Keto bad for your liver????
briteyes
Posts: 435 Member
What do we think about this recent article from Good Housekeeping?
http://www.goodhousekeeping.com/health/diet-nutrition/a47695/what-is-the-keto-diet/
It seems quite misleading and misinformed, leaving a lot of key details out....
http://www.goodhousekeeping.com/health/diet-nutrition/a47695/what-is-the-keto-diet/
It seems quite misleading and misinformed, leaving a lot of key details out....
0
Replies
-
I can't read the whole thing right now. Too much misinformation.
But so far...what a load! Speaking of B.S.0 -
Total load of BS, mainly based on the author's bias with no science to back up her claims.1
-
Bad article.
My favorite was this gem:not to mention how hard (and boring) it is to eat mainly coconut oil and butter for months on end.
My dinner last night was a chicken thigh, roasted zucchini and a huge salad with avocado and vinaigrette. High in fat? Yes. But 3/4 of my plate was vegetables.8 -
Yes, I love how the author claims all you eat on a keto diet is bacon, butter, and coconut oil!!! And claims that we don’t eat plants anymore... yikes! And how many people just read this crap and believe it???? I wanted to leave a comment but they don’t have a comments section... gee I wonder why??? So I left a nice IG post and made sure to tag them.1
-
"Keto diets rely on an extreme technique to (temporarily) move the scale down a few pounds, and basically eliminates all joy associated with eating real food and living life."
Seriously? Don't go keto, it tastes like sadness and despair!
The article makes a big deal about the first few pounds of water weight and how it's just water and will be gained back with eating carbs. No weight loss beyond the first few pounds is acknowledged at all. I guess if you lost more than a few pounds with keto you must be imaginary!2 -
tcunbeliever wrote: »"Keto diets rely on an extreme technique to (temporarily) move the scale down a few pounds, and basically eliminates all joy associated with eating real food and living life."
Seriously? Don't go keto, it tastes like sadness and despair!
The article makes a big deal about the first few pounds of water weight and how it's just water and will be gained back with eating carbs. No weight loss beyond the first few pounds is acknowledged at all. I guess if you lost more than a few pounds with keto you must be imaginary!
So I'm like a fairy, then? I'd better get purple sparkly wings. And a rockin' wand.6 -
I eat a lot more vegetables now than I did when I was noshing on the muffin at the local coffee shop. I also eat almonds for a snack. I just don't feel guilty for eating fat anymore. This is probably closer to how we are Meant to eat. Think about it, Healthy Meats, Lots of vegetables with limited junk. It's just a new approach.
I ate rotisserie chicken the other day with the Primal (avocado oil) Chipotle Mayo mixed with it. It WAS DELISH. I was so happy. I had roasted brocolli. My breakfast was boiled eggs, avocado and green tea. Guess who's breakfast was more full of bio available nutrients? Me or the guy who eats a slice of toast with jelly and coffee with cream and sugar.
Yup... ME ME ME!12 -
baconslave wrote: »tcunbeliever wrote: »"Keto diets rely on an extreme technique to (temporarily) move the scale down a few pounds, and basically eliminates all joy associated with eating real food and living life."
Seriously? Don't go keto, it tastes like sadness and despair!
The article makes a big deal about the first few pounds of water weight and how it's just water and will be gained back with eating carbs. No weight loss beyond the first few pounds is acknowledged at all. I guess if you lost more than a few pounds with keto you must be imaginary!
So I'm like a fairy, then? I'd better get purple sparkly wings. And a rockin' wand.
Like you don't already have them...6 -
tmoneyag99 wrote: »I eat a lot more vegetables now than I did when I was noshing on the muffin at the local coffee shop. I also eat almonds for a snack. I just don't feel guilty for eating fat anymore. This is probably closer to how we are Meant to eat. Think about it, Healthy Meats, Lots of vegetables with limited junk. It's just a new approach.
I ate rotisserie chicken the other day with the Primal (avocado oil) Chipotle Mayo mixed with it. It WAS DELISH. I was so happy. I had roasted brocolli. My breakfast was boiled eggs, avocado and green tea. Guess who's breakfast was more full of bio available nutrients? Me or the guy who eats a slice of toast with jelly and coffee with cream and sugar.
Yup... ME ME ME!
+1 to this.
On another note: A piece of the problem/perception of Keto though can be found in forums with posts BY overzealous keto individuals who report only things like eating fat bombs, bacon and BPC loaded with coconut oil and Kerrygold butter.3 -
I tried to finish it just so I know the comments some will make about it but it is worse than bad. I do not think to get something that wrong could be done by accident or ignorance.0
-
baconslave wrote: »So I'm like a fairy, then? I'd better get purple sparkly wings. And a rockin' wand.
Oh, oh, ME TOO!! I need to know where to get some for me too!!1 -
Bad article.
My favorite was this gem:not to mention how hard (and boring) it is to eat mainly coconut oil and butter for months on end.
My dinner last night was a chicken thigh, roasted zucchini and a huge salad with avocado and vinaigrette. High in fat? Yes. But 3/4 of my plate was vegetables.
I can’t think of the last time I had coconut oil and butters just to keep my eggs from sticking to the pan.
