Winter comfort food cravings - Mad Hatter Survival Tips!

Snooozie
Snooozie Posts: 3,464 Member
Good morning Hatters!

Since returning to the bitter cold temps I've noticed my cravings for "comfort food" have returned as well.. and I think perhaps some other Hatters are in the same boat? I found an article that seems to indicate its a phsyiological response from our bodies, whih is reassuringg at least that its a normal reaction during the winter, but not all that helpful when you're trying to lose weight :laugh:

I thought I'd share it in case its of any help to anyone else, but also thought I'd ask if any Hatters have any strategies or tips they've found useful to keep the cravings under contgrol, or incorporate the need for increased carbs in inventive and healthy ways?

I think my own stratetgy will be to make sure I include some of my comfort foods, but will find healthier versions of them and use appys and snacks like soups and "filling" choices so I eat smaller portions of my favs.. but would love to hear any thoughts, ideas, tips etc from the rest of the Hatters - making our own winter survival strategies! :bigsmile: Here's the article:




As temperatures fall, experts say, our winter appetites can spin out of control.

And while a heartier appetite for a few months out of the year may not seem like such a big deal, it can be when we end up gaining weight year in and year out. Many people who are around 50 years old are also around 30 to 35 pounds heavier than they were when they graduated high school -- and those pounds are roughly equal to 30 winters of a heartier appetite :sad: -- so it really does add up," says McAllister, a family practice medicine specialist from Lexington, Ky.

But what is it about frostier temperatures that drive us to eat more? Experts say there are a number of factors at work.

It's cold. Days are shorter, and nights are longer. When winter hits, cravings for comfort foods increase. And unfortunately, few of us find comfort in whole wheat pita bread and carrot sticks!

"As soon as temperatures drop, our appetite goes up for high-calorie, high-carbohydrate foods -- stews, mashed potatoes, mac and cheese -- the dishes that make us feel warm and cozy," says Barrie Wolf-Radbille, MS, RD, a nutritionist with the New York University Program for Surgical Weight Loss.

"Simply put, when outdoor temperatures drop, your body temperature drops, and that's what sets up the longing for foods that will warm you quickly," says Kristin Herlocker MS, RD, a nutrition expert with Diabetes Centers of America in Houston.

In short, she says, feeling cold triggers a self-preservation mode that sends the body a message to heat up fast. And that message is often played out as a craving for carbohydrate-rich foods -- the sugars and starches that provide the instant "heat" boost your body is longing for.Moreover, McAllister says, when we give in to those cravings for sugary, starchy foods, blood sugar spikes and then falls, setting up a cycle that keeps the appetite in motion.:frown:

"We get hungrier quicker, so we reach for more high-carbohydrate 'fillers,' and the vicious cycle is on," says McAllister.

There's also a cultural stigma influencing our winter food choices. "Technically, any food will boost your metabolism and help your body temperature to rise, but culturally, we're not trained to think of salads or fruits and vegetables as winter eating -- first, because there's less of them around, but also because we associate winter with richer, heavier meals, going back to when we were children," she says. So, when your body sends the message, "Warm me up" your brain hears, "Bring on the mac and cheese.":noway:

Of course, winter also means holiday parties, and wheelbarrows full of the very foods we're craving. "Not only does the winter season set us up to crave these higher-calorie foods, but the holidays put them in front of us, usually in great abundance

The Dark Days of Dieting

While for some it's falling temperatures that sets appetites in motion, for others, it's the decrease in sunlight.

"Up to 6% of the population suffers from SAD -- a type of depression caused by a lack of exposure to light," says McAllister. SAD is Seasonal Affective Disorder that occurs the same time each year as the days are shorter, but goes away as the days get longer in spring and summer. Besides shorter days and a decrease of light in the winter, other causes include problems with the body's biological clock or in levels of the brain chemical serotonin.

But it's not just light that those with SAD crave. McAllister says it's also carbohydrates -- and lots of them. The reason?

"People who are affected with SAD have lower blood levels of serotonin," she says. "Not surprisingly, those carbohydrate-rich foods give us a serotonin rush, so for many people, winter food cravings are a way of self-medicating."

