Need advice on home gym equipment
sundaywishes
Posts: 246 Member
Hi all, this is my first post in this group, but I have been lurking for quite some time. I’d appreciate it if I could get some advice on home gym equipment, specifically a bench with squatting capabilities. My fiancé is fine with getting a cheaper, beginner bench/rack and then upgrading as we progress, but I’d rather spend just a little bit more money and get something that we can use now and then grown into. These are three that I have narrowed it down to, in order of cheapest to most expensive. I’ve read through all the reviews of each product and I feel like I’m stuck between the second and third choices. I think that the second would be adequate, but the third has a bit higher weight capacity and seems like it is better constructed. However, I don’t want to spend more money just to spend more money. I know my fiancé will say that the first (cheapest) choice is fine for us now, but I’d feel better if we went with at least the second choice. I’m including the first one just in case I can’t twist his arm enough to go with the second or third choice. I’d really appreciate input on these products (or if anyone knows of a better product, preferably at or under the highest price of $320). Thanks 
http://www.amazon.com/Marcy-Diamond-Mid-Size-Bench/dp/B0041GMVL0/ref=pd_sim_sbs_sg_34
^cheapest, but only one 5-star review.
http://www.amazon.com/Marcy-Diamond-Olympic-Surge-Bench/dp/B003LQSXSG/ref=pd_sim_sbs_sg_21
^slightly more expensive, but has 36 reviews, with only 2 one and two-star reviews.
http://www.amazon.com/XMark-XM-4424-International-Preacher-Attachment/dp/B004OVLS9I/ref=pd_sim_sbs_sg_31
^most expensive, with 9 reviews, 5 are five-star and 4 are four-star. Can hold the most amount of weight and seems like the best constructed and longest lasting.
Thanks again!
http://www.amazon.com/Marcy-Diamond-Mid-Size-Bench/dp/B0041GMVL0/ref=pd_sim_sbs_sg_34
^cheapest, but only one 5-star review.
http://www.amazon.com/Marcy-Diamond-Olympic-Surge-Bench/dp/B003LQSXSG/ref=pd_sim_sbs_sg_21
^slightly more expensive, but has 36 reviews, with only 2 one and two-star reviews.
http://www.amazon.com/XMark-XM-4424-International-Preacher-Attachment/dp/B004OVLS9I/ref=pd_sim_sbs_sg_31
^most expensive, with 9 reviews, 5 are five-star and 4 are four-star. Can hold the most amount of weight and seems like the best constructed and longest lasting.
Thanks again!
0
Replies
-
I don't see how you would use any of those for squats.0
-
@fire_rock -- They all have catches on the backside for racking. If you know of any better equipment, please let me know. I am new to buying gym equipment, which is why I'm asking for advice.0
-
I don't see how you would use any of those for squats.
Me either.0 -
@fire_rock -- They all have catches on the backside for racking. If you know of any better equipment, please let me know. I am new to buying gym equipment, which is why I'm asking for advice.
You should not be squatting anything up in the heavy range without safety bars. If you are going to be laying down some money, an actual squat rack would be much better. You can use a bench in the squat rack, assuming the safety bars are adjustable, for benching.
Do you have room for a power cage?0 -
I would recommend squat stand along with a bench. That will be versatile, not clunky space wise and far more useful for your lifting goals. It could be a bit more costly upfront though
Examples here - http://www.roguefitness.com/strength-equipment/squat-stands.php
Though I am sure you can find more inexpensive models from other companies or used on craigslist0 -
I would recommend squat stand along with a bench. That will be versatile, not clunky space wise and far more useful for your lifting goals. It could be a bit more costly upfront though
Examples here - http://www.roguefitness.com/strength-equipment/squat-stands.php
Though I am sure you can find more inexpensive models from other companies or used on craigslist
I would only recommend the ones with safety bars.0 -
I would only recommend the ones with safety bars.
Yes, definitely this0 -
I would echo every Sara said.
And the only way I see you getting something sufficient while staying in your $300 budget is to find something used on Craigslist.0 -
@fire_rock -- They all have catches on the backside for racking. If you know of any better equipment, please let me know. I am new to buying gym equipment, which is why I'm asking for advice.
You should not be squatting anything up in the heavy range without safety bars. If you are going to be laying down some money, an actual squat rack would be much better. You can use a bench in the squat rack, assuming the safety bars are adjustable, for benching.
Do you have room for a power cage?