This kind of misinformation is infuriating but sadly every day I hear of someone trying to figure out how to eat “enough”...1 -
Honestly I didn't even read it...but I've seen people here bash keto unfairly. They call it a fad diet, claim we eliminate an entire macro section, or say they could never do without veggies and fruit...i don't know about you guys, but I eat WAY more veggies now than ever before...and I've gotten pretty inventive with my salads to keep it interesting and full of nutrition. Keto has forced me to increase my palate, if anything. It's amazing how many options are there when you're not cramming onion rings and pizza in you're pie hole at every opportunity. (And truth, despite a love for veggies, I would never choose the broccoli over French fries in the past).7
-
Sunny_Bunny_ wrote: »Bad article.
My favorite was this gem:not to mention how hard (and boring) it is to eat mainly coconut oil and butter for months on end.
My dinner last night was a chicken thigh, roasted zucchini and a huge salad with avocado and vinaigrette. High in fat? Yes. But 3/4 of my plate was vegetables.
I can’t think of the last time I had coconut oil and butters just to keep my eggs from sticking to the pan.
This kind of misinformation is infuriating but sadly every day I hear of someone trying to figure out how to eat “enough”...
True. My butt is my fat bomb currently...my body can snack on that.
13 -
baconslave wrote: »tcunbeliever wrote: »"Keto diets rely on an extreme technique to (temporarily) move the scale down a few pounds, and basically eliminates all joy associated with eating real food and living life."
Seriously? Don't go keto, it tastes like sadness and despair!
The article makes a big deal about the first few pounds of water weight and how it's just water and will be gained back with eating carbs. No weight loss beyond the first few pounds is acknowledged at all. I guess if you lost more than a few pounds with keto you must be imaginary!
So I'm like a fairy, then? I'd better get purple sparkly wings. And a rockin' wand.
Like you don't already have them...
0 -
Well I've been eating off plan for the past few days and like next to none of those carbs have been veggies. I eat way more veggies keto. I don't even like veggies but they round out a keto meal nicely. However if I'm eating carbs I want rice, French fries, and ice cream.4
-
I don’t remember the last time I’ve consistently eaten this much produce. And I want to eat it, which is even better!4
-
I've seen a lot of articles like this over the years and a lot of misconception about certain ways of eating from friends and family. A lot of people think Vegans only eat salads and LCHF only eat eggs and bacon all the time. I know there are extremes to any way of eating which generate bad news and that is the first thing a writer will latch onto since it gets views, sells adds, and who knows if the writer or company they work for has other interests in mind.
The concept of giving up sugar, processed food, and a daily double cheese burger with large fries and a 32oz coke challenges a persons comfort zone and snarky articles like this one are a kneejerk reaction to someone who doesn't have the willpower nor wants to give up on their "crack" foods so they will find every reason not to do so. I've also noticed a lot of these articles the writer only tries it 10-30 days for the sake of writing the stupid article so of course they need to make it somewhat entertaining and alleviate people's fears about something that might take them out of the comfort zone and instant gratification mindset.
No matter what if you are informed about what you are eating and how it affects your body and don't go to some extreme that puts your health at risk then it shouldn't matter.
The one thing I hear a lot from a lot of different people is "It's not like you eat *enter junk food of choice here* all the time so its OK to eat it a few times a month" and its those same people who crab about being overweight and eat that type of food all the time. That is who this article is written for it's not aimed at people who know there are better ways to eat and be healthy.
3 -
I guess a downside is one could wind up with a skinny liver vs a fatty liver.4
-
LOl0
-
What do we think about this recent article from Good Housekeeping?
http://www.goodhousekeeping.com/health/diet-nutrition/a47695/what-is-the-keto-diet/
It seems quite misleading and misinformed, leaving a lot of key details out....
I saw that article and it pissed me off with how much of a load of BS it is.1 -
Just sent the following email to GH:
What is Keto - Jan 23/18
Very disappointed in GH for printing this article and supporting this person’s obviously biased opinion piece. It does not have any solid scientific evidence behind it and is based on incorrect and outdated information.
It would be much more professional to present the science behind ketogenic and low carb eating rather than use outmoded opinions to deride a way of eating that has helped so many people with health related issues from diabetes to joint pain. The author obviously did no research before making her claims but what is worse GH made her erroneous statements appear correct and acceptable by printing the article.
It must make your readers wonder how accurate other GH articles must be.
Sent from my iPad10 -
baconslave wrote: »So I'm like a fairy, then? I'd better get purple sparkly wings. And a rockin' wand. Sorry, I guess you dropped your wand somewhere, the magic one that turns carbs into fats....
3 -
LOL1
-
canadjineh wrote: »baconslave wrote: »So I'm like a fairy, then? I'd better get purple sparkly wings. And a rockin' wand. Sorry, I guess you dropped your wand somewhere, the magic one that turns carbs into fats....
Can’t believe you just doxxed @baconslave like that
2 -
Ringbearer2 wrote: »canadjineh wrote: »baconslave wrote: »So I'm like a fairy, then? I'd better get purple sparkly wings. And a rockin' wand. Sorry, I guess you dropped your wand somewhere, the magic one that turns carbs into fats....
Can’t believe you just doxxed @baconslave like that
0 -
No malicious info ! Just wishing we could find the magic wand that turns carbs into fats. (not 'carbs into fat' - we are already good at that, lol)3
This discussion has been closed.