We are pleased to announce that as of March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor has been introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!
Hunger and when to eat
MissMaggie3
Posts: 2,464 Member
I have a couple of questions about hunger and calories, and would really appreciate some advice.
I'm a newbie, and I've just finished week 3 of stage 1. The hunger has really taken me by surprise - I am getting SO hungry, but not on the days I lift. I'm messing with the rules, in that I'm using the hunger as my guide rather than stick to the schedule of when I'm supposed to eat extra. Before I started this, I was maintaining on 1650, but working out a lot - circuit training, cardio etc - and always eating back my exercise calories. I'm now going over 1650 on lifting days a bit, typically by about just 100 cals I think, but on rest days I need - and I mean NEED - 300, 400 or even 500+ extra calories. I'm doing fairly gentle cardio on rest days, so I can end up with net calories of around 2300.
My first question is, should I force myself to eat extra on lifting days, or keep on using the signals my body gives me? I thought I was gaining weight, but now I seem to be the same as I was on maintenance, but I have noticed a little extra loose skin (eek!). So presumably I am gaining muscle in places. I lift in the evening, so was wondering if I'm 'carrying over' the need for extra calories for that reason.
My second question is, do you think I should assume a maintenance level higher than it was? I'm about right with the estimates according to the book (and how my body was previously), but I kind of feel my metabolism has quickly responded to the programme.
If it helps, I'm 5' 4" and I currently weigh 114 pounds. I'm age 53. I'm just about hitting the 30% protein requirement, but some days only manage 28% or 29%.
P.S. So sorry if you are seeing this in 2 different places - wasn't sure where to post.
I'm a newbie, and I've just finished week 3 of stage 1. The hunger has really taken me by surprise - I am getting SO hungry, but not on the days I lift. I'm messing with the rules, in that I'm using the hunger as my guide rather than stick to the schedule of when I'm supposed to eat extra. Before I started this, I was maintaining on 1650, but working out a lot - circuit training, cardio etc - and always eating back my exercise calories. I'm now going over 1650 on lifting days a bit, typically by about just 100 cals I think, but on rest days I need - and I mean NEED - 300, 400 or even 500+ extra calories. I'm doing fairly gentle cardio on rest days, so I can end up with net calories of around 2300.
My first question is, should I force myself to eat extra on lifting days, or keep on using the signals my body gives me? I thought I was gaining weight, but now I seem to be the same as I was on maintenance, but I have noticed a little extra loose skin (eek!). So presumably I am gaining muscle in places. I lift in the evening, so was wondering if I'm 'carrying over' the need for extra calories for that reason.
My second question is, do you think I should assume a maintenance level higher than it was? I'm about right with the estimates according to the book (and how my body was previously), but I kind of feel my metabolism has quickly responded to the programme.
If it helps, I'm 5' 4" and I currently weigh 114 pounds. I'm age 53. I'm just about hitting the 30% protein requirement, but some days only manage 28% or 29%.
P.S. So sorry if you are seeing this in 2 different places - wasn't sure where to post.
0
Replies
-
I can only tell you what happens to me- about 2 weeks in my appetite went nuts too, esp on the day after lifting. Now it's like this daily!
The book recommends a weigh in 4 weeks into the prog- you should be the same weight if eating maintenance. If not, adjust your basic cals.
As long as you're not getting bigger in the waist, you're OK!
0 -
good to know LOL0
This discussion has been closed.