Low Carber Daily Forum

Join
We are pleased to announce that as of March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor has been introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

Alcohol consumption/ Scale playing Jedi Mind tricks?

RhiannonBecks
RhiannonBecks Posts: 189 Member
edited November 2024 in Social Groups
Hi all,

So I tried searching for a discussion in regards to this, but not sure If I missed it or it hasn't been discussed (though hard to believe it hasn't).

Regardless, I think I am just being overly cautious/concerned and I understand this is long term goal.

But nice to meet you, I'm Neurotic. :) With that said, I will get to the actual question.

So Saturday I had a bachelorette party and I pre-planned my entire day, including budgeting a few drinks while we were out. I had 3 Michelob Ultra (2.9 NC each) and then I had a White Wine spritzer (that wasn't planned but still had room to budge).

So I have been steadily dropping, (even an ounce or two here or there), And monitor my weight daily, just for the sake of tracking; but since Saturday my weight is slowly creeping up, ounce by ounce! What Gives! Is my body holding onto the Alcohol still? From Friday's weigh in (AM) I am up 1.3 pounds. I know that I haven't eaten excess cals to gain said weight.

So is this all in my head, am I making a mountain out of a mole hill? (I think that's what the saying is).

Just need some perspective. Thanks in advance!

Replies

  • tcunbeliever
    tcunbeliever Posts: 8,219 Member
    Everyone is probably a bit different, but alcohol definitely makes me retain water for about 3 days...if I drink on a Saturday evening, I won't see the scale adjust back to normal until Wed AM...
  • RalfLott
    RalfLott Posts: 5,036 Member
    edited August 2017
    1.3 lbs doesn't seem like a reason to go on the wagon. I'm in maintenance mode, yet my weight fluctuates within a 5-lb range over the course of a week, even a couple days sometimes.

    PS. Your scale is not on your side!
    http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/1l0415166/scale-why-should-i-dump-thee-let-me-count-the-ways
  • Smoked33
    Smoked33 Posts: 186 Member
    Just a tip...daily weighings(or any weighings) really only work to provide information on how your body responds to stimulus...if you are going to fret/stress/lose sleep/kill your diet/etc..because of a scale reading you really should consider ditching it for calipers or a measuring tape or just good faith and a mirror. (ps, not suggesting you're over-reacting, just a general tip :) ).
  • baconslave
    baconslave Posts: 7,041 Member
    Alcohol disrupts the electrolyte and water balance in the body, so it affecting your water balance/retention isn't so surprising. You can't gain real weight that fast, unless you are packing in 3500 cal per day OVER maintenance. So it's water fluctuation. Give it time. :smile:
  • RhiannonBecks
    RhiannonBecks Posts: 189 Member
    baconslave wrote: »
    Alcohol disrupts the electrolyte and water balance in the body, so it affecting your water balance/retention isn't so surprising. You can't gain real weight that fast, unless you are packing in 3500 cal per day OVER maintenance. So it's water fluctuation. Give it time. :smile:

    Thanks @baconslave I figured as much! I want to track daily just so I can see the natural fluctuations, but sometimes its hard when it is moving up to psych myself out. I have been at cal deficit/carb goal so I know I haven't eaten that 1.3 pounds on. But sometimes logic goes out the door when worry takes its place, lol. :)
  • kpk54
    kpk54 Posts: 4,474 Member
    After all these years on MFP through weight loss and and 3+ years of maintenance, I finally decided to read that link above about "dumping the scale". I clicked on it (just now) and found "discussion not found".

    I guess that is telling me that I need to keep doing what I am doing which is accepting that weight fluctuates for any number of reasons and if I don't eat over my calories day in and day out, I won't get fat again. I do weigh every day. I always have. When the scale goes up I say "hmmm". :/ When the scale goes back down I say "hmmm." :)
  • baconslave
    baconslave Posts: 7,041 Member
    edited August 2017
    kpk54 wrote: »
    After all these years on MFP through weight loss and and 3+ years of maintenance, I finally decided to read that link above about "dumping the scale". I clicked on it (just now) and found "discussion not found".

    I guess that is telling me that I need to keep doing what I am doing which is accepting that weight fluctuates for any number of reasons and if I don't eat over my calories day in and day out, I won't get fat again. I do weigh every day. I always have. When the scale goes up I say "hmmm". :/ When the scale goes back down I say "hmmm." :)

    there's something wonky with the link (typo). Gimme a min to track it down.

    ETA:
    Try this one:
    http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/10415166/scale-why-should-i-dump-thee-let-me-count-the-ways
  • swezeytba
    swezeytba Posts: 624 Member
    I always give a least 3 days for an adjustment period after any event I think might have a negative effect on my weight. That seems to be the magic window for me for my body to return back to the correct weight.
  • RhiannonBecks
    RhiannonBecks Posts: 189 Member
    Thanks all for the responses, I think I was feeling a bit like whaaaat, bc I did "plan" for the intake, but I guess I just didn't plan for the few days after. Onward & Upward. Going forward I know if I allow a drink, don't step on the scale for a few days, lol.

    Thanks again! :)
  • RhiannonBecks
    RhiannonBecks Posts: 189 Member
    Welp - ya'll were right. Patience is my friend. Just thought id update, that 1.3# I was worrying about is a total non issue. Today is 3ish days out and hopped on the scale, down 1.2#

    Back to last weeks weight & feeling great!
This discussion has been closed.

Categories