Do you eat peanuts??

Options
chani8
chani8 Posts: 946 Member
I just read, for the second time (the first time I read it, I was in denial), that peanuts are not healthy.

I love peanuts. I love organic peanut butter. Apparently, it's not very healthy.

http://thepaleodiet.com/nut-fatty-acid-composition/

"One nut that you should not include in your diet is peanuts. Peanuts are not nuts, but rather are legumes. Here are the reasons why we do not recommend either peanuts or peanut oil. If you look at peanut oil fatty acid composition in the Table of Vegetable Oils, notice that it contains little saturated fat and almost 80% is made up of cholesterol-lowering monounsaturated and polyunsaturated fats. Hence, on the surface, you might think that peanut oil would probably be helpful in preventing the artery clogging process (atherosclerosis) that underlies coronary heart disease. Well, your ideas were not a whole lot different than those of nutritional scientists – that is, until they got around to actually testing peanut oil in laboratory animals. Starting in the 1960s and continuing into the 1980s, scientists unexpectedly found peanut oil to be highly atherogenic, causing arterial plaques to form in rabbits, rats, and primates – only a single study showed otherwise. Peanut oil was found to be so atherogenic that it continues to be routinely fed to rabbits to stimulate atherosclerosis to study the disease itself.

At first, it was not clear how seemingly healthful oil could be so toxic in such a wide variety of animals. Dr. David Kritchevsky and colleagues at the Wistar Institute in Philadelphia were able to show with a series of experiments that peanut oil lectin (PNA) was most likely responsible for its artery clogging properties. See “Lectin may contribute to the atherogenicity of peanut oil.” to learn more about peanut oil and cardiovascular disease.

Lectins are fairly large protein molecules, and most nutritional scientists had assumed that digestive enzymes in the gut would degrade it into its component amino acids. Consequently, it was assumed that the intact lectin molecule would not be able to get into the bloodstream to do its dirty work. But they were wrong. It turned out that lectins were highly resistant to the gut’s protein-shearing enzymes. An experiment conducted by Dr. Wang and colleagues and published in the prestigious medical journal Lancet revealed that PNA got into the bloodstream intact in as little 1-4 hours after subjects ate a handful of roasted, salted peanuts. See “Identification of intact peanut lectin in peripheral venous blood.” for more details.

Even though the concentrations of PNA in the subject’s blood were quite low, they were still at concentrations known to cause atherosclerosis in experimental animals. Lectins are a lot like super glue ö it doesn’t take much. Because these proteins contain carbohydrates, they can bind to a wide variety of cells in the body, including the cells lining the arteries. And indeed, it was found that PNA did its damage to the arteries by binding to a specific sugar receptor. So, the practical point here is to stay away from both peanuts and peanut oil. There are better choices."

What do you think - should I eliminate peanuts or just limit them?

Replies

  • kiramaniac
    kiramaniac Posts: 800 Member
    Options
    I was eating them quite a bit. Then I noticed my still seemed to have started around the time where I started eating them. And then the scale started moving against when I cut them out. Could be coincidence. I'll still have them ow and then, but it isn't a regular thing now.
  • Comonemo
    Options
    I used to eat organic peanut butter all the time, until I read something similar to this. I have since switched to eating almond butter and snacking on roasted/salted pecans, walnuts and macadamia nuts. (now I have to restrain myself from the pecans!)
  • chani8
    chani8 Posts: 946 Member
    Options
    I just read a pro-peanuts article now.

    I didn't know peanuts were so controversial!!

    http://www.whfoods.com/genpage.php?tname=foodspice&dbid=101

    Interestingly, their studies combine "nuts/peanuts" so that we really don't know if it was nuts or peanuts that were so beneficial.

    I think I'm going to try to back off on the peanut butter. I was trying to find a non-calcium rich food for the morning, when I take a lot of iron, but I think the little bit of calcium in almonds will just have to be ok.
  • teaddicted
    Options
    i eat peanuts everyday. they give me 9g of carb everyday but they can full me for like 3-4 hours!
  • Mistizoom
    Mistizoom Posts: 578 Member
    Options
    I eat them. But I don't do paleo.
  • chirosche
    chirosche Posts: 66 Member
    Options

    I think I'm going to try to back off on the peanut butter. I was trying to find a non-calcium rich food for the morning, when I take a lot of iron, but I think the little bit of calcium in almonds will just have to be ok.

    You take a lot of iron? Iron can be dangerous if you take too much. It can kill you. Did a doctor tell you to take a lot of iron? Just be careful.

    I've read a lot about peanuts and I could eat lots of them. But my nuts of choice is pecans (I grew up in the South around pecan trees) almonds and brazilian.
  • chani8
    chani8 Posts: 946 Member
    Options

    I think I'm going to try to back off on the peanut butter. I was trying to find a non-calcium rich food for the morning, when I take a lot of iron, but I think the little bit of calcium in almonds will just have to be ok.

    You take a lot of iron? Iron can be dangerous if you take too much. It can kill you. Did a doctor tell you to take a lot of iron? Just be careful.

    I've read a lot about peanuts and I could eat lots of them. But my nuts of choice is pecans (I grew up in the South around pecan trees) almonds and brazilian.

    Thank you for the warning. I've been wondering myself how much iron I should take since I'm very anemic right now. I googled it and apparently 45mg of iron is the max a person should take. I'm adjusting my intake to make sure I don't go over that now.
  • chirosche
    chirosche Posts: 66 Member
    Options
    Good, cause it can kill you. I'm sure you'll read up on it.. :-)