Road vs. Tri bike?

I have done 3 sprint triathlons this season and I definitely want to do more, but need a bike upgrade (I'm riding a hybrid right now). I understand the major differences between road and tri bikes, but I'm still not sure what to get. I would like to do an olympic distance race next year, but don't anticipate longer races than that in the next few years. I am currently in the lower half of my age group for my races and a lot of that is my bike times. In the future, I would really like to go on group rides to get in some longer distances (I'm kind of excluded from those right now, because I can't keep up on my hybrid). I expect that I will do 3-4 races a year and the rest will be training. So what do ya'll think? I'm happy to give more info, if I've left anything important out. Thanks so much for your help!
«1

Replies

  • TyTy76
    TyTy76 Posts: 1,761 Member
    Most group rides will not allow to use a tri bike.

    I would get a decent road bike, and put some shortie aero bars on.


    I know a of people who do all their training on a road bike, then race on their tri bike. (never understood that)
  • mleech77
    mleech77 Posts: 557 Member
    Most group rides will not allow to use a tri bike.

    I would get a decent road bike, and put some shortie aero bars on.


    I know a of people who do all their training on a road bike, then race on their tri bike. (never understood that)
    What Ty said. Pretty much every group ride I've seen organized won't allow tri bikes. They want you to be able to reach the brakes quickly and not have to hop from the aero bars to the horns in order to do so.

    Right now for my tris I'm doing a road bike with aero bars and some adjustments on the seat and stem. Redshift sports makes a quick change system that will allow you to go from road bike profile to tri bike profile if you're interested in that. DCRainmaker has a write up on it from interbike. http://www.dcrainmaker.com/2013/09/redshift-demonstrates-aerobarseatpost.html, or you can check out their site directly. http://www.redshiftsports.com/
  • Thanks a lot! My initial thought was to get a tri bike, but I would like to participate in group rides and hate to eliminate that option. I spoke to a friend earlier (road racer, not tri athlete) and was given the same advice. I feel better having that decision narrowed down, now for all the other choices!
  • scott091501
    scott091501 Posts: 1,260 Member
    There are a lot of bikes that could set up great with some shorty aero bars for tris. Felt's AR series of bikes and Cervelo's S series being two that immediately come to mind. There are lots of group rides here in Houston that you'll just get the side eye from roadies if you show up with a tri bike and you'll have to prove that you can handle the bike in a pack. I have heard stories of triathletes being asked to leave though or just hang off the back of the pace line.

    Oh and in regards to racing on your tri bike and riding your roadie in training. If you have them set up the same (ie fit with the same measurements) it's a lot more cost efficient to put the training miles on your road bike and leave your tri bike set up for racing.
  • SonicDeathMonkey80
    SonicDeathMonkey80 Posts: 4,489 Member
    Road bike. You don't *need* a tri, bike, but you will need a road bike.
  • BrianSharpe
    BrianSharpe Posts: 9,248 Member
    If you can afford to get both, if you're like most of us mere mortals you'd be better of to get a decent road bike.
  • TyTy76
    TyTy76 Posts: 1,761 Member
    Road bike. You don't *need* a tri, bike, but you will need a road bike.

    I have seen people finish Iron-Distance races on hybrid bikes...

    :wink: :wink:
  • scott091501
    scott091501 Posts: 1,260 Member
    Road bike. You don't *need* a tri, bike, but you will need a road bike.

    Not necessarily. I have zero need for a road bike. I can more than hold my own in a pace line with a bunch of roadies on my tri bike. I also see no need to ride with roadies on a regular basis as there are plenty of group rides in my area specifically by triathletes, for triathletes.

    Road bike. You don't *need* a tri, bike, but you will need a road bike.

    I have seen people finish Iron-Distance races on hybrid bikes...

    :wink: :wink:

    Those people are a gluten for punishment. 56-112 miles on a hybrid is nuts.
  • Yeah, my hybrid is a nice bike, but it keeps me from going on any group rides in my area. I end up doing a lot of my bike training at the gym (spin class), but that has not prepared me well for the hills and wind in my recent races. It is also kind of demoralizing to hear "on your left" so many times during a race! I'm ready for a faster bike!
  • FrenchMob
    FrenchMob Posts: 1,167 Member
    Work on the engine before you worry about a bike. If anything, get some road bike tires on your hybrid (700x28c for example) which will help a lot. If you can't keep up with a group ride with the hybrid, chances are you won't be able to with a road bike either, until you further build up your bike cardio.
  • scott091501
    scott091501 Posts: 1,260 Member
    Work on the engine before you worry about a bike. If anything, get some road bike tires on your hybrid (700x28c for example) which will help a lot. If you can't keep up with a group ride with the hybrid, chances are you won't be able to with a road bike either, until you further build up your bike cardio.

