Amflautist's accountability thread
amflautist
Posts: 939 Member
I'm starting OMAD today. I really think it would make more sense for me to wait a while before starting this thread, but I decided to do it anyway because I need to be accountable to myself. Immediately! About 18 months ago, I had successfully completed a 60# weight loss here on mfp, and was starting to look good. Then disaster struck. I was dancing at my daughter's graduation. Dancing in shoes that weren't made for the purpose - and I twisted my knee. A couple of meniscus tears. I went to physical therapy, got a cortisone shot, and tried hard to wait it out and let my knee heal. No go. I found a great knee surgeon - he quoted 50% chance that arthroscopic surgery would make things better, 10% chance things would be worse. Had the surgery last July, and then faithfully did a heckofalot of physical therapy. Unfortunately, the knee keeps getting worse. I use hiking sticks a lot to assist my walking, and some days I pick up my crutches just to get around without pain. I have gained 20# since the knee injury. NOT GOOD!
I am finally motivated to get this extra weight off! My schedule doesn't allow me the luxury of a knee operation until late summer. I WILL get this extra 20# off by then. I will use this accountability thread to keep the progress moving.
I have no doubts about OMAD. That is going to be the easy part. The harder part will be figuring out what physical exercises I can do to strengthen my muscles and get in better shape prior to getting a NEW KNEE!
Height: 6'
Starting weight: 195.8
Goal before getting a new knee: 175
Eventual goal: 165
I am finally motivated to get this extra weight off! My schedule doesn't allow me the luxury of a knee operation until late summer. I WILL get this extra 20# off by then. I will use this accountability thread to keep the progress moving.
I have no doubts about OMAD. That is going to be the easy part. The harder part will be figuring out what physical exercises I can do to strengthen my muscles and get in better shape prior to getting a NEW KNEE!
Height: 6'
Starting weight: 195.8
Goal before getting a new knee: 175
Eventual goal: 165
0
Replies
-
Welcome back and I'm sorry to here about your knee injury
I started out at 194 and didn't start exercising (walking on the treadmill) until 6 months later and I lost 50 LBs so you can lose weight without exercising 
Good luck!!! 1 -
The kitchen is for weight loss, the gym is for fitness. I don't think exercise is necessary for success with OMAD, besides Brenda there are others who have had stunning success without exercise. Others swear by it.
What I think is most important is to stop stressing your body. Start OMAD, do what's right for your knee, and don't worry about the rest. Your major priority is to feel good, and that includes both weight loss AND a healthy knee. Getting the rest of your body in shape can wait until later. Until then, I would follow whatever your doctor is telling you.
Don't stress about getting in shape. Numero uno for you is to get that knee back, I would think. In the meantime, OMAD will help, as you already know.3 -
I agree with what @brendagaudette and @leeveejohn said! I have over 8 years in Personal Training and you do not need to workout to lose weight. Actually it can hinder your results by overstressing your system. Start with OMAD and progress from there!!2
-
Thank you everyone. I am feeling so lucky I found this group. 2
-
I concur with the above advice. I lost 90 pounds doing OMAD with zero exercise. Only recently have I added a bit of light exercise but while doing so I really focus on not stressing my body too much in the process.1
-
amflautist wrote: »Thank you everyone. I am feeling so lucky I found this group.
I'm with you! Lucky, lucky, lucky. What a great group.
0 -
One week. I thought it would be easy. Wasn't. Twice I ate again in the evening. I need to figure out a new pattern for my evenings so that I'm not doing this, because I'm not hungry at that time. Good news is that I lost 2# anyway. Lucky me, eh? I want to quit this cheating, because I can't count on luck every time.
26 Mar 2017: 195.8
2 April 2017: 193.8
0 -
I found this TEDx talk on fasting. "Why Fasting Bolsters Brain Power"
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=4UkZAwKoCP8
I'm going to put it on my desktop and watch it every time I think about eating when I shouldn't.
