Net Carbs vs. Carbs
BlueLineSki2009
Posts: 2 Member
Hi Everyone!
I want to make sure I'm counting the right macros and I am relatively new to Keto. I started once before and was not seeing results. I am not tracking on MFP and realized that I was not seeing results because I was miscounting carbs. Can someone school me in what carbs to track? There is a HUGE difference and I just can't seem to find the right answer. Thank you in advance!
Megan
I want to make sure I'm counting the right macros and I am relatively new to Keto. I started once before and was not seeing results. I am not tracking on MFP and realized that I was not seeing results because I was miscounting carbs. Can someone school me in what carbs to track? There is a HUGE difference and I just can't seem to find the right answer. Thank you in advance!
Megan
0
Replies
-
Hi,
when you look at your labels:
Total carbs - fiber= net carbs
For the most part, people want to stay under 20 net carbs
2 -
I'm struggling to determine if MFP carbs total is net carbs or total carbs. I succumbed to way distorted thinking the other day after being devastated when I saw my carb total after I thought I had a great on-plan breakfast and lunch. Should I really just be watching the sugar total?0
-
@furrryhat MFP shows total carbs, you have to subtract your fiber to get your net carbs...2
-
Thanks for the clarification!0
-
I always just track total carbs.
Keeps me lower right across the board.1 -
@Everyonelies Thank you for the info!0
-
You can get into a lot of grey area with tracking net carbs but I get why people do it. I myself did it for a long time and at some point will probably do it again.
Good rule of thumb if it is a whole food like a vegetable that you are eating subtract the fiber and you are good.
If it is a processed food that has fiber on the label take half the fiber away.
Sugar alcohols also will play a part in subtracting and getting net carbs.2 -
When I did log regularly I would subtract the fiber grams from the carb total, in my head.
Everyone finds what works for them and it’s not wrong when it does. Using a “Keto calculator”can help you too! I don’t have a way to post the link for it here, but if you’re needing help setting up your macros google that and it can help you find the balance you’re striving for.
2 -
I track net, but I do keep an eye on fiber so if I go over a bit, but my fiber is going to cover it, then I don't fret about it...I don't generally eat any processed food items with fiber or sugar alcohols, so my fiber is all from veggies.2
-
There is another app i was told to use called Carb Manager and it actually counts your net carbs for you and shows nice graphs of carbs fats and protein and how much you have left to eat if your tracking for a certain percentage1
-
New to Keto, old MFP logger (on and off).
So I was initially distressed by how many carbs I was seeing and "discovered" I could track fiber independently within MFP. That makes the keto friendly items match the literature. You still have to do the subtraction yourself but the data seems to be there.
I'm looking for any advice you all can provide to better utilize the MFP features to understand and manage the diet.0 -
I used to log my sweetener but will begin omitting my new choice, Truvia, as all those carbs are erythritol. Sugar alchohol. Not a net carb (but not fiber either.)1
-
I consider fiber to be detrimental, so I definitely won't subtract it. I also consider artificial sweeteners to be a problem, so I don't subtract them either. It really depends on your goals. Fiber won't kick you out of ketosis. If that is your only goal, you can subtract it. Many artificial sweeteners won't cause issues but some will. I usually don't subtract them.
It helps to remember that the idea of net carbs was originally created to allow people to put more natural vegetables in their diet and not processed low-carb bars or sweets.3 -
I am in full agreement with Fitgoat.
Dr Michael Eades created the net carb math and he has since stated that he regrets introducing the idea because of its so often applied. His only intention was to get his patients to eat more green vegetables.4 -
If I look at the “nutrients” tab versus just macros tab it shows you fibre and carbs. I subtract the fibre from the carbs to get the net carbs. It took me awhile to check both tabs and I couldn’t figure out how to get lower carbs even though I was eating very strictly0
-
What's been working for me so far, since 11/12/18 is staying under 20 NET carbs, and on here I'm generally around 30 carbs. I also intermittent fast and have yet to hit a stall, though I'm sure I'm due any time now lol0
This discussion has been closed.