But even if you don't have full-blown SAD, your eating habits can be affected by shorter days and longer nights.:cry:

"When it gets dark out early, people stay in more, so they feel more isolated and usually more hungry," "Seasons affect moods and moods affect our eating patterns, so when it's dark and gloomy, people just tend to eat more."

At the same time, winter can cut into physical activity. Not only do shorter days and colder weather reduce our outdoor time, but in many locations, snow and ice make our normal fitness activities impossible. Since exercise helps increase serotonin levels, McAllister says the lack of activity is a double whammy: "If we're not exercising, our appetite increases, and ultimately that means we're eating more and moving less -- and that's a disaster plan for weight gain."

Despite all these appetite-boosting factors, experts say you can take control. With a little bit of planning, you can keep your life and your appetite in perfect harmony all year long. Some suggestions.



1. Have a Healthy Snack.

Eat a high-protein, high-fiber snack between meals -- like some peanut butter on a whole wheat cracker, or low-fat cheese on a slice of wheat bread. Healthy snacking will fuel your body's heat mechanism, helping keep you warmer. The warmer we remain in cold weather, says Herlocker, the less we crave carbs.

2. Make a Winter Activity Plan.

Even if it's already mid-winter, Wolfe-Radbill says take a pen to paper and list all the things you did in spring and summer, then write a corresponding list of winter activities you could do. Not only does exercise burn calories, it also affects brain chemicals linked to appetite, so it can help control how much you eat, McAllister says.

3. Create Low-Calorie Comforts.

If you know you're going to crave those wintry comfort foods, find lower-cal ways to do it. Mac and cheese made with low-fat cheese, steamy pizza with veggies and a whole wheat crust, a bowl of vegetable soup, cocoa with non-fat milk -- be creative in cutting calories while keeping the comfort.

4. Get a Daily Dose of Light.

If you think your food cravings may be related to shorter days, try to spend at least some time outdoors in sunlight every day. If that's not possible, talk to your doctor about light therapy -- a way of increasing serotonin levels through exposure to artificial light.

5. Keep a Lid on Seasonal Goodies.

That's not just a figure of speech. Keep rich treats left over from the holidays out of direct eye view, McAllister says. If someone has brought you goodies as a gift, say thanks, without sampling.
«1

Replies

  • SunnyLynnie
    SunnyLynnie Posts: 87 Member
    Hey Snoozer! As you have seen from my food diaries, I DO have my comfort foods, but I make light versions (cookinglight.com or cleaneating.com are two excellent resources). So I can have my chicken pot pie and eat it too! Thanks for your post! Now to get back to my marking. :grumble:
  • seehe
    seehe Posts: 946 Member
    Thanks Snoozie for the helpful tips! We are having very inconsistent weather here. I practically froze to death while you were gone, then it was in the 80's F for several days, and now its raining and going to continue to rain for a week and be in the low 60's. Crazy! Maybe our weather is going through menopause?!?

    Note to anybody who wants to see the fantastic photos of Snoozie's adventure in Costa Rica, they are posted in the previous thread:-)
  • Snooozie
    Snooozie Posts: 3,464 Member
    Ty for the sites lassie!! Gonna have to try some conversions for sure. Mmmm chicken pot pie!
  • Snooozie
    Snooozie Posts: 3,464 Member
    Rofl on the weather menopause!! Mother Nature IS a woman after all so I think you might be right Susan !
  • Thanks for the interesting post. I do struggle in the winter- have not handled the cravings well, but will keep reading others' tips to get back on track.
  • cbmcphillips
    cbmcphillips Posts: 801 Member
    Rofl on the weather menopause!! Mother Nature IS a woman after all so I think you might be right Susan !


    :laugh: :laugh: :laugh: :laugh: :laugh:

    :laugh: :grumble: :sad: :bigsmile: :huh: :huh:

    Carol
  • cbmcphillips
    cbmcphillips Posts: 801 Member
    side zip pants + 6 glasses of water..... hmmmm. what was she thinking????:laugh:
  • Snooozie
    Snooozie Posts: 3,464 Member
    :laugh: @ cbm.... that there was no chance a zipper will ever get stuck while we are desperate to hit the litter box??? LOLOL too funny!
  • bisland
    bisland Posts: 245 Member
    Thank you for the post Snooozie. All great tips. I do not want to wish my life away, but do look foreward to the warmer weather and longer days of spring. I so enjoyed my early AM walks or jogs as a way to start my day. It seemed to lead to healthy choices for the rest of the day and to lower my stress level.