1 -
2 pounds is a good start. I watched that Tedx talk one day when I was browsing for info on fasting. Interesting.0
-
I'm more hungry at night time too and this is why my eating window is anytime between 4 and 6, I can handle not eating all day knowing I'm going to be able to eat later...Oh and thats a good loss for the week while snacking 0
-
Nighttime is hard because I'm out of willpower by then. Still, I'm going to keep my OMAD earlier, because my body doesn't reduce the inflammation of my knee at night unless I stop eating at 3.0
-
amflautist wrote: »One week. I thought it would be easy. Wasn't. Twice I ate again in the evening. I need to figure out a new pattern for my evenings so that I'm not doing this, because I'm not hungry at that time. Good news is that I lost 2# anyway. Lucky me, eh? I want to quit this cheating, because I can't count on luck every time.
26 Mar 2017: 195.8
2 April 2017: 193.8
No luck involved. That might work for you but it would be easy for it to get out of control so understand your concern.0 -
I used Excel to make a chart of most of my weight data, starting 7/28/2011, which is the day I started with mfp.
Sobering. I thought I was maintaining my weight in the 170s. Nope! Most of the time in the past 5 years I have been in the 180s. Lately in the 190s, and even over 200 (data not yet entered). I SO happy I found this group! My knee is going to be happy too!
2 -
Nice chart! It's amazing the lessons to be learned from a simple run chart0
-
I love a good chart, even when it's brutally honest
being aware of what is happening is a great start to doing something about it:) 0 -
Yes, brutally honest. My picture is brutally honest also. Taken March 2012 when I was at the same weight I am now.0
-
Yes your knee is going to love you 0
-
Your 'brutally honest' pic is pretty nice!0
-
OMAD
1st Goal = 172 (weight when I wrecked my knee)
Wk .. Weight ... Chg ... Total
0 .... 195.8
1 .... 193.8 ..... -2.0 ..... -2.0
2 .... 191.4 ..... -2.4 ..... -4.4
Luck is with me again! Lost 2.4 pounds. It's what I gained that I really appreciate however.
I am sleeping a LOT better. I always knew that if I ate dinner late, or drank wine, I didn't sleep well. So I would try to have dinner 5-6PM. Now I know that it's even better to have dinner 12-1PM. I'm sleeping like a baby now.
Even better, the swelling in my knee is way down. Yesterday I went to the library, and walked around the supermarket - with no pain!
Today I'm going to try a little walk up the road ... We'll see what the knee can do now.
2 -
Wonderful results!!! Be kind to your knees, one of mine keeps nagging me about whatever it is I happen to be doing.0
-
That's one thing i noticed right away was the sleep, i hadn't noticed before how often i woke up throughout the night.
Knee pain sucks, 2 years ago I fell while attempting to swing on a root lol and ever since then, my one knee always wants to bow out.
Good luck with your walk 0 -
OMAD
1st Goal = 172 (weight when I wrecked my knee)
Wk .. Weight ... Chg ... Total
0 .... 195.8
1 .... 193.8 ..... -2.0 ..... -2.0
2 .... 191.4 ..... -2.4 ..... -4.4
3 .... 190.0 ..... -1.4 ..... -5.8
Too many evenings of broken promises to myself. Not just eating, but eating things I don't want to have in my life anymore. The only successful evenings were the ones when I left the living room (where husband was eating his dinner and watching TV), avoided the kitchen (where the counters were covered with food), and went into my bedroom to read a book. I am not yet strong. But I WILL BE!!2 -
You are losing and that's great, hang in there you can do this!!! Happy Easter 0
-
I know how you feel, kinda. Dislocated my knee when I already weighed 324lbs, then ballooned to 363 in the year it took for my knee to recuperate. I was always big, but usually closer to 260 then that. I was ashamed and used everything as an excuse. I just gave up. Going OMAD was the best thing I did. It jump started my weight loss. I lost 64 lbs just being OMAD with no exercise. I'm now starting to implement exercise.0
-
Thank you. Your story encourages me. Sometimes I feel that old ladies aren't expected to do these things, and so we give up. I don't want to give up.1
-
Woohoo! In the 180's this morning. Now just have to hold that until official weigh in tomorrow.3
-
amflautist wrote: »Woohoo! In the 180's this morning. Now just have to hold that until official weigh in tomorrow.
Great job!0 -
Nice, Amflautist! You've got this!!0
-
Awesome
0 -
Stay strong! You're doing great0
This discussion has been closed.