Fake Sweeteners - seriously

2

Replies

  • RockstarWilson
    RockstarWilson Posts: 836 Member
    I finally found a sweetener that isn't very sweet. :smiley:
    Great Value 0 calorie sweetener made with stevia extract.
    1 packet in a 20 oz coffee is just about right.

    Now and with all new foods I have to check my bg# 2 hours
    afterwards to make sure it's a good fit.

    Pre-breakfast 99
    Post-breakfast 104

    Coffee & stevia are in :smiley:

    What was your breakfast?
  • KenSmith108
    KenSmith108 Posts: 1,967 Member
    I finally found a sweetener that isn't very sweet. :smiley:
    Great Value 0 calorie sweetener made with stevia extract.
    1 packet in a 20 oz coffee is just about right.

    Now and with all new foods I have to check my bg# 2 hours
    afterwards to make sure it's a good fit.

    Pre-breakfast 99
    Post-breakfast 104

    Coffee & stevia are in :smiley:

    What was your breakfast?

    My breakfast was: 3 scrambled eggs with a tablespoon of heavy cream, cast iron cooked
    in a tablespoon of butter. Topped with a 1/4 cup shredded taco blend cheese.
    Coffee with stevia

    500 cals, 5g carbs, 0g fiber, 25g protein & 41g fat

    Delicious!!!
  • gaelicstorm26
    gaelicstorm26 Posts: 589 Member
    I think that, like anything, moderation is key. For those who shouldn't really be ingesting much real sugar, artificial sweeteners can be quite helpful.

    Personally, I try not to rely on them that much. I know that my Greek yogurt is sweetened with them, but the low carb content and protein punch is worth it for me. I rarely drink diet soda. I prefer water with a decent amount of lemon. I do sometimes have one of those fruit-flavored seltzer water. Water all the time does get a bit boring...it's nice to mix it up a few times a week.

    I think that anything, when used in excess, can become unhealthy. Honestly, I'm more concerned with the crappy air I breathe everyday. Ick.
  • SkinnyKerinny
    SkinnyKerinny Posts: 147 Member
    I'll be so happy when I get my house-- I have so many plans to grow a nice garden like I had long ago. Stevia will be one of the first things. Then I'll just throw the leaves and water in the Vitamix and strain the liquid with a nut milk bag. Then I'll know there isn't anything in there that I don't want to ingest.
  • auntstephie321
    auntstephie321 Posts: 3,586 Member
    I'll be so happy when I get my house-- I have so many plans to grow a nice garden like I had long ago. Stevia will be one of the first things. Then I'll just throw the leaves and water in the Vitamix and strain the liquid with a nut milk bag. Then I'll know there isn't anything in there that I don't want to ingest.

    We bought a stevia plant recently with some other herbs. It grows beautifully.
  • Kitnthecat
    Kitnthecat Posts: 2,076 Member
    There is no way I will ever consume Aspartame or Splenda again, but I will use very tiny amounts of stevia and xylitol or real sugar.....but very rarely. I find that I don't want a sweet taste in my food very often. Just don't need any sweetener very often, so usually skip sweet altogether.
  • JessicaLCHF
    JessicaLCHF Posts: 1,265 Member
    If love to get to the place where I could drink coffee black (mainly cause I'm impressed by it, lol) but I'm no where close yet! And now that I'm LCHF I'm loving heavy cream. I do think Ima try to halve my sweet dosage again tho.
  • KnitOrMiss
    KnitOrMiss Posts: 10,103 Member
    I have a FB friend who is on a mission against Splenda/aspartame. She's posting and tagging me in post after post. I DO thing they aren't the best choice, and maybe dangerous, but I think of them as the lesser of two evils.

    Being a diabetic I can't do sugar or honey. Being a low carber, I don't want to waste carbs on them but I still want some sweet sometimes.

    Her posts go to sites I don't consider real legit. But I am wondering if I'm doing serious damage to my body. Has anyone here studied this out and have real legit sources to share?

    I'd include stevia in the fake stuff cause it's the processed stuff or TRUVIA which is readily available in foods I would buy (yes I'm aware you can grow it but I don't mean the plant).

    I have gone up and down this whole gamut a few times now. I've posted this in other related questions, but what it comes down to for me is this.