    I am thinking of setting up some goals for myself, Maybe put $1 in a jar everytime I exercise for 30 minutes, then treat myself to a manicure when I have enough. Does anyone do anything like this? Any ideas???
  • cbmcphillips
    cbmcphillips Posts: 801 Member
    :laugh: @ cbm.... that there was no chance a zipper will ever get stuck while we are desperate to hit the litter box??? LOLOL too funny!

    and the belt...that came with the pants....made of matching fabric.... too long... had to take off every time I needed to use the ladies room for fear of it falling in the toilet - since the pants only had one flimsy loop on the one side for the belt to hang onto...onto.....:laugh: :laugh:
  • cbmcphillips
    cbmcphillips Posts: 801 Member
    On a more serious note ... Tonya - our thoughts and prayers go out to you.....

    Carol
  • Snooozie
    Snooozie Posts: 3,464 Member
    Morning Hatters!

    Woke up to my Keurig not working; had to do an emerg run to Tim's to get a coffee then back to call customer service... fortunately they walked me thru some stuff and got me working again.. phew!! Being a coffee fanatic, I always used to keep a spare machine and carafe around when I used a brewer just in case, but since I went to the Keurig I relaized I dont have a backup anymore LOL.. I freely admit I just threw on a pair of jeans over my jammies to make the run.....the whole way remembering my mom always saying make sure you have clean underwear on just in case of an accident.. wonder what they'd think of jammies if it ever came to pass :embarassed:

    I hopped on thte scale this morningjust for a check up since I weighed when I got back - the few pounds from vacation are gone already (pretty sure that isnt due to my efforts, just the fact that NOT sitting on a beach drinking all day might be the reason its gone!!??) but hopefully by next sched weigh in next week there will be an additional drop; I'm thinking of changing my weekly sched to Monday as I start nightshift then... might need the encouragement that morning as that shift plays havoc with my eating habits!

    Bis: I DO use a reward system for myself, but as I havent really had a lot of loss lately (which is gonna change now that I'm back and ready to focus on my goals!) but I tend to go in amounts i.e. when I hit 10lbs I treated myself to a new book I wanted). I might switch it up now considering your idea.. perhaps start putting $ in my vacation kitty for next year every time I lose a pound! :bigsmile:

    I'be been living off stuff in the freezer since I got back so need to do a big grocery run today; will be burning a few calories doing all the laundry and packing stuff away and cleaning the pit here - hope everyone is having a good day AND tgif for some!!
  • hairsprayhon
    hairsprayhon Posts: 334 Member
    I'm back! Not quite the vacation that Snoozie had but it was nice to be warm in Florida where the temps were from 60 to 79, perfect tennis weather. And it was great having Greg along to play. My dad's wife comments on every aspect of my weight and monitors my food intake. When we met a friend who said I looked good, she said "this is the third time she's lost weight since I've known her so I don't know how long this will last". I just said, "I have never been close to this weight in the 10 years I've known you and I am staying fit forever" Greg and I then spent 2 days in Clearwater because my daughter was accepting an award. I had never been to the gulf coast and it was beautiful. I thought we would be able to swim but it was too cold, instead we walked miles on the gorgeous beaches. Coming home to temps in the teens and snow on the ground was a lot different from when I left. Driving home from the airport, you could see lots of purple lights on buildings as Baltimore prepares for the Super Bowl. A lot of people did not take down their Christmas tree so as to keep things the same as when they watched the playoff games. We are one of those families. And even though I don't watch the game I do the cooking and I can't mess with the vibe, so even when visiting my dad I made crab cakes before the game and berry cobbler for half time. The plant city strawberries are even better when you eat them in Florida on the day they were picked. I thought this was blood orange time, but I missed that season.
    Hope everyone is doing well, I will catch up with the posts!
  • seehe
    seehe Posts: 946 Member
    WELCOME BACK JANET!
    So happy you had a great time:-) I so envy you and Snoozie's walks on the beach.
    I am a fish
    images_edited-1_zpse07bafc6.jpg

    living a Desert Rat's existence
    DesertRatIcon_zps9a51a6ef.jpg


    As far as your dad's wife, this is what good Ol' Benjamin has to say about that....