    Not sure I'd agree with this. One a hybrid isn't designed for that use. Two, most people don't have hybrids that fit them correctly. While I agree that the engine is of far more importance than the bike a well fit road/tri bike will yield a much more comfortable and enjoyable experience than a hybrid will.
  • Drudoo
    Drudoo Posts: 275 Member
    The aero dynamic benefits of a tri bike in a short distance triathlon are not worth the price. Over a long course, the seconds and watts add up with a tri bikes aerodynamic benefits (foil tubing, aero position, etc.). This is compounded with the different seat post geometry allowing for more use of the quads while 'saving' your hamstrings for the run.

    I'd go road bike if you plan on staying short course and tribike if you plan to dabble in long course. Shortie bars are easy to put on and take off and the road bike will have much more versatility.

    I switch between my tri and road bikes up until 8 weeks from an event then I am strictly on the tri bike.
  • I think that there are very few people that would be able to keep up with a 20-30 mile 18-22 mph group ride on a hybrid.
  • Giraffe33991
    Giraffe33991 Posts: 430 Member
    I do sprint duathlons and have a tri bike. It's much better than a road bike.

    One suggestion...if you're sticking with sprint distances, skip those expenseive clip shoes. You'll never make up the extra time it takes putting them on in transition.
  • I bought a road bike when I wanted to start tris. I was afraid of a tri bike and read about so many people mostly riding their road bikes. After 1.5 years of riding, I just bought my first tri bike and now I'm selling my road bike. I don't go on group rides and I like going fast, therefore I see no point in ever riding my road bike over my tri bike.

    I also tried going the whole road bike with shortie aero bars and all that did was scare me more away from a tri bike because it made my road bike so twitchy. My tri bike though is amazingly not twitchy to the point I am surprised every time I go on a ride on it how comfortable I am on the bars in terms of feeling in control of the bike.

    As to the comment about going without clipless pedals for sprint distances, I can't imagine not having my clipless pedals for all distances. Yes you lose time in transition putting on shoes (unless you do flying mounts/dismounts), but to me at least, it would feel very difficult trying to push my speed without being able to do a full pedal stroke (pushing down and pulling up).
  • trijoe
    trijoe Posts: 729 Member
    I say if you're going to do triathlons then get a freaking tri bike. I don't even own a road bike - just a tri bike and a cross bike. Everything I can do on a road bike, I do on my tri bike. I used to own a road bike, but I got rid of it. My tri bike is so much better! Why keep something I'm not using?

    We have a multitude of tri clubs in my area, and they do group rides all the time. I've been on more group rides than I can count, and all of them on my tri bike.

    You can't group ride on a tri bike? WRONG!!! Anybody who says or thinks this doesn't know what he/she's talking about.

    Find a tri club. Ride with other triathletes. They know what you're trying to accomplish, and have a better chance of helping you get where you want to be with your cycling skills. Road riders act like snobs and jerks toward triathletes. Screw them. I have no time or patience for people like that.

    To repeat: TRI BIKE!!!
  • TyTy76
    TyTy76 Posts: 1,761 Member
    I say if you're going to do triathlons then get a freaking tri bike. I don't even own a road bike - just a tri bike and a cross bike. Everything I can do on a road bike, I do on my tri bike. I used to own a road bike, but I got rid of it. My tri bike is so much better! Why keep something I'm not using?

    We have a multitude of tri clubs in my area, and they do group rides all the time. I've been on more group rides than I can count, and all of them on my tri bike.

    You can't group ride on a tri bike? WRONG!!! Anybody who says or thinks this doesn't know what he/she's talking about.

    Find a tri club. Ride with other triathletes. They know what you're trying to accomplish, and have a better chance of helping you get where you want to be with your cycling skills. Road riders act like snobs and jerks toward triathletes. Screw them. I have no time or patience for people like that.

    To repeat: TRI BIKE!!!

    So there have been 3 or 4 people in this thread that don't know what they are talking about?

    okay then..
  • scott091501
    scott091501 Posts: 1,260 Member
    I say if you're going to do triathlons then get a freaking tri bike. I don't even own a road bike - just a tri bike and a cross bike. Everything I can do on a road bike, I do on my tri bike. I used to own a road bike, but I got rid of it. My tri bike is so much better! Why keep something I'm not using?

