Can nuts really stall you?
ettaterrell
Posts: 887 Member
I've been stuck since around Christmas from having a few beans and a few drinks over the new year. How ever From past experience I should be moving by now and I'm not. The only thing different is I bought a can of mixed nuts.. I measure them on scale and usually only 1 serving and was working them into my calorie goals. How ever I was just reading another post and she was having problems being stuck and everyone was saying "nuts" causes stalls... I thought if I worked in to my goals it would be great to add them to my diet but now I'm wondering is that what has me stalling for so long? Keep or trash them?
0
Replies
-
Some people say that nuts stall them. I find they do not affect me that way. You might also try soaking a serving of nuts 6-8 hours the night before you intent to eat them which is a beneficial practice.0
-
Keeping them within the macros works fine, for me, but are so easy to overeat! I don't keep them in the house since their "call" can be loud too!0
-
Nuts can stall me. I have had to drop them for a while and then slowly add them back in after things started moving again. But, it's different for everyone.0
-
-
ettaterrell wrote: »
I don't get this either.. I can't think of what is in nuts that would stall someone, unless nuts are pushing them over their recommended calories for weight loss.0 -
Christine_72 wrote: »ettaterrell wrote: »
I don't get this either.. I can't think of what is in nuts that would stall someone, unless nuts are pushing them over their recommended calories for weight loss.
When I was eating more nuts, I would rarely go over 20 grams of carbs or 2,000 calories for the day. I would usually only eat one or two ounces, not a bucket full. For some reason, nuts stall me sometimes. I haven't noticed it as much this time around, but a few attempts ago when I was eating very clean (90% just meat and LC Veggies) the nuts would throw things off and make me stall.0 -
FWIW I haven't noticed nuts stalling me.0
-
As much as I love eating them, roasted cashews are not my friend.0
-
I eat 1/4 to 1/2 cup of nuts a day most days & have lost 31 lbs since early October. No stall here.0
-
Also, one of my boys is allergic to all nuts except peanuts and almonds, so those are the only two I eat/keep in the house. Not sure what effect other nuts would have on me.0
-
Nuts have definitely stalled me even with portion control. The only ones I even attempt to graze sparingly is macadamia nuts. I'm not sure why though.0
-
Controlled nuts don't stall me. I have some on most days. It's the binge nut days that stall me. The days of a cup of macadamia nuts with coconut flakes, or 1.5+c of pistachios... It's not really a stall, just me eating too much.
It's funny how different foods affect everybody differently.0 -
There's also the possibility of mold toxins in nuts being the culprit If you consider Dave Asprey's research on the subject. In his book, he goes into great detail about how nuts are processed and which ones are most likely to have troubling amounts of mold toxins which would cause inflammation and hinder or hide weight loss. He basically says that if you aren't buying very fresh nuts which are kept refrigerated, then you should just assume there is mold present. Now, weather or not you are particularly sensitive to it is another story. But his basic method to determine this is by eating them and if it affects how you feel or affects health in any way, such as hindering weight loss, then you should stop eating them and see if things go back to normal.
So there's another idea to consider.0 -
I had never thought about it but I haven't eaten nuts since I started Woe until last week. It was just a can of mixed nuts great value brand, not refrigerated.. I have stopped eating them as of 3 days ago so we shall see. Let me say that I don't think they caused my stall I know that New Years did lol. But it normally takes me about a week to get back on track and this is taking a lot longer... Nuts being the only thing different in my diet. Thanks for everyone's input and trying to help me figure this out!0
-
I eat a serving every single day and have no problem at all. I did have a stall for a few weeks in December but perseverance seemed to do the trick for me. I really can't understand it being a factor either. I guess the only way to find out is to go some time without them. But in my case I'd rather eat my nuts and not see the scale move- eventually it does.0
-
I also eat a serving size every day (30 grams) of pecans. I buy them from costco and roast them in my oven with melted butter and salt. I also store them in the fridge to keep them fresh. I haven't noticed any issues with weight loss. One of my most favorite snacks is cottage cheese and pecans. So yummy!0
-
2/3rds of a cup to a full cup of dry roasted nuts daily and I haven't stalled as a result.0
-
Those that arnt stalling are the ones ur eating the already seasoned ones in a jar or can or is it a more fresh nut0
-
ettaterrell wrote: »Those that arnt stalling are the ones ur eating the already seasoned ones in a jar or can or is it a more fresh nut
0 -
ettaterrell wrote: »Those that arnt stalling are the ones ur eating the already seasoned ones in a jar or can or is it a more fresh nut
Planters right from the jar.0 -
Roasted, salted nuts pre packaged from the grocery store, 1 oz a day. No stall.0
-
I also eat a serving size every day (30 grams) of pecans. I buy them from costco and roast them in my oven with melted butter and salt. I also store them in the fridge to keep them fresh. I haven't noticed any issues with weight loss. One of my most favorite snacks is cottage cheese and pecans. So yummy!