Thanks, Sara, for the response. I thought having a spotter would allow for these to work well, but if there is a safety concern, I definitely want to address that. I don't want to spend more than ~$300 on a rack, especially if it doesn't include an adjustable bench. I'd really want to spend less than that if it doesn't include a bench, but I know these things aren't cheap. My fiance doesn't even want us to spend that much. I still need to buy a bar, plates, mats, etc.
I would be setting this up in my garage, so I would have room for a cage, but all the cages I found that seemed to be good enough quality were way out of my price range, which is why I didn't include any in this post.0 -
@fire_rock -- They all have catches on the backside for racking. If you know of any better equipment, please let me know. I am new to buying gym equipment, which is why I'm asking for advice.
You should not be squatting anything up in the heavy range without safety bars. If you are going to be laying down some money, an actual squat rack would be much better. You can use a bench in the squat rack, assuming the safety bars are adjustable, for benching.
Do you have room for a power cage?
Thanks, Sara, for the response. I thought having a spotter would allow for these to work well, but if there is a safety concern, I definitely want to address that. I don't want to spend more than ~$300 on a rack, especially if it doesn't include an adjustable bench. I'd really want to spend less than that if it doesn't include a bench, but I know these things aren't cheap. My fiance doesn't even want us to spend that much. I still need to buy a bar, plates, mats, etc.
I would be setting this up in my garage, so I would have room for a cage, but all the cages I found that seemed to be good enough quality were way out of my price range, which is why I didn't include any in this post.
Not sure if you are in the US, but craigslist is a good resource to find used gym equipment - you can often get good deals that way.
Not sure of the quality, but you can get power cages for a little more than $300 new on Amazon also. If it were me, I would go for a slightly lower quality power cage over a higher quality bench set that did not include safety bars.0 -
I would recommend squat stand along with a bench. That will be versatile, not clunky space wise and far more useful for your lifting goals. It could be a bit more costly upfront though
Examples here - http://www.roguefitness.com/strength-equipment/squat-stands.php
Though I am sure you can find more inexpensive models from other companies or used on craigslist
Thanks for the site.
Also, I've been searching on craigslist and it seems like no one in my area likes to squat =/ I really want to get this home gym set up and I've been looking for quite some time. Just getting restless I suppose.0 -
@fire_rock -- They all have catches on the backside for racking. If you know of any better equipment, please let me know. I am new to buying gym equipment, which is why I'm asking for advice.
You should not be squatting anything up in the heavy range without safety bars. If you are going to be laying down some money, an actual squat rack would be much better. You can use a bench in the squat rack, assuming the safety bars are adjustable, for benching.
Do you have room for a power cage?
Thanks, Sara, for the response. I thought having a spotter would allow for these to work well, but if there is a safety concern, I definitely want to address that. I don't want to spend more than ~$300 on a rack, especially if it doesn't include an adjustable bench. I'd really want to spend less than that if it doesn't include a bench, but I know these things aren't cheap. My fiance doesn't even want us to spend that much. I still need to buy a bar, plates, mats, etc.
I would be setting this up in my garage, so I would have room for a cage, but all the cages I found that seemed to be good enough quality were way out of my price range, which is why I didn't include any in this post.
Not sure if you are in the US, but craigslist is a good resource to find used gym equipment - you can often get good deals that way.
Not sure of the quality, but you can get power cages for a little more than $300 new on Amazon also. If it were me, I would go for a slightly lower quality power cage over a higher quality bench set that did not include safety bars.
Yup, in the US, see previous comment for craigslist. I'll go back onto amazon to see about the power cages. I really appreciate the input. Now just to start twisting my man's arm.....0 -
Depends. Are you planning on ever bench pressing on your own without a knowledgable spotter?
If so, get a power cage and set the bars above your throat (if you're emotionally attached to your throat and don't want to injure it ... people die benching in their garage because their adrenaline overrides their better judgment, just FYI).
If you have 300 bucks to spend (I'm assuming because of your most expensive choice) and the space for it, get something like this and put a bench in it:
http://www.amazon.com/Power-Squat-Deadlift-Bench-Racks/dp/B004UMM4QC/ref=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&qid=1363793324&sr=8-2&keywords=power+rack
If you're wanting to do something like Starting Strength or Stronglifts, I'd recommend against anything without a safety bar also. If you're planning on progressing much slower, you might get away with something cheaper, but if you already know you're going to be lifting for a long time to come, then why skimp?0 -
I would honestly just continuously search craigslist for good equipment to pop up.
You have the right thinking of buying the right equipment instead of buying crap, then having to buy again in a couple of years.