    Any fool can criticize, condemn and complain - and most fools do.
    mzibloftffh_zps867819dc.jpg
  • Snooozie
    Snooozie Posts: 3,464 Member
    ditto on the welcome back Janet! Glad you got some quality beach walking in with your son; and I salute you on your reply to your D'sW's comment.... I would NOT have been as polite I'm afraid ... I'm guessing something along the lines of "oh bite me" would have come outta my mouth.. so I bow to you!

    Susan: almost snorted my water when I saw your pics... loved the desert rat most!! and loved the line.. i am a fish.. living a desert rats EXISTENCE!! . TOOOOO FUNNY!
  • cbmcphillips
    cbmcphillips Posts: 801 Member
    oh I so love Ben Franklin... being so close to Philly.....

    that is so true for all the PITAs in our worlds... and one of mine is acting up now:grumble: .... but in 5 months he will be gone and the strong survive.....:laugh:

    and as Eleanor Roosevelt would say... damned if you do, damned if you don't....

    Carol
  • TArnold2012
    TArnold2012 Posts: 929 Member
    Looks like the Hatters are doing great.

    As for me all is well (umm except I am sick again :grumble: ) but just been busy. We are gearing up to study for standardize testing :angry: :explode: :mad: you get the picture of my feelings? :laugh: If they would just have let me do what I wanted we wouldn't have this to do :grumble: but who am I to question authority :laugh: the one that can't keep her mouth shut. I just don't believe in teaching to the test. If you start at the beginning of the year anything they need to know for a test can be taught along the way. Imagine that as a concept I want to scream but I cut my tongue out, sew my lips, and refuse to look at the principal in the eyes.

    I am really struggling to get the weight lose to get moving again after Christmas. It feels like it is just hanging on and refusing to let go. I am doing all the things I know to do but it just seem to budge more than a pound at a time. Yes, I know that's still a good lose but just a bit disappointed that it has slowed down this much. I am going to hand tough but btw the winter comfort zone of foods and this I find myself fighting battles in my mind daily.


    Just love Franklin !!!! I happened to write a children's book on him during a history college class. Well I have 5 lesson plans to finish for the day. Hope everyone has a great week.
  • cbmcphillips
    cbmcphillips Posts: 801 Member
    now wer're down to 63 members..... hmmmm....
  • Snooozie
    Snooozie Posts: 3,464 Member
    Lol no worries Carole I deleted a couple of members who hadnt logged on to the site for over 4 months - hence why the number dropped!
  • Snooozie
    Snooozie Posts: 3,464 Member
    Morning Hatters!

    Hope everyone is doing ok.. we're almost one month into the New Year - been a tough couple of weeks for some with family issues and illness and frustrations; and this time of year is definitely tough to keep the motivation going at times, I know for me right now its the exercise I have to get committed to; and I just cannot seem to get started.. I have no excuse at all, just need to actually DO it. I'm starting night shift tonite for a week (and of course the guy upstairs is back hammering all day now!) and fighting off a chest cold all of which of course I use to say to myself that I can't do anything on this shift ,or til I'm feeling better.. which is complete BS I know ... so my challenge to myself is to stop the procastinating and focus on deciding what to do, and stop yapping about it and just DO I T already.

    The hammering is driving me mental already, so better get up and get cracking before I go bonkers... lol
  • kobiemom
    kobiemom Posts: 218 Member
    I agree with the roller coaster weather complaints! It finally got above freezing here and it's raining for three days with snow and freezing temps predicted for Friday. My walks aren't going well, but I'm using the Wii Zumba. We'll see if it does anything. I know I need to be consistent to lose this weight but so many factors are out of my control.
    Janet- I'm sorry to hear your father is married to my MIL!! It's HER misery, not yours. BTDT til the day she died. Snoozie - I've been thinking of my homemade Mac n' cheese recipe for a week! Now I know why. Thanks for the article. TA - sorry you're sick. There's a lot of that going around. My husband is sick and that happens about every five years. Thank goodness! Big baby! Seehe- love your pics! Carol - another Ben Franklin favorite: "Tis better to remain silent and be thought a fool than to open your mouth and erase all doubt." Have a great day, Everyone!
  • Snooozie
    Snooozie Posts: 3,464 Member
    ROFL @ "I'm sorry to hear your father is married to my MIL" :laugh:
  • cbmcphillips
    cbmcphillips Posts: 801 Member
    thanks Kobie....

