We are pleased to announce that on March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor will be introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the upcoming changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!
Determining your calorie goal
DanaW13
Posts: 207 Member
I know there are a lot of discussions out there about this on MFP, but I figured I would broach this topic since we're are all in the same boat if having about 15 or less pounds to lose. I have been using the MFP goal which puts me at 1280 to lose 1 pound per week (my current weigh is 133 lbs). This is with a light activity lifestyle (SAHM of two young kids). And when I work out I eat the extra calories (I run about 4 times per week and each time burn about 400 calories).
I was wondering what everyone else is doing? Do you use the MFP estimate or is there a website you use? Do you eat all your exercise calories?
I was wondering what everyone else is doing? Do you use the MFP estimate or is there a website you use? Do you eat all your exercise calories?
0
Replies
-
Honestly, I hadn't been paying much attention to it. I eat at a cafeteria, and it turns out if I just have the normal main meal serving, some fruit and vegetables each meal, I lose weight at a decent rate. However, I'm not allowed to eat there for the next month, so I plan to do the -1.5 pounds per week number + eating back exercised calories until I'm back.0
-
I calculated my TDEE using varying websites (they all give a slightly different number but I generalized). My TDEE should be around 2000 per day. So, I settled for 1750cals and logging EVERYTHING and accurately (weigh every solid that goes in and measure every liquid). I went from 149.5 to 146.6 in 1.5 weeks. It's a bit too rapid for me (would like to drop 0.5lbs per week) so I'm guessins my TDEE is higher than 2000. The best numbers are your results!!
Once I figure my "real" TDEE, i'll eat as close as possible everyday for minimal weight loss while still doing weights in the gym to lose body fat% and not lean muscle mass.
At least that's how I am doing it
0 -
G01, that's great you can do it without counting! I have to count or I just eat too much. Thanks for the info Gen. I tried a TDEE website and got a higher number than what MFP gives me. I don't know though, I'm afraid to go up! I'll stick with my current number for a couple weeks and see how it goes.0
-
G01, that's great you can do it without counting! I have to count or I just eat too much. Thanks for the info Gen. I tried a TDEE website and got a higher number than what MFP gives me. I don't know though, I'm afraid to go up! I'll stick with my current number for a couple weeks and see how it goes.
It's normal that you got a higher number. MFP doesnt calculate any exercice so if you tell MFP you want to lose 1lbs per week, it gives you a number. Then you log exercice and he goes "well you told me that you wanted to lose 1lbs, so now that you burned some calories, eat them back!"..
I hope I am making sense And I get that you're afraid to go up. I was too!! What's your calorie per day goal right now? 0 -
I know there are a lot of discussions out there about this on MFP, but I figured I would broach this topic since we're are all in the same boat if having about 15 or less pounds to lose. I have been using the MFP goal which puts me at 1280 to lose 1 pound per week (my current weigh is 133 lbs). This is with a light activity lifestyle (SAHM of two young kids). And when I work out I eat the extra calories (I run about 4 times per week and each time burn about 400 calories).
I was wondering what everyone else is doing? Do you use the MFP estimate or is there a website you use? Do you eat all your exercise calories?
Thanks for posting this - I'm using the MFP goal too (1320 currently to lose 1lb per week) . I eat back most of my exercise calories, though it took me a few months to realise I was supposed to! I'm wondering about switching my goal to 1/2 lb a week so I have a few more calories as on days I don't exercise I can get hungry.0 -
Gen--even after taking exercise into account, MFP gives me about 300 less calories. Right now my calorie goal per day is 1280, and in addition I get on average 250-300 exercise calories (so total is about 1550 per day). When I did an online TDEE estimate I got 2350 calories for maintenance (including exercise as you said). 80% of that is 1880. So still a big difference, if I am doing this right?
Heleahic--yes a .5 pound loss per week is not a bad way to go--better for long term maintenance! My goal is still a pound per week because I am impatient...0 -
I took bmr of 1300 and added 200 cal.
My tdee is 1800 but so unsure coz my days are much different.
1500 is pretty enough food and I lose inches, some weight too.
165 cm
Sw 58.5
Cw 57
Gw 55 prolly.. I m not sure, using mirror
I lift weight and walk uphill 3 times a week
Not eating cal back mainly0 -
Dana: honestly I find MFP's calorie goals a little low. But, that's just me. I have done a LOT of reading on this site and I found that for me, calculating TDEE and eating close to that works a lot better (for my mood and for my body) to eat closer to that while still being in a deficit. It's all a game of trial and error and consistency and accuracy 0
-
Gen--it sounds like you track really accurately and have been able to find your best number. I have not been as good tracking but have gotten better the past couple weeks, so I will take your advice and see if you can come to some conclusions 0
-
Dana: keep me posted if you want!!! I would be happy to help if I can:flowerforyou: 0
-
Thanks Gen, I appreciate it. I've had two weeks now of good tracking, so I think I may soon be able to tell what really works for me. 0