I think the bare minimums for a home gym are a squat rack (doesn't have to be a cage if you have spotters), a bench, olympic barbell + plates. I managed to find all of that on CL for about 200 dollars. Just be patient.0 -
Yup, in the US, see previous comment for craigslist. I'll go back onto amazon to see about the power cages. I really appreciate the input. Now just to start twisting my man's arm.....
You"ll probably get more bang for you buck with a sumo rack: http://www.amazon.com/TDS-C-92565-SPL-Sumo-Rack-Special/dp/B004TMMA26/ref=pd_sim_sbs_sg_10 -
Yup, in the US, see previous comment for craigslist. I'll go back onto amazon to see about the power cages. I really appreciate the input. Now just to start twisting my man's arm.....
You"ll probably get more bang for you buck with a sumo rack: http://www.amazon.com/TDS-C-92565-SPL-Sumo-Rack-Special/dp/B004TMMA26/ref=pd_sim_sbs_sg_1
I saw that one - looks good - actually thinking of it for myself as the safety bars are adjustable.0 -
Thanks guys for your posts. At the risk of sounding completely stupid here, how do you squat and bench in a cage or using a sumo rack? I haven't ever used those before and I'm trying to visualize it....
And while craiglist may be my best bet price wise, I'm getting really impatient trying to find things (been looking for a few months and I really want to just start lifting again already), plus I would have to find someone to help me transport the equipment. I know you guys can't help with that, I'm just frustrated by it.0 -
Thanks guys for your posts. At the risk of sounding completely stupid here, how do you squat and bench in a cage or using a sumo rack? I haven't ever used those before and I'm trying to visualize it....
And while craiglist may be my best bet price wise, I'm getting really impatient trying to find things (been looking for a few months and I really want to just start lifting again already), plus I would have to find someone to help me transport the equipment. I know you guys can't help with that, I'm just frustrated by it.
You just set the safely bars at the right level and just do the squats or bench in them. For the sumo rack you would need to ensure you are positioned correctly so you are squatting with the bar over the safety rails.0 -
Depends. Are you planning on ever bench pressing on your own without a knowledgable spotter?
If so, get a power cage and set the bars above your throat (if you're emotionally attached to your throat and don't want to injure it ... people die benching in their garage because their adrenaline overrides their better judgment, just FYI).
If you have 300 bucks to spend (I'm assuming because of your most expensive choice) and the space for it, get something like this and put a bench in it:
http://www.amazon.com/Power-Squat-Deadlift-Bench-Racks/dp/B004UMM4QC/ref=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&qid=1363793324&sr=8-2&keywords=power+rack
If you're wanting to do something like Starting Strength or Stronglifts, I'd recommend against anything without a safety bar also. If you're planning on progressing much slower, you might get away with something cheaper, but if you already know you're going to be lifting for a long time to come, then why skimp?
^^that one is a good deal - it's actually on sale at the moment - $260. Hmmm...maybe doing some shopping myself!0 -
Depends. Are you planning on ever bench pressing on your own without a knowledgable spotter?
If so, get a power cage and set the bars above your throat (if you're emotionally attached to your throat and don't want to injure it ... people die benching in their garage because their adrenaline overrides their better judgment, just FYI).
If you have 300 bucks to spend (I'm assuming because of your most expensive choice) and the space for it, get something like this and put a bench in it:
http://www.amazon.com/Power-Squat-Deadlift-Bench-Racks/dp/B004UMM4QC/ref=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&qid=1363793324&sr=8-2&keywords=power+rack
If you're wanting to do something like Starting Strength or Stronglifts, I'd recommend against anything without a safety bar also. If you're planning on progressing much slower, you might get away with something cheaper, but if you already know you're going to be lifting for a long time to come, then why skimp?
^^that one is a good deal - it's actually on sale at the moment - $260. Hmmm...maybe doing some shopping myself!
Yeah, I got really excited when I saw that one, and then saw that it's another $100 for shipping =( Still seems to be the best deal though--the sumo racks are way more than that when you factor in shipping. That may be the one I end up going with....just gotta find a decent deal on a bench, bar, and weights. Maybe craigslist will help me out there.0 -
Thanks guys for your posts. At the risk of sounding completely stupid here, how do you squat and bench in a cage or using a sumo rack? I haven't ever used those before and I'm trying to visualize it....
