Experiences with sourdough bread while keto?
solska
Posts: 348 Member
So I guess I'm late to figuring this out but I read quiet a bit about how if the fermentation process is long in making sourdough bread, all the sugar (carbs) in the bread will be eaten by the bacteria. And that this should not effect low carb diets. I wonder if people have tried/experienced this and seen how it effected their bloodsugar, weight loss, keto state etc.
0
Replies
-
It may have fewer carbs and sugars than other breads but it's still way too high in my opinion. One slice of that would mean absolutely zero other carbs for the day and that's a no go for me. I need my veggies.1
-
Generally you are making bread with sourdough starter - and you still add flour and additional sugar when you mix the actual bread dough...so, even assuming zero carbs in the starter, you are going to end up with a lot of carbs in the bread...though I'm sure low-carb versions exist.0
-
uhm, no lol
1 -
I've never been a bread maker and never really ate that much anyway. Well, not true. Soup and bread (or crackers) with a pile of butter. Multiple crackers and big, big piles of butter. How could I have forgotten. Soup will never be the same now.
Here's a site where you can find some LC breads.
http://www.shop.greatlowcarb.com/Great-Low-Carb-Sourdough-Bread-793936945940.htm1 -
tcunbeliever wrote: »Generally you are making bread with sourdough starter - and you still add flour and additional sugar when you mix the actual bread dough...so, even assuming zero carbs in the starter, you are going to end up with a lot of carbs in the bread...though I'm sure low-carb versions exist.
The idea is the during the fermentation process the bacteria in the starter eat the carbs/sugars in the flour.0 -
tcunbeliever wrote: »Generally you are making bread with sourdough starter - and you still add flour and additional sugar when you mix the actual bread dough...so, even assuming zero carbs in the starter, you are going to end up with a lot of carbs in the bread...though I'm sure low-carb versions exist.
The idea is the during the fermentation process the bacteria in the starter eat the carbs/sugars in the flour.
Yeah, no. It won't eat nearly enough carbs. If you ever home-brewed beer, wine, or any other alcohol, you would know how much gas gets put off and how long it takes to get even the majority of the sugars fermented. It is wishful thinking to believe that sourdough is better than any other bread.1 -
Here is a commercial loaf nutrition list: https://ndb.nal.usda.gov/ndb/foods/show/8186?manu=&fgcd=&ds=Standard Reference0
-
tcunbeliever wrote: »Generally you are making bread with sourdough starter - and you still add flour and additional sugar when you mix the actual bread dough...so, even assuming zero carbs in the starter, you are going to end up with a lot of carbs in the bread...though I'm sure low-carb versions exist.
The idea is the during the fermentation process the bacteria in the starter eat the carbs/sugars in the flour.
Even if 100% of the carbs in the flour are consumed in the sourdough STARTER - you don't make sourdough bread with only starter...generally you make sourdough bread with a cup of starter and about 3 cups of flour (plus sugar, salt, milk, butter, etc)...and then you bake it and fermentation is halted, so there's no time for the carbs/flour from the bread making process to be consumed...fermentation is only occurring within the starter, not within the bread itself.0 -
try making low carb tortillas with cream cheese...they are not bad at all. Plus it gives you the satisfaction of eating a break like food. Only a couple of carbs per tortilla.0
-
tcunbeliever wrote: »tcunbeliever wrote: »Generally you are making bread with sourdough starter - and you still add flour and additional sugar when you mix the actual bread dough...so, even assuming zero carbs in the starter, you are going to end up with a lot of carbs in the bread...though I'm sure low-carb versions exist.
The idea is the during the fermentation process the bacteria in the starter eat the carbs/sugars in the flour.
Even if 100% of the carbs in the flour are consumed in the sourdough STARTER - you don't make sourdough bread with only starter...generally you make sourdough bread with a cup of starter and about 3 cups of flour (plus sugar, salt, milk, butter, etc)...and then you bake it and fermentation is halted, so there's no time for the carbs/flour from the bread making process to be consumed...fermentation is only occurring within the starter, not within the bread itself.
Yes, very skeptical myself about it which is why I wondered if anyone had an experience with it. What I read considers the bacteria in the yeast (not starter) eating up the carbs in the flour... and a very long fermentation process, kinda how sugar in kombucha is eaten up eventually. Here is some of that http://www.lowcarbsite.com/showthread.php/13526-Sourdough0 -
misskitty2018 wrote: »try making low carb tortillas with cream cheese...they are not bad at all. Plus it gives you the satisfaction of eating a break like food. Only a couple of carbs per tortilla.
Yes, I love those and fat head pizza etc.0 -
Can't blame you @solska. I miss the scent of freshly toasted sourdough bread.1
-
I wonder if it would be possible to develop a bread recipe that used a sourdough starter that was still low carb, but tasted a little more like real sourdough? Hmmm....1
-
-
Oh my. A 9x5 pan results 16 slices and 200 CALORIES per slice.
0 -
No experience with this at all, but it may be worth a try - a very precise picky recipe though, and ingredients must be weighed and not measured with cups. https://www.lowcarbmaven.com/the-best-psyllium-flax-bread/
A slice is 127 cal, 3 net carbs (10 minus 7 fibre)1 -
Daisy Brackenhall just put up her Seed and Nut loaf, looks dense and yummy: https://www.ketogenicforums.com/t/seed-nut-loaf/126362
-
canadjineh wrote: »No experience with this at all, but it may be worth a try - a very precise picky recipe though, and ingredients must be weighed and not measured with cups. https://www.lowcarbmaven.com/the-best-psyllium-flax-bread/
A slice is 127 cal, 3 net carbs (10 minus 7 fibre)
I don't mind weighing....Just keep forgetting to pick up the psyllium husk powder. May just have to break down and order it on Amazon...Then I'd have it in 2 days! LOL0 -
canadjineh wrote: »No experience with this at all, but it may be worth a try - a very precise picky recipe though, and ingredients must be weighed and not measured with cups. https://www.lowcarbmaven.com/the-best-psyllium-flax-bread/
A slice is 127 cal, 3 net carbs (10 minus 7 fibre)
I've had different results with different recipes. One with hoagies worked well.0
This discussion has been closed.