........LOL
Calories: Yes, I was really good today ahead of a big party here tomorrow and no logging
Tracking: Yes
I won't be around tomorrow and will be taking my 2nd pass day..........see y'all Monday!5 -
Exercise: Y 19K steps including two 60 minute walks.
Calories: Y 1925/1800+ 713 exercise calories
Tracked:Y
Dipped into the exercise calories a little today.6 -
Tracked burned calories housecleaning stayed under5
-
12/21
Pass day
It's our Anniversary,plus we had a fellowship meal at our church.
I did exersize and log.5 -
12/21
Did I exercise for at least 20 minutes? Yes, two 20 minute sessions. First was a virtual hike in King's Canyon Natl. Park. Then another 20 minutes at the start of a movie we watched.
Did I stay within my calorie budget for the day? Yes
Did I keep track of everything I ate and drank? Yes
Happy Anniversary @stella7x7!4 -
@stella7x7 Happy Anniversary!
Exercise? Yes, 55 minute walk.
Within my calorie goal? Yeah.
Tracked everything? Completely.
New Fitbit is giving me significantly fewer exercise calories. Under 150 calories for 10k steps seems low (I'm on the "sedentary" activity level). Old Fitbit gave almost 300 calories on similar steps.3 -
Dec 21:
Exercise >20 minutes: Yes. 60 minutes elliptical. 50 mins boxing/core class.
Within kcal (<1800): Yes. 1732 kcal.
Track everything: Yes.
I tried a group class today and it was a pretty awful experience and defeating. I thought it was going to be primarily boxing, but it ended up being more than 50% core/low back stuff that I couldn’t do (low back issues). Why is the class called boxing if you spend less than 30% of the time boxing?!?!?! Ugh!
I’m glad I tried something new, but going to scratch group fitness classes from my new year resolutions. I’m definitely still too big/unfit for group classes. I’ll re-visit the idea mid-next year when I weigh less and hopefully a bit stronger3 -
Congratulations! @stella7x71 -
Surprising amount of exercise calories used outside today. Higher than normal temperatures even though it's the winter solstice,
Tracking; good
Calories: under my limit3 -
Did I exercise for at least 20 minutes? Was unable to workout this morning as my hubby and I wanted to get out early to drive up to South Lake Tahoe for the day. However, I got more than 10K steps just walking around the town and casinos, so I'm good on exercise!
Did I stay within my calorie budget for the day? Yes and under
Did I keep track of everything I ate and drank? Yep!2 -
I’m happy to report that I didn’t have to use a pass today in our Christmas family dinner. I earned 500 calories in exercise ahead of time. I ate a very light lunch of about 150 calories. Mostly chicken and veggies. At dinner, the calories were “spent” quickly. I enjoyed my faforite food, including desserts but I was selective and controlled. I waited 20 minutes for the “signal” to register in my brain before deciding or not to have another serving. I tracked everything including the chocolate covered toffee. I broke even with my daily calories and I still have 500 calories left from exercise. Macros were in the vicinity also. It was a good day.
👉Yes x3👈
I still have one pass left.
The kitchen is closed!3 -
craigo3154 wrote: »December 21
Exercised?: Yes (3 km in 24 mins - hills)
Calories?: Yes
Tracked?: Yes
Late walk today after lunch with friends. Great to catch up.
Just before walking, my daughter requested to come walking, so I split into two walks, my 3km power walk (short circuit), then a further 2km with daughter at her pace so we could talk (well her talk and me listen ). When my daughter asks to walk, I know it's mainly to talk, so I will not let that pass unless COMPLETELY unavoidable. She knows I walk to help with my mental state, so she did not want to interfere with that.
@RangerRickL.
Metabolism repost (by request)
---
Have not soap boxed for a while but inspired to do so today.
Summary:
- Carbohydrates WITHOUT fibre spike blood sugar VERY rapidly
- The body switches to use FAT, ONLY when carbohydrate is depleted
- The QUICKEST way to burn FAT is to proportionally limit CARBOHYDRATE intake in your diet
This is what science has worked out on carbohydrate metabolism on a normal person.
When carbohydrate enters the digestive system it is broken down into glucose for absorption through the small intestine into the blood stream. Fibre slows down the absorption by moderating the speed at which carbohydrate leaves the stomach and disrupting the smooth flow of nutrients though the membranes in the small intestine. High blood sugar is detected by the pancreas and promotes the release of insulin from the beta cells. The pancreas alpha cells stop producing glucagon.
Insulin:
- ushers glucose into cells for immediate use
- signals the livers glycogen store to store excess glucose
- signals the body to combine the glucose molecules into fat from storage in the fat cell stores (adipose tissue) if unable to be used or stored in the livers glycogen store.
Glucagon:
- signals the livers glycogen store to release glucose into the blood stream.
- signals the fat cells to start releasing stored fat from the fat cell stores and breaks the fat into fatty acids for consumption by the cells for energy.
There are other back up systems (like ketosis) to get energy to the cells, but the insulin/glucagon system is the primary one to work and the quickest to change. (It takes multiple days on REALLY LOW insulin to switch the body into ketosis. Essentially the liver glycogen stores must be empty).
When glucose is consumed, the MAIN byproduct is CO2 and Water. BOTH are expelled with every breath.
When reducing FAT normally, it is converted to fatty acids then into acetyl CoA molecules that are consumed by the cells. This can ONLY occur once the blood sugars are low enough for the pancreas to produce glucagon to do it's magic (this is a GROSS over-simplification, but the nett affect is the same).