    I am insulin resistant with a strong side effect of postprandial solemnolance. I am not diabetic. However, I react to:

    Aspartame - sore throat, headaches and cravings (tastes bad) - less reaction if paired with heavy fats.
    Splenda (sucralose) - hard crashes, headaches (if liquid), and HARD cravings
    Stevia, liquid, with dextrose or maltodextrin - headaches (liquid - natural flavors), hard crashes, strong cravings
    Erythritol - hard crashes, moderate cravings.
    Other sugar alcohols - severe gastro distress, crashes, cravings
    Xylitol/SA in Trident gum - consumed in very limited quantities - no major reaction, in large quantities, same as erythritol.
    Monk Fruit - Too Pricey for me right now.

    Only one I have found that doesn't affect me in headaches or crashes - though it still does trigger milder cravings if used too much - is Sweet Leaf Stevia packets. However, I'm terrified to try the liquid drops because they include those scary natural flavors that give me migraine-like headaches.

    Walden farms - headaches, crashes, cravings
    Torani - tastes bad, crashes, cravings

    So for me, I stick with the sweet leaf stevia packets/powder. It is the only one my body will partially tolerate. I have isolated each of the sweeteners above and verified reactions... So I don't know if they affect my BG, but it would stand to reason considering they do spike my insulin....

    As most other said, find what you tolerate, use it as little as possible, and live your life...
  • GaleHawkins
    GaleHawkins Posts: 8,159 Member
    Maybe it is just a dense guy thing but I found if I drink something like coffee or tea without sugar for a couple week I am as free from fake carbs as I am real carbs. I was getting stomach discomfort from some sweeteners so I just stopped all.
  • KnitOrMiss
    KnitOrMiss Posts: 10,103 Member
    My thing is that I love tea, but tea does not always love me. The tannins in tea cause a weird chemical-type reaction in my mouth that is not...enjoyable. A single sweetener packet or half of one minimizes this for me. I guess I can try just heavy cream to see if that helps. My body is currently boycotting coconut oil for some reason.
  • jillmcafee
    jillmcafee Posts: 34 Member
    I tolerate aspartame fairly well, but sucralose gives me migraines. I have to check labels now, since a lot of products are switching to sucralose as a sweetener. Sucralose is chlorinated sugar (as in swimming pool chorine - ick!), which probably explains why it affects me that way!

    Sugar alcohols cause ... GI distress ... to both me and my husband, so we have banned them in our home - LOL!
  • pootle1972
    pootle1972 Posts: 579 Member
    Ewwww.......im pouring away my sugar free chlorine drink now....
  • totaloblivia
    totaloblivia Posts: 1,164 Member
    I wish I could kick my diet coke with aspartame... seems harder to do without than alcohol (decided I had to go alcohol free again to get back to losing weight...it had definitely started to creep back to an every day event).
  • Sajyana
    Sajyana Posts: 518 Member
    If love to get to the place where I could drink coffee black (mainly cause I'm impressed by it, lol) but I'm no where close yet! And now that I'm LCHF I'm loving heavy cream. I do think Ima try to halve my sweet dosage again tho.

    I did this. I used to drink my coffee half coffee and half hot milk with 2 very heaped teaspoons of sugar. I replaced the sugar with monk fruit sweetener, gradually reducing the amount and replaced the milk with double cream.

    I can now drink coffee straight and black although I prefer it with cream. I no longer use any sweetener at all.

  • GaleHawkins
    GaleHawkins Posts: 8,159 Member
    @Sajyana I followed the same path on coffee with heavy sugar and milk. I got down to black OK but when I went LCHF I started using cream and now it is 36% butter fat Heavy Whipping Cream. The fake sugars had started to cause belly discomfort unlike real carbs.
  • KnitOrMiss
    KnitOrMiss Posts: 10,103 Member
    This conversation makes me really wish I liked coffee.... I haven't found a way to tolerate tea this way yet.
  • ladipoet
    ladipoet Posts: 4,180 Member
    I will only comment that Aspartame ( which Coke is now removing totally, as sales are dropping, as with pepsi..people don't want it in their drinks) is a substance that was POORLY tested, and yet the FDA inner circle went ahead and approved it..much like the untested grain experiment on the Amerina people by Ancel Keyes.

    In any reading you will find more than 20,000 complaints filed on Aspartame, then the FDA decided to hide the issue by lumping the complaints inside a different group name..so they disappear.

    Dr. Mercola is totally against it..but Dr.bernstein ( diabetes expert) is FOR it… and against Truvia as it spikes his BG

    I am not thrilled to consume it..if it gets really hot, then cools I am not certain it is the same chemistry….soldiers in the M.E. said the soda cans were boiling in heat…and tasted weird after….

