We are pleased to announce that as of March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor has been introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!
General questions - Diet Break Strategies
duckiec
Posts: 241 Member
For both schedule (travel, and prep for a mud run) and sanity reasons, I've decided to do a diet break- I'm staying around maintenance this week. Or at least I think I am- my Fitbit is messed up from time changes, and my tracking is a lot more general than usual; not being obsessed with tracking is a big part of the mental break. I'm sure evening cocktails (which I haven't had all year) made me go over calories a day or two with no nutritional benefit. Fun, though!
Next week my schedule returns to more-or-less normal, then I have a vacation the following week. I was thinking of going back to usual deficit next week, then likely another break during vacation, I figure there's no reason to indulge with a normal schedule and no real food challenges in the "in between" week.
But, would going back and forth disrupt any of the physical benefits of the diet break? I figure I have three choices:
1) go back to usual deficit (which fairly strict - 750ish cals/deficit/day)
2) go back to a deficit, but less aggressive
3) stay on break, stay at/around maintenance.
Any input on which would work best in this scenario? I wasn't necessarily looking for a 3-week break; the scale's already up 5lbs which is freaking me out a bit. But if I'm gonna take a break, I want to maximize the physical benefits, and not just put on weight I'll have to take off later.
Oh, and exercise is not my normal routine either- finishing one program, doing mostly cardio (running) until I get back home after vaca and start something else.
Another question, too - importance of macros in diet breaks? As part of this is mental, there are a lot more "treat" foods (and margaritas) with negligable nutritional benefit. Is meeting my deficit macros (i.e. 100g protein) sufficient during a break, where some of the other calories get filled up with the fun stuff, or should I be focused on meeting the protein % goal for that higher calorie level? Fat and carbs shouldn't be a problem.
Thanks for any tips and input!
Next week my schedule returns to more-or-less normal, then I have a vacation the following week. I was thinking of going back to usual deficit next week, then likely another break during vacation, I figure there's no reason to indulge with a normal schedule and no real food challenges in the "in between" week.
But, would going back and forth disrupt any of the physical benefits of the diet break? I figure I have three choices:
1) go back to usual deficit (which fairly strict - 750ish cals/deficit/day)
2) go back to a deficit, but less aggressive
3) stay on break, stay at/around maintenance.
Any input on which would work best in this scenario? I wasn't necessarily looking for a 3-week break; the scale's already up 5lbs which is freaking me out a bit. But if I'm gonna take a break, I want to maximize the physical benefits, and not just put on weight I'll have to take off later.
Oh, and exercise is not my normal routine either- finishing one program, doing mostly cardio (running) until I get back home after vaca and start something else.
Another question, too - importance of macros in diet breaks? As part of this is mental, there are a lot more "treat" foods (and margaritas) with negligable nutritional benefit. Is meeting my deficit macros (i.e. 100g protein) sufficient during a break, where some of the other calories get filled up with the fun stuff, or should I be focused on meeting the protein % goal for that higher calorie level? Fat and carbs shouldn't be a problem.
Thanks for any tips and input!
0
Replies
-
But, would going back and forth disrupt any of the physical benefits of the diet break? I figure I have three choices:
1) go back to usual deficit (which fairly strict - 750ish cals/deficit/day)
2) go back to a deficit, but less aggressive
3) stay on break, stay at/around maintenance.
It won't matter which you chose in the long run. Personally, I'd go back to a normal deficit for the in-between week to mitigate some of the vacation damage.Another question, too - importance of macros in diet breaks? As part of this is mental, there are a lot more "treat" foods (and margaritas) with negligable nutritional benefit. Is meeting my deficit macros (i.e. 100g protein) sufficient during a break, where some of the other calories get filled up with the fun stuff, or should I be focused on meeting the protein % goal for that higher calorie level? Fat and carbs shouldn't be a problem.
Eat the amount of protein you've been eating. If anything, since you're not in a deficit, you could probably get away with a little less.0 -
Tagging to respond to later.0
This discussion has been closed.