    so true so true......

    as she keeps her mouth shut....anybody got duct tape? jk.....

    water is my friend... will only have my mouth open for that.....
  • hairsprayhon
    hairsprayhon Posts: 334 Member
    The comment about my dad being married to your MIL is so funny, because that is exactly the way I think of her-as my second MIL, as if the first one was not enough of a hassle. When DH complains about her, I say that I am used to it because I had 26 years of practice with my first MIL before I got this second one.
    On a more serious MIL note, she ended up in ICU while I was in Florida and I am headed back to the hospital now. It has been such an emotional experience for everyone. Just when DH is accepting that this is her time, she rallies, he gets hopeful and then the process starts again. Despite the advanced directive, when she was there alone the doctor inserted a breathing tube.
    Meanwhile once again I have to say to all of you nurses, thank you for all that you do. Her nurses have been wonderful and I am in awe of their patience and calmness in as stressful a place as the ICU.
  • kobiemom
    kobiemom Posts: 218 Member
    Thanks! I was an ICU nurse for twenty years. Mostly Cardio-Thoracic ICU - open heart surgery, aneurysms, trauma, etc. I've stepped back to school nursing for now.
  • cbmcphillips
    cbmcphillips Posts: 801 Member
    For those with family members having health issues - hope it gets better soon. Blessings and prayers coming your way.....

    For those that don't know, in Aug 2010 I had my own health scare (diagnosed with bleeding on the brain...blood clots and other complications.....) But the good news is that through the power of prayer, and awesome health care, and everyone involved you would never know it to look at me now......Thank you so much to all the nurses, doctors, technicians, and everyone else involved.... :flowerforyou:

    Now if I could only get the gastro guy out.... maybe send him thru the MRI machine???? jk..... :):laugh: better safe than sorry.... the only lingering complication is a liver hemioginia ? spell? blood clot near the liver... the only bad thing is the location... but the good news is the gastro guy is keeping an eye on it plus the gall stones... but no symptoms except that the dr says I have them....:laugh:

    And the other good news that I was only out of work from August 2010 and returned 1 November 2010 (out for less than 3 months).. and yes, I do know enough to count my blessings....:smile:

    See you all soon....Carol
  • seehe
    seehe Posts: 946 Member
    Janet: So sorry for what you are all going through. (((((hugs))))) to you and yours

    Kobie: I am impressed and my hat is off to you!

    Carol: Holy Cow! So glad you are OK and able to count your blessings.

    Hope everyone has a peaceful night's sleep and a great day tomorrow :-)
  • tonyacoursey
    tonyacoursey Posts: 404 Member
    Good Morning Hatters, I want to thank you for all that you have done for me. I am so very thankful for the check ins and such. I owe a round of return emails and will get to them but wanted to let all of you know that YOU are family to me. I have so much to be thankful for and it is because of this group and a few others that I have come to realize how much we can do for others via the internet. We may not be related by blood or vicinity but we are related by this group and I so very much appreciate all of you. There are many things that have made me laugh over the last few days and so many things that I can relate too.

    Special thanks to Snoozie, Janet, Seehe, Kobie and Carol.

    I couldn't make it through these minutes, hours, days and weeks without all of you special MMH's!
  • hairsprayhon
    hairsprayhon Posts: 334 Member
    One day we will have a Mad Hatter convention and gather together and give the hugs in person that we are constantly sending to each other. I am looking forward to that day. Knowing that I have the support of all of you is really priceless.
    Tonya, hope the healing starts now.
    Made it to body pump today for the first time in over a week as expected it was tough. The substitute teacher has a following of marathoners, there were about 20 of them today. But the unfortunate thing is that the new ladies who were trying to get started were not there. It's intimidating to begin in the miidst of all these people with their sleek runners bodies. I wish I had a way to contact them and tell them to just focus on themselves and getting fit is about getting stronger and not about other people. Since i can not reach out to them, I will say to any of my hatter friends who are intimidated by the hard bodies at the gym--hang in there and don't be intimidated. The other thing is keep track of your progress if you start, like I did, unable to do even one modified push up, celebrating the when yo u can do one and then aim for 5. Fitness and strength is something within all of our reach.
    We are having a temporary thaw today with actual sunshine!!! Even ICU rooms are less depressing when sun is streaming through the windows.
  • Snooozie
    Snooozie Posts: 3,464 Member
    Morning Hatters...

