We are pleased to announce that as of March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor has been introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

Clean Eating Vs. Low Carb Eating

MSmith74
MSmith74 Posts: 24 Member
edited February 15 in Social Groups
What works for you?
I feel better when I eat clean but I lose more when I eat low carb.

Replies

  • mamarundrc
    mamarundrc Posts: 1,577 Member
    For me, I don't eat clean as a means to lose weight. I eat clean because it makes me feel better. I have more energy and feel less bloated. Sure, losing some weight has been nice, but over the last few years I have come to realize that being healthy is so much more than a number on a scale.

    The only time I ever specifically focused on a low carb diet, I felt horrible all the time. I focused just on net carbs and nothing else and I felt out of whack. I wasn't choosing food because of the nutritional content, just the obscure carb number. Sure I lost a lot of weight but as soon as I stopped obsessing about carb counting I gained it all back and then some.

    With that being said, clean eating for me is a lower carb diet then my regular diet. I have found that I am often under my calorie goal and when I am good about following a nice clean diet, I am rarely hungry. I am always amazed at the quantity of food I am able to eat to reach my calorie goal when I am eating clean.
  • kingscrown
    kingscrown Posts: 615 Member
    Because I tend to have a sweet tooth and love simple carbs I do watch my carbs. I definitely keep them below 200, but shoot more for 125. I find eating clean really helps me with this. It's a work in progress. I find logging helps me keep track and pinpoint items that shoot my day really high.
  • Bernadette60614
    Bernadette60614 Posts: 707 Member
    I focus on "clean" carbs...which means I don't eat anything with flour or sugar, not that flour or sugar in moderation are "bad", but I find it is easier for me to not rationalize overeating when I made a hard and fast rule: no flour, no sugar.

    One a week I have a small frozen yogurt at a shop, but with almonds and berries, today I was having a craving for chocolate so I had 2 Fiber one chocolate brownies, but that will be it for my sugar/flour for the week.

    I tend to avoid high sugar fruits, e.g., grapes/pineapple, but if I have to have them I'll have them with a good, slow burning fat, e.g., walnuts.
  • Shanz78
    Shanz78 Posts: 143 Member
    I do both. I eat clean unprocessed foods so that pretty much eliminates all bad carbs. I dont eat wheat or gluten. I get my carbs from fruit and starchy vegetables. But if im really having a craving ill have brown rice bread or tortilla, or organic GMO free corn chips. If you eliminate processed carbs you will stop craving them and feel a whole lot better.
  • Debbiedebbiey
    Debbiedebbiey Posts: 824 Member
    I'm trying to decide what to do myself, last summer I lowered carbs to 50 but never lost weight til I got to 20. Off & on I lost 16 lbs, kept feeling deprived & fell off the wagon too many times. So this week I've decided I'm tired of feeling & eating crappy- but decided to add an apple, green beans & some raw carrots back in.... How bad could that be? Well I'm back up to 40 carbs- so well see ! I guess everybody's different- just think maybe the apple w/ peanut butter will help me not feel deprived.
  • MSmith74
    MSmith74 Posts: 24 Member
    ME too. I feel bad when I am watching my carbs. and tend to chose foods just based on their carb content, instead of nutritional value.
    BUT i feel like when I eat a low carb diet I tend to lose weight faster.
    Talk about FRUSTRATED!
  • montana_girl
    montana_girl Posts: 1,403 Member
    I do both. I eat clean unprocessed foods so that pretty much eliminates all bad carbs. I dont eat wheat or gluten. I get my carbs from fruit and starchy vegetables. But if im really having a craving ill have brown rice bread or tortilla, or organic GMO free corn chips. If you eliminate processed carbs you will stop craving them and feel a whole lot better.

    This is pretty much what I do as well. I tend to eat a lot of carbs, but it's coming from veggies, fruits and meats so I don't worry about it as much. I just stay away from processed foods and cut back on the wheat/grains/pasta. That has made a big difference for me. Not sure how it's helping the weight loss, but I feel better when I don't eat as many "bad" carbs!
This discussion has been closed.