We are pleased to announce that as of March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor has been introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!
stupid smith machine question
Lyadeia
Posts: 4,603 Member
Monday morning, I had a lot of things to do and couldn't go to my normal gym for my workout. Instead I had to use the equipment at work which is laughable at best. It was bench press day, and the ONLY thing available was a damned Smith machine...
Last week when I was at the gym, I did 2 sets of 5 reps with 95 pounds and a final set of 6 reps with 95 pounds. I intended to increase the weight this week since I keep my compound lifts at 5 reps.
This week, I used that Smith machine...which was kinda uncomfortable trying to figure out how to situate myself to get somewhere near my normal range of motion, but I digress...and loaded it with 100 pounds and was able to do 8-10 reps on all the 3 sets.
So my question is this:
Next Monday when it is time to do more bench presses, and I am at my gym and using a real bench and bar instead of that silly machine, should I drop back to 95 pounds or use 100 pounds? I ask this because I know that without that dumb machine, I wouldn't have done as many reps with the more weight because there's no need to fire up assisting/stabilizing muscles, or even core muscles. So, I don't know if I should be happy that my new 1RM was calculated to be 120ish or if I should not even bother recording it since it wasn't actually the exact same exercise (if you know what I mean).
Your thoughts?
---And just because I was annoyed with a smith machine being in my workplace's gym, I did increase my dumbbell bench press and chest fly weight to compensate. I do those exercises (as well as push-ups) after the bench. And since I increased weight on those exercises, I am confused as to whether the gains on bench were real or whether or not I just wasn't tired from the smith crap.
---Sorry for the silly question. I just don't want to look like an *kitten* on next Monday at my gym if I load up 100 pounds and can't actually push it and need a meat head to help me get it off my chest, lol. :flowerforyou:
Last week when I was at the gym, I did 2 sets of 5 reps with 95 pounds and a final set of 6 reps with 95 pounds. I intended to increase the weight this week since I keep my compound lifts at 5 reps.
This week, I used that Smith machine...which was kinda uncomfortable trying to figure out how to situate myself to get somewhere near my normal range of motion, but I digress...and loaded it with 100 pounds and was able to do 8-10 reps on all the 3 sets.
So my question is this:
Next Monday when it is time to do more bench presses, and I am at my gym and using a real bench and bar instead of that silly machine, should I drop back to 95 pounds or use 100 pounds? I ask this because I know that without that dumb machine, I wouldn't have done as many reps with the more weight because there's no need to fire up assisting/stabilizing muscles, or even core muscles. So, I don't know if I should be happy that my new 1RM was calculated to be 120ish or if I should not even bother recording it since it wasn't actually the exact same exercise (if you know what I mean).
Your thoughts?
---And just because I was annoyed with a smith machine being in my workplace's gym, I did increase my dumbbell bench press and chest fly weight to compensate. I do those exercises (as well as push-ups) after the bench. And since I increased weight on those exercises, I am confused as to whether the gains on bench were real or whether or not I just wasn't tired from the smith crap.
---Sorry for the silly question. I just don't want to look like an *kitten* on next Monday at my gym if I load up 100 pounds and can't actually push it and need a meat head to help me get it off my chest, lol. :flowerforyou:
0
Replies
-
I would treat your bench press progression as if the smith machine workout never occurred.0
-
That was pretty much what I was thinking, but I just wanted to make sure. Thanks!0
-
Locking as this looks to have been resolved Let one of us know if you want to add anything and we can unlock. Please include a link to the thread in the PM.0
This discussion has been closed.