    Thought I'd slide in while I have my coffee - up early as usual after the first night shift, which kinda sucks as its perfect sleeping weather out there right now being rainy and dreary (it's hard sleeping during the day when the sun is shining but days like this were made for snoozing - but I'll head back this afternoon and try for a few more hours. Am battling a cold which appears to want to settle in my chest; however I'm grateful I managed to avoid it over the holidays and while I was on vacation, so I won't whine (much lol) if my extra vitamin popping doesn't keep it at bay!

    BTW: Seehee I think it was you who threw a question in a while back about why I use "Snoozie" as a nickname (I had to add an extra O to my usual nickname on MFP as someone was already using Snoozie on the site when I joined up).. Long story short - over the past 20 years whenever I needed some extra "pin money" (as my grandmother used to call it... extra cash for luxuries as opposed to necessities like the mortgage and bills!) I would always take on a 2nd job aside from my full time one (which I've been doing for 29 years now).. each job usually lasted 6 months to a year until I had made whatever $ I wanted or got bored with the job or whatever lol) and our weird shifts at work gave me lots of day off at a time, so there was always something I could find where they would work around my shifts) Oftentimes I did both jobs on the same day; i.e., if I was on midnights I would work from 10pm to 6am, come home, nap (or SNOOZE) for 20 min on the couch, then head to the other job and work from 7am to 11am, then home to sleep and back into work for 10pm every day.. or on dayshift I would work 530am to 230pm, come home and nap til 330, head to second job for 4pm and work til 11pm, then home and up at 4am to be back at work.. I survived on naps (or snoozes as I called em) as sleeping for any length of time was impossible lol Naps also kept me going during the years of caregiving for my parents - so I started using "The Snooz" on some sites like my scrabble games, and eventually it morphed into Snoozie.. way too much info huh??? but there ya go!

    I had some pretty weird second jobs over the years I must say lol.. but always had fun - once I tried the bookstore though I stayed there for almost 10 years; it was the best of both worlds and let me indulge in my of my favourite passions (books!) and an employee discount..LOL! I only gave up all second jobs last January, and promised myself I would force myself to go one whole year of only working one full time job like a normal person, and work on my health which had taken a real hit from constantly being on the go (living on frozen dinners and fast food of course as my excuse was I didn't have time to prepare healthy meals...ahem!!) Hmmm.. now that I think about it... there are only 2 days left in the year I promised to take off.. maybe time to start looking for another one?? LOL

    I suddenly noticed when I got on the scale last week and saw the pounds lost, that I am only 1.5 or so pounds away from a set of numbers I haven't seen in 20 years or so. and it was kind of a shock to realize it for some reason; I think because I am so used to seeing the current numbers not changing more than a pound or two lately, that seeing a new digit nudge up from the left kinda threw me off.. but then I relaized with the 20lbs I had lost over the year before I found MFP, and the 15 since I came here, it was actually "happening".. (does that make sense to anyone else..?? When you see a number coming up you never really believed might appear on the horizon?) I've gotta think with the awesome losses the Hatters have all experienced someone else had to have that "wow.. it's happening moment?" I think there's a part of me that's actually scared about the day I get on the scale and see it actually show up... does THAT sound weird to anyone? Part of me wants to stop eating completely until I see it, and part of me wants to run out and stuff my face so I don't see it.... hmmm... perhaps I should book a weekend in GSP's funny farm room ....

    OK, nuff babbling... better get some replies done here then figure out what to do with myself til its time to hit the sack again; neither the laundry or the house cleaning appeal to me so we'll see what kind of mischief I can rustle up!!


    :bigsmile: by the way I see we have some new members; just wanted to say hello and welcome!! Feel free to lurk for a while and read thru the previous topics to get an idea of what we're about (and please don't base it on my ramblings above.. the other Hatters are quite sane and normal!) LOL or jump in and introduce yourself anytime!