    We have a multitude of tri clubs in my area, and they do group rides all the time. I've been on more group rides than I can count, and all of them on my tri bike.

    You can't group ride on a tri bike? WRONG!!! Anybody who says or thinks this doesn't know what he/she's talking about.

    Find a tri club. Ride with other triathletes. They know what you're trying to accomplish, and have a better chance of helping you get where you want to be with your cycling skills. Road riders act like snobs and jerks toward triathletes. Screw them. I have no time or patience for people like that.

    To repeat: TRI BIKE!!!

    So there have been 3 or 4 people in this thread that don't know what they are talking about?

    okay then..

    FWIW I actually agree with Joe on most points but wanted to couch my opinion incase there were roadies here. I've been to several group rides and you will get the side eye from roadies. You just end up spending a crap ton of time proving you can handle your bike in a pace line. Honestly not worth my time. I'd train on a tri bike with other triathletes.
  • SonicDeathMonkey80
    SonicDeathMonkey80 Posts: 4,489 Member
    Not everybody is from a big enough city that is lucky enough to have tri clubs and roadie clubs.
  • The tri bike on group rides issue is only an issue if you go on group rides. Honestly, I've never seen the appeal in them. I don't do my running in a group so I see now reason why to ride in a group.
  • TyTy76
    TyTy76 Posts: 1,761 Member
    The tri bike on group rides issue is only an issue if you go on group rides.

    Which the OP said they wanted to do.

    So for the OP it is an issue.
  • Yes, I have a friend who is really into cycling and would love to join her on some rides. I do not live in a neighborhood that is easy to ride more than ~8 miles in without just doing really short loops around the same areas, so to increase my distance for long rides I need to drive somewhere else. I feel a little bit safer having a group along with me. I have never rode on anything other than a hybrid bike in my life and used to fall down all the time as a kid and young adult. I've been a bit scared about making the transition to a faster bike, but need to get over that. I ended up getting a road bike over the weekend. I really appreciate all of your comments and suggestions and I've actually learned a lot from you. Maybe in a year or two I can add a tri bike to my collection. I just got my new shoes and pedals (never rode a bike with these before) and I am going out tomorrow evening to practice in a safe area. I am not the most coordinated person in the world, so keep your fingers crossed for me!
  • IronPhyllida
    IronPhyllida Posts: 533 Member
    Yes, I have a friend who is really into cycling and would love to join her on some rides. I do not live in a neighborhood that is easy to ride more than ~8 miles in without just doing really short loops around the same areas, so to increase my distance for long rides I need to drive somewhere else. I feel a little bit safer having a group along with me. I have never rode on anything other than a hybrid bike in my life and used to fall down all the time as a kid and young adult. I've been a bit scared about making the transition to a faster bike, but need to get over that. I ended up getting a road bike over the weekend. I really appreciate all of your comments and suggestions and I've actually learned a lot from you. Maybe in a year or two I can add a tri bike to my collection. I just got my new shoes and pedals (never rode a bike with these before) and I am going out tomorrow evening to practice in a safe area. I am not the most coordinated person in the world, so keep your fingers crossed for me!
    Good luck!!
  • FrenchMob
    FrenchMob Posts: 1,167 Member

    You can't group ride on a tri bike? WRONG!!! Anybody who says or thinks this doesn't know what he/she's talking about.
    Don't get your tri shorts in a bunch. Actually, most roadie clubs won't allow tri bikes on their group rides so you're not entirely right either.
  • FrenchMob
    FrenchMob Posts: 1,167 Member
    This is me in May 2010 - First year of multisport. What I'm riding is a 2003 Rocky Mountain Metro - hybrid. I swapped the flat bar for a aero bar setup I picked up used for $80. I swapped the tires to 700x28c Gatorskins on the original 32 spoke heavy wheels. The bike weighed in at 27.5 lbs in "race" trim. My race mountain bike weighs a little less than that..lol
    asi1.jpg

    On this 30 km (18.6 mile) rolling course with a few good climbs, I averaged 20.5 MPH.

    At my next race a month later, another 30 km bike course, but this time fairly flat but I did have to turn around close to the end because my Garmin popped out of the quick release and had to go pick it up...I still managed an average speed of 21.6 MPH.
    This is the race coming into transition - look at those quads..lol
    dsc00713_small.jpg

    Again, the engine is worth more than the equipment.
  • scott091501
    scott091501 Posts: 1,260 Member
    I'll agree with a good engine trumps all. That said have the right tools for the job, and a hybrid ain't it. Buy a road or tri bike that is most importantly FIT CORRECTLY. A correctly fit bike will allow you to make the most efficient use of energy and it will hide you from the wind. Thus it sets you up to run better than an ill fitted bike would and it cuts down on drag.
  • trijoe
    trijoe Posts: 729 Member

    You can't group ride on a tri bike? WRONG!!! Anybody who says or thinks this doesn't know what he/she's talking about.
    Don't get your tri shorts in a bunch. Actually, most roadie clubs won't allow tri bikes on their group rides so you're not entirely right either.

