Skip to content
  • Register
    • We are pleased to announce that as of March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor has been introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

    Questions - Heart rate monitors

    Posts: 66 Member
    edited December 2024 in Fitness and Exercise
    Ok MFP friends, I'm really in need of some advice :) I'm currently using a New Balance heart rate monitor with a chest strap. But I'm becoming more and more frustrated with it. I'm pretty sure its picking up other heart rate signals when I'm at the gym because my heart rate will go from 105 to 165 within seconds and sometimes goes back and forth. I'm thinking about getting a new one, but have no clue where to start. I need one that will work indoors, not requiring a GPS signal. I prefer the chest strap for continuous heart rate versus having to touch the wrist watch to get the heart rate.

    So the question, those who are using a heart rate monitor, which one? How do you like it? Does it have a chest strap? Would you recommend it? Can you use it indoors or does it require a GPS signal?

    Any advice or recommendation greatly appreciated! Thanks everyone :)

    Welcome!

    It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.
    Sign In
    Register

    Replies

    • Posts: 9,487 Member
      I have the Polar FT4 - love it. Has a chest strap. I frequently use it indoors. Doesn't require GPS signal.
    • Posts: 178 Member
      Polar FT4. Love It. Yes it has a chest strap (barely even notice it's there). Would definitely recommend it. I use it indoors all the time, and outdoors. No GPS Signal required.

      Basically it's a good basic HRM to start with. IF you love it and decide you want more after some time, then do so but why pay more for all the bells and whistles if you don't even know if you'll use them.
    • Posts: 2,631 Member
      yup, polar. the watch is not comfortable tho. (for me anyway) i put it on my bra strap.
    • Posts: 200 Member
      I got a cheap one from lidl. It has a chest strap and ive used it indoors and out. I really like it but haven't had one before so cant compare. Does what i want.
    • Posts: 89 Member
      Polar F4. I got mine at ****'s Sporting Goods. It's so much cheaper at Amazon.
    • Posts: 337
      Polar, they are not suppose to mix signals with other heart rate monitors.
    • Posts: 8,754 Member
      I have experienced my heart rate going crazy also. It does this on my spinning bike. But, I don't pay it much attention. I just use my HRM. I have an old one...Polar F6.
    • Posts: 3 Member
      Hi
      If you are going for a Polar make then make sure it has the feature "Own Code" on it so that it does not pick up the HR signal from another user. i use the FT7 and find it brilliant :happy:
    • Posts: 221 Member
      Some heart rate monitors are also GPS receivers but GPS is nothing to do with the HR part of it.

      Could be your battery is low - solution - change the battery

      could be you are not wearing strap correctly - solution - check your handbook ensure it is properly placed and contacts are in contact!

      could be your heart rate is in fact spiking - solution - try another HR monitor and see if you get same results

      Could be your HRM is malfunctioning - solution - check your warranty

      You maybe wanna do all the above before getting something else.
    • Posts: 66 Member
      Thank you everyone for the feedback! I'm definitely going to check out the Polar HRM's and see if I can find one thats best for me!
    • Posts: 10 Member
      I have heard that with the Polar HRM if the battery dies you have to send it back to the company. Has anyone been faced with that problem?
    • Posts: 15
      My Polar FT 7 has user changeable batteries for the watch and the chest strap. This was definately a feature I wanted when I was researching HRM's. Some Polar models do not have this feature. Good luck... :)
    • Posts: 66 Member
      How about those using the FT4, are you able to change the batteries yourself? Thanks!
    • Posts: 3,624 Member
      Polar F4. I got mine at ****'s Sporting Goods. It's so much cheaper at Amazon.

      LOL at the censorship
    • Posts: 1 Member
      I knew. LOL. :laugh: It won't let me type at all.
    • Posts: 576 Member
      How about those using the FT4, are you able to change the batteries yourself? Thanks!

      Yes, I just had to change the battery in my Polar FT4 last month. It was a bit of a challenge to get the back off but once I did, it was easy to change the battery.
    • Posts: 38
      I have a polar ft40 I just got a week or so ago the instructions show how to change the batteries and I LOVE IT!!! :smile:
    • Posts: 268 Member
      Just got a Polar FT4 a week ago, and won't ever try another brand--I totally love it!!
    • Posts: 1,820 Member
      I have a Polar that I use with my Android phone and Noom. It works on the Precor stuff at the gym too.
    • Posts: 175 Member
      I did a lot of research and settled on the Polar FT2 - its one up from the most basic but it has all I need. It has a chest strap (very comfy) with a coded transmitter which should cut interference out. I'm in the process of joining a gym so have not really used it yet but I am looking forward it it!!
    • Posts: 320 Member
      Polar FT7! rocks my world and it doesnt pick up a signal from any other HRM monitors. A great buy on Amazon. I paid about $81 for mine through HRM USA, one of amazon's affiliates.
    • Posts: 19,251 Member
      I have heard that with the Polar HRM if the battery dies you have to send it back to the company. Has anyone been faced with that problem?
      The polar website *suggests* you send it back.
      I have the F7 and have changed the battery myself. Got the replacement battery at Radio Shack (or whatever it's called now).
    • Posts: 55
      Yep...Polar FT4 - chest strap, no GPS & I use at gym...not to mention it's pink & cute!:wink: LOVE IT!
    • Posts: 221 Member
      Polar Ft60 hrm. Love it! My boyfriend wears his too and they don't get our rates mixed.
    • Posts: 24
      I have a Polar FT7 which I purchased from Amazon for $76.00. I exercise with someone using a Polar FT7 with no problem.
    • Posts: 532 Member
      Yes the Polar FT4 you can change the batteries on yourself. I also just purchased this, actually the FT40 (but that just gives online help or something, training planner) but it basically the FT4... so far so good, happy with it and can use in gym with no interference.
    • Posts: 36 Member
      Personally I use the Polar FT4, I love it! had another one before and it was a pain to use. Polars are very user friendly.
    • Posts: 89 Member
      .
    This discussion has been closed.

    Welcome!

    It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.
    Sign In
    Register

    Quick Links

    Categories