Weight lifting
sleevedjaimi
Posts: 12 Member
The great debate of lifting after bariatric surgery. How many of you regularly incorporate weights into your week? How many are against it? There's so many views on weight lifting. I've started lifting weights 4X a week (heavy weights) and incorporating some cardio into that. On the other 3 days I am doing strictly cardio. Anyone lifted weights and stalled losing for a bit, how long was your stall?
Just want to hear other's opinions!
Just want to hear other's opinions!
0
Replies
-
As I got closer to goal, and needed fewer calories burned from my workouts, I reduced the cardio time and added in more weights. In hindsight, I wish I would have added weights earlier, I may have reduced the lean body mass lost. I'm not doing great at getting to the gym as often as I would like (I am aiming for 3x per week), but the summer is more active, so I am getting more outside time exercise. Hopefully after our really busy June, I will be able to get back on track and lift more.
I am aiming for 3 sets of 10 reps on the machines and a couple sets of (assisted) pullups. If I get into a three times per week routine, I plan to have one day be heavier weights, lower reps.
Edited to add: I haven't seen many advocating *not* lifting.0 -
THANK YOU for this thread. My only type of exercise has been walking and running, and I've been wanting to incorporate weights in. I got a blister on my foot from some new dress shoes two days ago, and after (unwisely) running on it last night, I was bummed when I knew this morning that I need to lay off walking/running for a couple of days. Now I know exactly what to do - time to quit putting off the weights and just go do it.0
-
I do both cardio and strength training. I have been doing the cardio since before I had my surgery, and I started using the machines at the gym several months after. I started working with a trainer after that, and I still do strength training, but it's more core-focused. I do cardio 5-6 times a week, and I try to do strength training 3 times a week.0
-
Thanks for the replies. I'm just worried that if I am so focused on lifting I won't lose the weight.0
-
Even if you have a slight stall in your weight-loss, the benefits of lifting and the overall fat loss you will achieve is worth it!0
-
I try to walk, bike or do elliptical 5x week and since two months post op I've been lifting weights 3-4x week. I've been doing two sets of ten reps and I plan to bump that up to three sets soon. I am really enjoying the weight lifting, it feels great. While it's probably increased my muscle mass some, that's inconsequently compared to my overall weight loss. It's helped my balance as my center of gravity and gait have changed, it's strengthened muscles around arthritic knees and bad back helping resolve the chronic joint pain I used to have...I could go on. I believe weightlifting has had more positive impact on my emerging body than has aerobic excercise. I highly recommend weight lifting.0
-
I started lifting as soon as I was cleared after my surgery. I do 50/50 weighs and cardio. I usually alternate days between weighs and running.0
-
I have a friend who had his RNY a few years ago. He told me to start weight lifting when I first mentioned that I was serious about the surgery. He believes that it really helped with "filling in the loose skin on his arms". Also, that you'll "really appreciate having stronger leg muscles when standing and squatting post-op." Of course that's antecdotal and YOMV.
My docs told me that I'll be able to return to my lifting program within 4 weeks post-op, as long as the stitches heal. Directly after surgery, they advise against lifting anything over 40#.0 -
Yes! I tore my internal stitches at 2.5 weeks post-op, likely from lifting a 25# toddler. Wait 4 weeks to lift - the tearing is so painful!0
-
I do strength training 3 times a week normally, and do cardio 6 times a week. I had a arm lift in May and still waiting to get cleared to do weights again. My trainer said that weights is the best way to lose the fat, and I don't worry about what that scale says as my size is so much smaller.0
-
I do cardio 6 times a week and strength training 3 times a week. I do 2 sets of 15, hoping to move that to 3 sets in a week or so. I am 7 weeks out.0
-
ok, I know that I should probably avoid asking this especially here among those that do weights regularly, but here goes. My son in law is into power lifting. Since I don't know much about it, and am trying to be a good (or better) mother in law, I thought that I would ask his advice on adding weights to my workout. He will be here in the coming week and I don't want to approach him on this if it will cause more division between us.
So, are the weights you all are doing the barbell, big bar type weights and bench pressing etc, or do you mean using the weight machines at the gym? I hadn't considered the weight machines as "doing weights" but it could be. I injured my shoulder last fall using the machines at too high of a weight and ended up with surgery in November. That was right when I began my bariatric inquiry. I haven't used them since.
I consulted someone at the club to help me determine my weights on each machine, but I don't trust that now and wondered how you all determined where to start. I want to get benefits without hurting myself and need to set a new routine for workouts. I have gone back to the gym now for water exercise and also ride the recumbent bike I got for my home. If anyone can help me out with advice, I would love that. Reply here or message me please.0 -
jillcwatson - I'd ask the son-in-law for help. as a power lifter, he had to start with "regular" weight lifting and still has a routine that he follows. the upside to asking him for help is that he will be "afraid" to cause you any injuries and risk the wrath of both his wife and you (lol).0
-
Jill, you are going to get better advice from your son in law if you are clear in what you are asking. Do some reading on the web to understand some of the basics and then ask SIL to come to the gym with you to check your form on the machines or benches.