When acetyl CoA molecules are consumed, the MAIN byproduct is CO2 and Water. BOTH are expelled with every breath. (note the similarity with glucose).
You only need to breath (exhalation) to get rid of the waste products. Perspiration and urination are the other means of eliminating water.
Keeping the brain fuelled is the PRIMARY job of the digestive system. For most people, well over half the calories they burn in a day are consumed by the brain.
Why is all this important:
1) It is the excess calories CARBOHYDRATES, FATS and PROTEINS that make you gain weight.
2) CARBOHYDRATES are metabolised FIRST. Only when depleted does fat get metabolised.
3) FAT is metabolised as fatty acids and do not require insulin to get through the cell walls.
It takes time for the fat burning process to kick in. Lots of small meals per day (snacks), can slow down the fat burning process as the insulin levels remain high and the glucagon levels are not allowed to rise.
Processed carbohydrates (with fibre removed or reduced) hit you twice.
1) It is fibre, protein and fats that makes you feel full.
2) A large excess of glucose in the blood is more likely to be stored as fat in adipose tissue if the livers glycogen stores become full.
Reducing the frequency and proportional amount of carbohydrate (particularly processed carbohydrate) in your diet, you will lose weight faster.
The problem with processed carbohydrate is that they are:
- Traditionally comfort food
- Less filling so you are tempted to eat more
- Subsidised to produce (makes them cheap)
- Have a long shelf life (less loss in getting to market - makes them cheaper)
Long, high levels of insulin also lead to insulin resistance (Type 2 diabetes). There should be no mystery as to why the prevalence of processed food coincides with the Obesity/diabetes epidemic.
If you are struggling to lose weight. Look at your diet. How much do you eat (MFP tracking)? Is too much coming from carbohydrate that is not filling you up?
CICO works. However, it's hard to measure the output. But by measuring the input and tracking your weight a good estimate of the output can be derived.
Soap box away.
(I hope you learned something today )
@craigo3154 Helpful - aligns with my experiences.
I’ve decided to go back to meat & veg only dinners2 -
Tracked - no
Calories - don't know
Exercise - Yes, 20 minutes running3 -
Yes x32
-
Yes x32
-
Yes x 32
-
Happy anniversary @stella7x7
Thanks for the info Craig. I know I need to cut down on carbs but find it harder to put into practice.
Pass. Had a lovely lunch with old friends. We had our first Christmas Dinner together 2 decades ago. Now it's a noisier and bigger group with husbands and lots of children. I didn't track, but I'm ok with that.1 -
Happy anniversary @stella7x7
Thanks for the info Craig. I know I need to cut down on carbs but find it harder to put into practice.
Pass. Had a lovely lunch with old friends. We had our first Christmas Dinner together 2 decades ago. Now it's a noisier and bigger group with husbands and lots of children. I didn't track, but I'm ok with that.
@am_change. Its actually not so much reducing carbs as ensuring your intake is less than your output. The carbs themselves are not filling (fibre, fats and protein are).
For a lot of people, the easiest way to reduce total intake is to:- Do not eat between meals.
- When eating, do so away from other distractions (like TV, internet, work, etc..), so you actually think about what you are eating.
- Portion out your food and put away excess before commencing to eat (this way you need to go out of your way to eat more).
Reducing things like sweet food (cookies, cake, soft-drink) and processed carbs (including processed wheat (flour), ie. bread, pizza, pasta) is VERY difficult. These foods are prevalent in our modern society due to being comfort food, long shelf life, cheap and subsidised to produce.
For me finding take away food is very difficult. Restaurant food is generally less of a problem, but less so than take away. Oddly enough gluten free is often the best option eating out (but not when the gluten free option is a wheat/flour/bread like replacement which is often terrible and best avoided).3 -
Pass 5
The scale today (Sunday) showed I'm 2 lbs up. The last couple days was hard. I should've made myself count my calories, but I was out of town yesterday and did not exercise.
Tomorrow is a new day.2 -
Pass day #5
Exercise: No
Calories:Yes
Tracked:Yes2 -
craigo3154 wrote: »Happy anniversary @stella7x7
Thanks for the info Craig. I know I need to cut down on carbs but find it harder to put into practice.
Pass. Had a lovely lunch with old friends. We had our first Christmas Dinner together 2 decades ago. Now it's a noisier and bigger group with husbands and lots of children. I didn't track, but I'm ok with that.
@am_change. Its actually not so much reducing carbs as ensuring your intake is less than your output. The carbs themselves are not filling (fibre, fats and protein are).
For a lot of people, the easiest way to reduce total intake is to:- Do not eat between meals.
- When eating, do so away from other distractions (like TV, internet, work, etc..), so you actually think about what you are eating.
- Portion out your food and put away excess before commencing to eat (this way you need to go out of your way to eat more).
Reducing things like sweet food (cookies, cake, soft-drink) and processed carbs (including processed wheat (flour), ie. bread, pizza, pasta) is VERY difficult. These foods are prevalent in our modern society due to being comfort food, long shelf life, cheap and subsidised to produce.
For me finding take away food is very difficult. Restaurant food is generally less of a problem, but less so than take away. Oddly enough gluten free is often the best option eating out (but not when the gluten free option is a wheat/flour/bread like replacement which is often terrible and best avoided).
Great advice thanks. Now just the hard job of following it!0 -
December 21
Exercised? YES - Crossfit Class
Tracked? YES
Calories? YES
Passes Used:0/3
1 -
Did I exercise for at least 20 minutes? No real exercise, just running around trying to get things done!
Did I stay within my calorie budget for the day? Yes
Did I keep track of everything I ate and drank? Yes1
This discussion has been closed.