    A rather annoying comment.

    Who says she said "Roadie clubs"? She didn't. There are TONS of groups out there doing rides that aren't "roadie clubs". Maybe you should pay more attention to what's said, vs/ what you infer.

    I stand by my point. You do not need a road bike to go on group rides. Get the bike you want, to do the job you want. From there, it's pretty easy to find like minded people to ride with. It's as simple as that.
  • TyTy76
    TyTy76 Posts: 1,761 Member

    You can't group ride on a tri bike? WRONG!!! Anybody who says or thinks this doesn't know what he/she's talking about.
    Don't get your tri shorts in a bunch. Actually, most roadie clubs won't allow tri bikes on their group rides so you're not entirely right either.

    A rather annoying comment.

    Who says she said "Roadie clubs"? She didn't. There are TONS of groups out there doing rides that aren't "roadie clubs". Maybe you should pay more attention to what's said, vs/ what you infer.

    I stand by my point. You do not need a road bike to go on group rides. Get the bike you want, to do the job you want. From there, it's pretty easy to find like minded people to ride with. It's as simple as that.

    Maybe you should quit being such an *kitten* maybe that's not your intention but you are
  • KathleenKP
    KathleenKP Posts: 580 Member
    I live in a large metro area (well, actually suburb type area) and have found a difference between the bike shops - in their recs, but more importantly to some of the comments I've been following in this thread - re: whether tri bikes are welcome on group rides.

    The one closest to me (local bike store chain) mainly focuses on road/mountain type bikes. They were discouraging me from any type of aero bars, saying they are not safe as add-ons, etc. That I couldn't use aero bars on group rides. They do not carry tri bikes in the shop, but will order them in. They won't come out and SAY they don't do tri bikes (they'd love to sell me one!), but I wasn't feeling like they really knew tri stuff. I've really liked these guys when they have tuned my bike, etc.

    There is another shop 10 miles away that I finally made it to today. They are a private/truly local shop with two store fronts. I went on recommendation of someone I know. This shop is a tri shop. They carry tri bikes (and rent wet suits). They are the bike support for the local HIM as well as other local tris. They also do group rides every week (some century rides, too), and half the people in the advanced group ride on tri bikes. I will probably be joining them in the Spring, or whenever my doctor clears me to ride. The person I know rides in the advanced group. (He doesn't do tris, but races mountain/cross/road.) I plan to start with the beginning group to get ride experience/etiquette/knowledge, but that guy and the shop owner said I will be moving to the advanced group pretty quickly with my speed (I laugh at that, although the beginner group top speed is where I was on my own).

    So I went in to look at the Felt AR, thinking of getting it changed out with tri parts, but he discouraged me from a tri bike for now. There is a new 2014 (with some pink, which I wanted!!) that will be coming in very soon. I can't remember which model, but I will be going back in the next week to get some shoes (had to leave to pick up my kids). He said that with the type of hills and roads we have here (including that HIM I have my eyes on), a road bike is what I need now (though probably 98% of participants use tri bikes for the actual race). He suggested to get the road bike and then turn it into my off-season training/rain bike if/when I eventually get a tri bike. I will likely get the aero bars put on because I also need them medically due to my wrist surgery. Disagreeing with the other shop, he said the aero bars were no different safety-wise than riding in the drops b/c either position requires you to move to get to your brakes. I told him right up front that I might have a lead on a used Felt. He was so non-pressure and willing to share lots of info anyway (and I've heard that about them). They have Cervelos and some others, but he said for the training bike, Felt was probably the way to go (cheaper, but still a good product), and to save the money to spend towards a tri bike later.

    Anyway, I'm just putting my experience so far out there for other newbies like me, and welcome input from more seasoned competitors.
  • KathleenKP
    KathleenKP Posts: 580 Member
    I forgot - with the tri shop, they partner with a physical therapist who does a bike fit (comes with the purchase) that will take 2-3 hours. They have a seat program where you trade out for a loaner seat and ride several hundred miles on it until you find the right seat. And there is lifetime maintenance. The other local shop offers none of that, and will sell me a bike for the same prices.