    I do have it on rare occasion….Dr. Fung believes any AS is too tempting and delivers insulin kicks… so it is difficult to lower our need for a sweet taste with something really 'safe'

    I switched to liquid Stevia to avoid maltodextrose, then the KAL brand started ADDING maltodextrose to that too!!

    I stay away from Aspartame (aka Nutrasweet aka Equal) by choice because it is a neurotoxin. It is a triple molecule composed of aspartic acid, phenylalynine and methanol (wood alcohol). These three substances are all neurotoxins. There is a section on the following link about 3/4ths of the way down which focuses on Aspartame so if you check out the following link just search for the terms "aspartame" to find the section:

    http://www.thedoctorwithin.com/sugar/sugar-the-sweet-thief-of-life/

    Methanol is a by-product of Aspartame after Aspartame breaks down in the small intestine which is then changed into formaldehyde in the body. I have no desire to pickle myself prematurely. That's what undertakers are for. Researchers also discovered that digestion is not even necessary to break down aspartame into these three toxins: when diet soda sweetened with Aspartame sits in a room where the temperate goes above 86 degrees Fahrenheit, formaldehyde is produced.

    I use liquid sucralose (aka Spelnda) among others like Just Like Sugar, Swerve, stevia, monk fruit, etc. as sweeteners because although I've done a lot of research on Splenda, I haven't found anything conclusive on it like I have on aspartame. I know there are those out there who can't or won't use artificial sweeteners due to health issues or personal choices. Unfortunately, I do not have a choice except to use artificial sweeteners. :/
  • kirkor
    kirkor Posts: 2,530 Member
    @ladipoet
    • The idea that aspartame causes "methanol toxicity" is based on the fact that when digested, aspartame does release a tiny amount of methanol. It's less than the amount you get from eating a piece of most any fruit. Tomato juice, for example, gives you four times the methanol of a can of diet soda. It's a common, naturally occuring environmental compound that is found in many foods. Nancy Markle, one of the most vocal aspartame conspiracy theorists, charges that the autoimmune disease lupus is actually misdiagnosed methanol toxicity caused by drinking 3-4 cans of diet soft drinks per day. If she's right, everyone who drinks a glass of tomato juice each day (or the equivalent in other fruits) is gravely ill with lupus. Time Magazine once devoted an entire article to debunking Nancy Markle's baseless claims about aspartame.

    • Much has been made of the claim that aspartame turns into formaldehyde in your system. This is true, because formaldehyde is a natural byproduct of digestion of methanol, and it happens whenever you eat almost anything. Formaldehyde is carcinogenic and is considered very dangerous in cases of occupational exposure, for example, when you get a dosage many orders of magnitude greater than the trace amounts produced during natural digestion. Again, aspartame does this in much smaller amounts than many common foods, so this has been a normal, healthy component of digestion for as long as humans have been eating fruits and vegetables.
    http://skeptoid.com/episodes/4127
  • nvmomketo
    nvmomketo Posts: 12,019 Member
    Coconut cream in coffee or chai tea adds a touch of sweetness so i will sometimes skip my stevia drop.
  • nicsflyingcircus
    nicsflyingcircus Posts: 2,899 Member
    I will only comment that Aspartame ( which Coke is now removing totally, as sales are dropping, as with pepsi..people don't want it in their drinks) is a substance that was POORLY tested, and yet the FDA inner circle went ahead and approved it..much like the untested grain experiment on the Amerina people by Ancel Keyes.

    In any reading you will find more than 20,000 complaints filed on Aspartame, then the FDA decided to hide the issue by lumping the complaints inside a different group name..so they disappear.

    Dr. Mercola is totally against it..but Dr.bernstein ( diabetes expert) is FOR it… and against Truvia as it spikes his BG

    I am not thrilled to consume it..if it gets really hot, then cools I am not certain it is the same chemistry….soldiers in the M.E. said the soda cans were boiling in heat…and tasted weird after….

    I do have it on rare occasion….Dr. Fung believes any AS is too tempting and delivers insulin kicks… so it is difficult to lower our need for a sweet taste with something really 'safe'

    I switched to liquid Stevia to avoid maltodextrose, then the KAL brand started ADDING maltodextrose to that too!!