Bench Press is done like this:
Go look at some squat videos in the form check thread for how to use one for squats0 -
Think I may have found a winner....that cage is $360 with shipping, but no bench, which I need. This is $390 with a bench, plus pull up bar and dip station...
http://www.wayfair.com/Marcy-Pro-Power-Rack-and-Bench-PM-3800-MCY1080.html0 -
Thanks guys for your posts. At the risk of sounding completely stupid here, how do you squat and bench in a cage or using a sumo rack? I haven't ever used those before and I'm trying to visualize it....
Bench Press is done like this:
Go look at some squat videos in the form check thread for how to use one for squats
Thank you! :flowerforyou:0 -
Think I may have found a winner....that cage is $360 with shipping, but no bench, which I need. This is $390 with a bench, plus pull up bar and dip station...
http://www.wayfair.com/Marcy-Pro-Power-Rack-and-Bench-PM-3800-MCY1080.html
Nice find. I should have paid attention to the shipping costs on the other one.0 -
If I had room for only one thing, it would be a cage (assuming the bar and weights don't count).0
-
Yeah, I got really excited when I saw that one, and then saw that it's another $100 for shipping =( Still seems to be the best deal though--the sumo racks are way more than that when you factor in shipping. That may be the one I end up going with....just gotta find a decent deal on a bench, bar, and weights. Maybe craigslist will help me out there.
See if you can find one locally. Do y'all have a Play It Again Sports where you live? I got my lifting equipment at Play It Again Sports and am super happy with it.
That's a nice one too!0 -
I absolutely (still) love the TDS cage I bought from New York Barbell: http://www.newyorkbarbells.com/92563.html ~$330. I bought mine 10+ years ago, but it looks just like the one in the pic.0
-
Yeah, I got really excited when I saw that one, and then saw that it's another $100 for shipping =( Still seems to be the best deal though--the sumo racks are way more than that when you factor in shipping. That may be the one I end up going with....just gotta find a decent deal on a bench, bar, and weights. Maybe craigslist will help me out there.
See if you can find one locally. Do y'all have a Play It Again Sports where you live? I got my lifting equipment at Play It Again Sports and am super happy with it.
That's a nice one too!
Closest one is a bit far, plus it would be a real pain in the *kitten* to find a truck to borrow to transport it. Thank you for the suggestion, though!
I think the wayfair website one is the best price I've seen for the equipment so far, but my fiance thinks it's a waste of money and that a regular rack will suffice. I'm trying to convince him otherwise. Silly "we make decisions together" rule
0 -
Yeah, I got really excited when I saw that one, and then saw that it's another $100 for shipping =( Still seems to be the best deal though--the sumo racks are way more than that when you factor in shipping. That may be the one I end up going with....just gotta find a decent deal on a bench, bar, and weights. Maybe craigslist will help me out there.
See if you can find one locally. Do y'all have a Play It Again Sports where you live? I got my lifting equipment at Play It Again Sports and am super happy with it.
That's a nice one too!
Closest one is a bit far, plus it would be a real pain in the *kitten* to find a truck to borrow to transport it. Thank you for the suggestion, though!
I think the wayfair website one is the best price I've seen for the equipment so far, but my fiance thinks it's a waste of money and that a regular rack will suffice. I'm trying to convince him otherwise. Silly "we make decisions together" rule
Play the 'do you want me to risk hurting myself' card.. 0 -
Yeah, I got really excited when I saw that one, and then saw that it's another $100 for shipping =( Still seems to be the best deal though--the sumo racks are way more than that when you factor in shipping. That may be the one I end up going with....just gotta find a decent deal on a bench, bar, and weights. Maybe craigslist will help me out there.
See if you can find one locally. Do y'all have a Play It Again Sports where you live? I got my lifting equipment at Play It Again Sports and am super happy with it.
That's a nice one too!
Closest one is a bit far, plus it would be a real pain in the *kitten* to find a truck to borrow to transport it. Thank you for the suggestion, though!
I think the wayfair website one is the best price I've seen for the equipment so far, but my fiance thinks it's a waste of money and that a regular rack will suffice. I'm trying to convince him otherwise. Silly "we make decisions together" rule
Play the 'do you want me to risk hurting myself' card..
I tried! lol. He said that he would be spotting me so I would be fine (hmmmm, Mister, what about when you lift?? You think I'll be able to properly spot you?...gotta remember to say that later lol). I also don't think he understands that I want to actually be strong, and not "strong for a girl", which means I hope to one day have some serious weight on the bar. We only spoke about it briefly during our lunch break, so when we get home I'm gonna lay it on thiiiiiiick. :happy: Wish me luck!0
This discussion has been closed.