I am adding a mix of machines and barbell work, and Dumbbells are supposed to be great as well. My approach is to add weight as long as I am able to keep correct form. For me this means that I am not changing form late in the set when it gets hard. If I start changing my form, I stop. I mix it up between a weight that I can do yhree sets of 10-12 and a weight I can do two or three sets of 5 reps. I figure as long as I don't hurt myself I'm doing myself good.
Start slow and don't feel pressure to increase weight quickly. You'll like how you feel and look. I have found that "lifting tired" is different (and better) than "cardio tired".
Rob0 -
I do a lot of lifting. Honestly, I don't care about stalls. I have actually just added creatine to my diet which is causing a bit of a gain. My body had changed far more than it would have with without the lifting. After all, isn't the goal to be healthy and to look better? A big fear of mine with surgery was losing muscle. WLS causes quick losses which unfortunately includes a lot of lean body mass (muscle). Losing too much muscle will not only slow your metabolism in the long run but it will decrease your strength and give you that "skinny fat" look. There are so many benefits to weigh lifting such as decrease risk of osteoporosis (very important for women and even more so after surgery because of decreased absorption), better balance and posture etc. I highly recommend it.0
-
I invested in a personal trainer to help me with my fitness goals, and I meet with him twice a week for weights (I do cardio 5-7 days a week--mostly running). I also try to do hand weights (12-15 lbs) at home once a week.
Anyway, the trainer and I do lots of different stuff: I flip tires and swing sledgehammers, I lift barbells and toss medicine balls, I use weight machines and kettle bells. Keeping it varied means I'm still sore after every workout--you sort of get used to it, lol--and that I don't get bored with it.
I don't think that lifting or running has caused me to gain weight in any way. It certainly has helped me maintain muscle mass while losing. The hardest part has been to maintain proper nutrition for my workouts--it can sometimes be difficult to know how many calories to consume so weight loss stays on track, but also so I have enough energy.0 -
I started out using soup cans and water bottles as weights. But now have a set of dumbbells at home and love them. Started six months out from surgery which probably helped maintain muscle mass.
The muscle gain probably triggered a stall (but there were so many stalls back then)... On the flip side, stopping exercise for a couple months seemed to help the weight drop off again. In the long run, gaining muscle might weigh a bit more, but will be slimmer and healthier.
There are exercise challenges on MFP (google YouTube to learn good form) which encourage working out.0 -
Don't hesitate to talk to your son in law, if he's knowledgable he'll tailor his advice appropriately. I use machines, they count (it's all resistance training). I may start to work in free weights and kettle bells as I gain strength and confidence. But at 55, I'm not the jock I was 30 years ago; it's most important to use proper from, not overdo it, and weave it in as part of your long term fitness routine and keep it enjoyable.0
-
I appreciate all of your comments. Nick will be here Monday night and I suspect we will hit the gym on Tuesday morning. I will be ready to listen and learn and then be adding some weights to my new exercise routine.
0 -
jillcwatson1 wrote: »ok, I know that I should probably avoid asking this especially here among those that do weights regularly, but here goes. My son in law is into power lifting. Since I don't know much about it, and am trying to be a good (or better) mother in law, I thought that I would ask his advice on adding weights to my workout. He will be here in the coming week and I don't want to approach him on this if it will cause more division between us.
So, are the weights you all are doing the barbell, big bar type weights and bench pressing etc, or do you mean using the weight machines at the gym? I hadn't considered the weight machines as "doing weights" but it could be. I injured my shoulder last fall using the machines at too high of a weight and ended up with surgery in November. That was right when I began my bariatric inquiry. I haven't used them since.
I consulted someone at the club to help me determine my weights on each machine, but I don't trust that now and wondered how you all determined where to start. I want to get benefits without hurting myself and need to set a new routine for workouts. I have gone back to the gym now for water exercise and also ride the recumbent bike I got for my home. If anyone can help me out with advice, I would love that. Reply here or message me please.
I use mostly barbell and dumbells. The only machine I use are the pulley, leg press and leg extension. I avoid them as much as possible because they usually only work one muscle group, you use less stabilizing muscles and if the machine isn't just right, it can cause bad form which can cause injury. As far as asking the SIL, keep in mind that power lifting is very different (It focuses on strength in usually 3 particular lifts-squat, bench press and deadlift). He may be able to give some advise but you may be better off with a personal trainer. I do think from a relationship standpoint, he will appreciate your asking him.0 -
gaining_while_losing wrote: »Even if you have a slight stall in your weight-loss, the benefits of lifting and the overall fat loss you will achieve is worth it!
This is exactly what my Doc and my trainer at the gym said! My Doc encouraged me to start slowly with light weights after 4-6 weeks. The more muscle you build the better the actual fat loss.0 -
Take your measurements every 2 weeks if you're not doing that already. When you start lifting even if you have a stalled scale, your measurements will show progress.0
-
I do a power class that you use weights on barbell and do a variety of movements for an all body workout. I also work with trainer using the TRX, kettlebells and other various workout items. Your SIL will probably be happy to assist you.0
This discussion has been closed.