    I use the Sweet Leaf liquid Stevia. A small bottle lasts me a looong time, since I use about 3 drops in an 8oz cup of coffee, ditto for any teas I might consume. NO added nothing that I am aware of.
  • KenSmith108
    KenSmith108 Posts: 1,967 Member
    Please don't laugh. How do you measure drops? Even when I give the slightest squeeze on the
    liquid stevia bottle it streams out, usually ruining my drink. The only work around I found so far is to make
    really big drinks, I don't drink coffee by the quart. :-(
  • Sunny_Bunny_
    Sunny_Bunny_ Posts: 7,140 Member
    Please don't laugh. How do you measure drops? Even when I give the slightest squeeze on the
    liquid stevia bottle it streams out, usually ruining my drink. The only work around I found so far is to make
    really big drinks, I don't drink coffee by the quart. :-(

    The sweet leaf and some others have an eye dropper type of dispenser. I also have the kind you're talking about too. Mostly measure those by how long you squeeze.
  • nicsflyingcircus
    nicsflyingcircus Posts: 2,899 Member
    Please don't laugh. How do you measure drops? Even when I give the slightest squeeze on the
    liquid stevia bottle it streams out, usually ruining my drink. The only work around I found so far is to make
    really big drinks, I don't drink coffee by the quart. :-(

    The sweet leaf and some others have an eye dropper type of dispenser. I also have the kind you're talking about too. Mostly measure those by how long you squeeze.

    This... when I give my dropper a gentle squeeze, I get... drops. If I squeeze it full out, I get a mini-stream.

  • Sunny_Bunny_
    Sunny_Bunny_ Posts: 7,140 Member
    Here's an example.

    s3a0i1ooj0lq.jpg
  • nvmomketo
    nvmomketo Posts: 12,019 Member
    Please don't laugh. How do you measure drops? Even when I give the slightest squeeze on the
    liquid stevia bottle it streams out, usually ruining my drink. The only work around I found so far is to make
    really big drinks, I don't drink coffee by the quart. :-(

    I find if I squeeze out a few drops before removing the dropper from the bottle, it then drips at a more controlled rate. I rub the sides of the dropper off on the edge of the bottle. It IS runny stuff.
  • KenSmith108
    KenSmith108 Posts: 1,967 Member
    Thanks, I just went to Walmart. I now have a Rube Goldburg stevia dispenser.
    I bought a Scope sample size bottle & an eye dropper set.
    My sweetie washed the bottle & I squeezed the liquid into it.
    The eyedropper reaches all the way to the bottom of the bottle. :smile:
    My world just became a better place. :lol:
    Thanks again.
  • rumrunner91
    rumrunner91 Posts: 7 Member
    edited September 2015
    NYTimes just posted an article on this subject the other day: http://www.nytimes.com/2015/07/28/upshot/the-evidence-supports-artificial-sweeteners-over-sugar.html?action=click&pgtype=Homepage&region=CColumn&module=MostEmailed&version=Full&src=me&WT.nav=MostEmailed&abt=0002&abg=1&_r=0

    (In case the link doesn't work, the title is "The Evidence Supports Artificial Sweeteners Over Sugar" and it's by Aaron Carroll.)

    If your friend is anything like my mother, this article probably won't convince her but it may help your peace of mind :smile:

    EDIT: The NYTimes posted this article on this subject several months ago but apparently is still in the "just the other day" section of my brain :confused:
  • greenautumn17
    greenautumn17 Posts: 322 Member
    Thanks, I just went to Walmart. I now have a Rube Goldburg stevia dispenser.
    I bought a Scope sample size bottle & an eye dropper set.
    My sweetie washed the bottle & I squeezed the liquid into it.
    The eyedropper reaches all the way to the bottom of the bottle. :smile:
    My world just became a better place. :lol:
    Thanks again.

    That sounds like a great idea!
  • Sajyana
    Sajyana Posts: 518 Member
    Please don't laugh. How do you measure drops? Even when I give the slightest squeeze on the
    liquid stevia bottle it streams out, usually ruining my drink. The only work around I found so far is to make
    really big drinks, I don't drink coffee by the quart. :-(

    You should be able to buy an eye dropper that you could use. I have bought little brown coloured glass bottles with eye droppers in the past. In Australia, I've found them at Chemist shops that dispense medications. Another source might be a shop that sells essential oils or similar.
  • SkinnyKerinny
    SkinnyKerinny Posts: 147 Member
    Just for the record, phenylalynine is not a neurotoxin-- it's an essential amino acid. I'm not saying I advocate isolating aminos and then ingesting them separate from the source food. But it is an amino acid.
This discussion has been closed.