Yay for costco pecans!! I love pecans, but they can be pricey. I love the bags from costco. I always have a couple bags in my freezer. Love your idea for roasting, stealing it!0 -
Macadamia nuts are the healthiest. Cashews are high in carbs, and many other nuts are high in Omega 6's which cause inflammation. If you CAN actually control the quantity, I suggest Macadamia nuts.0
-
Given a 2 week flat line after averaging 1-2lb loss a week for over 2 months, I will weigh in on the side of cashew nuts are an axis of evil. Too tasty. Even though they are in my calories and in my macros, since the mega pack of salted roasted goodness arrived in my house my weight has stalled. Could be irrelevant and i can't rhink of any justification but given little else changed in my diet my vote is yes nuts can cause a stall.0
-
4-16 January stall @56.6kg +0.1 to -0.5. Bit frustrated. Maybe this is just a recovery period rather than nuts. Since 16 Oct I have been eating to minimise sugar (no fruit, startches, grains, cereals) and lost 14 pounds.
I realise that in addition to nuts I have added more "healthy green leafy veg" but carbs still 40 to 70g (approx 15%) ; of which sugar 5 to 15g, fibre 20 to 30g. All still in macros, so soldiering on.
I am thinking of trying a fast day with a bulletproof coffee. Given I have not had coffee in those last 3 months that could be spectacular! Hyperactivity warning!! Sounds like it has helped some of you. Anyone have a fave recipe? Else I will just try the www.bulletproofexec.com website version. Thxs.0 -
I just make my normal strongman coffee with 1tbsb HWC and 1/2 Tbs coconut oil I have 2 to 3 a day.
Also I haven't had nuts all week and weight is starting to fall again, i am not saying the nuts caused by stall but I do think it did slow me down on the recovery. But I will try again later on to see if it effects me the same way just to be sure. (That's how I found out how sugar effected me was trial and error lol)0 -
It's great to be in a place nutritionally that you can test yourself with certain foods this way! I've been able to do this with many food items over the past several months too! My latest trial was some dark chocolate, and I learned that it's best not to keep it around! It called to me, just like regular chocolate! So I ate it all, and it's now gone! Won't be getting any more for a long time! Eye opening to see how easy it was to fall back into bingeing!0
-
Great to know! I will keep that out of the house lol0
-
Nuts definitely stall my weight loss. It's hard for me to have enough calories to spare in a day if I allow nuts to be part of my calorie allotment. I am not sure actually if I gain weight or stall weight loss because nuts, even lower carb nuts, contain more carbs than my body likes, or whether a higher calorie intake results from making nuts part of my my day. It is simply too easy to consume too many.
I noticed about 13 months ago, that all the so- called healthy paleo type baked goods, which were baked with an almond meal base, that I made for Christmas 2014, sugar free even, resulted in weight gain and a feeling of sluggishness. I determined that I needed to cut down on them and go even lower carb. I still make a few baked items with almond meal, but really restrict my intake.
It is also dangerous for me to even eat 1 oz of roasted salted nuts. They taste way too good. Which makes it easier to overindulge. I also don't feel good when eating too many nuts. My body doesn't like it. I am convinced that I will always need to restrict my intake of nuts, not only to lose weight or to maintain weight loss, but also to feel good. I feel sluggish and heavy after eating them, and my digestion slows and feels yucky.
So, I no longer make almond meal "bread-like" substitutes. I no longer coat chicken or fish in almond meal. I will not usually buy roasted, salted nuts. I do always have raw almonds, walnuts and even pecans and macadamia nuts in the fridge or freezer. I might cook with them, or eat a very few. Eating raw nuts makes it more possible to eat just a wee bit. Salted, roasted cashews are not a good idea for me to have around the house... Too tasty and dangerous! Too many carbs.
I did go through a phase where I would soak raw nuts in filtered water and sea salt, which makes them easier for me to digest. After soaking, I would dry them out at the lowest setting in my oven, then store them in the fridge. I was able to eat just a few of these, but no longer go through this ritual. It is easier to just stop trying to make nuts part of my regular routine.
I have found that snacks of meat or cheese work better for me, or better yet, avoid snacking and just eat a meal of meat, eggs, and maybe a bit of cheese or low GI vegetable. I have less digestive upset or feeling of sluggishness this way, and weight loss continues.
Come to think of it, I'd rather fast than eat nuts. It's just not worth it to me.0 -
It's great to be in a place nutritionally that you can test yourself with certain foods this way! I've been able to do this with many food items over the past several months too! My latest trial was some dark chocolate, and I learned that it's best not to keep it around! It called to me, just like regular chocolate! So I ate it all, and it's now gone! Won't be getting any more for a long time! Eye opening to see how easy it was to fall back into bingeing!
Yep! I've read on the boards a million times to swap to dark chocolate as you only need to eat 1-2 squares to feel satisfied.. Pffft whatever, it's not magic lol, it doesn't work for me, half a block is my minimum lol I no longer buy it either0
This discussion has been closed.