We are pleased to announce that on March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor will be introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the upcoming changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!
Protien Shakes??
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/691c4/691c4ca3a79408f53c8cee5f6e2a5a02f12dd3b3" alt="MellyMelx23o"
MellyMelx23o
Posts: 80
I've heard protien shakes help after working out to heal the muscles. I dont know how I feel about drinking them. I also heard they could be a bit pricey.... Any helpful info? Do you drink them? Only after a workout, or throughout the day??
0
Replies
-
i just get the body fortress from walmart - it's about 15.00 - i do one drink after my afternoon lifting (the drink is 3 scoops + water).
i am sure there are better ones out there & more costly ones, but this one works for me & fits into my daily diet & ratios (try for 25/25/50). on the weekends, my rest days, i usually take a 2 scoop shake mixed with some oatmeal for bfast. - i take it on the wkends b/c the muscles need them for recovery in general so i've always kept up my protien during the wkends - after workout is just the BEST time your body obsorbs the protien.
i will be adding a pre-workout protien once i get out of my cutting phase, but i still have almost 4wks until then.0 -
i just get the body fortress from walmart - it's about 15.00 - i do one drink after my afternoon lifting (the drink is 3 scoops + water).
i am sure there are better ones out there & more costly ones, but this one works for me & fits into my daily diet & ratios (try for 25/25/50). on the weekends, my rest days, i usually take a 2 scoop shake mixed with some oatmeal for bfast. - i take it on the wkends b/c the muscles need them for recovery in general so i've always kept up my protien during the wkends - after workout is just the BEST time your body obsorbs the protien.
i will be adding a pre-workout protien once i get out of my cutting phase, but i still have almost 4wks until then.
Thanks! :flowerforyou:0 -
I don't drink shakes on a daily basis, but I will have a post workout protein drink on heavier lifting days. I tend to just mix up a scoop of 100% vanilla whey protein isolate with some water.
On days when I have a more carb-heavy lunch of dinner, I'll drink a protein shake in the morning. water + ice + 1 scoop whey protein + probiotic yogurt + banana + frozen berries. Usually a protein shake will keep me feeling fuller and more satisfied than cereal or anything else.
Other good things to add -a bit of milled flax seed to up the fiber content.0 -
You can take anytime - AM, after a workout. Good places to get protein would include Wal-Mart, amazon.com, vitamin shoppe is also excellent. Can get premade shakes which are pretty spending but convenient. Costco sales premade muscle milk at bulk.
If you are able to go home - use protein powder, skim/soy/almond milk and ice. Blend together and it tastes pretty dang good - like a chocolate shake. I prefer the taste of this over the premade plus less preservatives and things like that.
You can mix with a lot of things like chocolate with Peanut butter, frozen fruit with vanilla. For my AM breakfast - I put a 3/4/ cup of frozen berries (blue,black & rasberry) in my blender, scoop of vanilla whey and almond milk and a little bit of water. Tastes like a berry shake - very good and filling. I do have a high powered blender(vitamix) that pulverizes the seeds so that might make a difference.
As far as taking protein shake - it's an easy way to get the protein to you system. (instead of eating a chicken breast) and low calorie. It's definitely not a man/body builder/testosterone thing. It's definitely a staple of my diet and great in a pinch. The biggest loser doctor, Dr.Huizenga, wrote a book and recommends natural protien shakes for after workout. Excellent book btw - linked below.
http://www.amazon.com/Where-Did-All-Fat-Prescription/dp/19312905710 -
I drink at least 1 protein shake a day. I always have a shake for breakfast. If I put in a hard workout, I will drink another one after or eat some other form of lean protein. I drink the MRM brand in vanilla. I buy it on Amazon for $22 (Approx 32 servings. 87 calories per serving). Protein (in any lean form) is great for feeding your muscles. I blend mine with coconut milk and baking cocoa (the chocolate MRM protein is more expensive, so I make mine chocolate with baking cocoa - 15 calories per tsp). I find the blog www.heandsheeatclean.com very helpful! Good luck!0
-
I have a protein shake almost every day.
I use the NNW brand from HyVee. I think it's like 19 dollars for 2 lbs of it. So far that's the cheapest I found and it's definitely worth it.
I drink it after every workout and also as snacks when I crave something sweet. I get the strawberry or chocolate milk flavors and make it with unsweetened almond milk, 1/2 c. oats, and fruit. (bananas, pineapples, strawberries, raspberries). Just depends on what I have.
This way it turns into a yummy iced protein smoothie!
It helps me not feel sick after working out and I just feel a lot better.0 -
You can have them after a workout, but a hand full of natural almonds could probably do the same for you and they are not man made if that is what you are concerned about. Don't get me wrong, I drink them, usually when I am running late and can't make breakfast or just substitute it for that meal entirely. I usually drink EAS Advantage, but you can buy shakes in powder form and get more bang for your buck that way0
-
I don't drink them, I figure I'm eating plenty of meat all the time I dont need to supplement protein too. Of course protein is found in a lot of other foods too, but that's where I get most of it personally.0
-
I drink them as my diet per my doctor. I drink one in the morning, one at lunch. I get two cups of silk almond (yummy) plus I can't tolorate milk... and I use muscletech (sams $18 for 5#) and with 2 scoops is 42 g of protein. I have to have 120 grams of protein per day because I am insulin resistent. so not really pricey. My bag of powder has lasted me months. Now the silk is pricer than a gallon of milk but that's my preference. I drink two shakes per day0
-
I use the Body by Vi (Visalus) protein shakes at least once a day. It's a great source of protein without the icky chalk-like taste. 90 calories for 2 scoops; 12g of protein. I know a few people who take two shakes a day to increase their weight loss, and a couple have even gotten off their diabetes meds using this. You can find it on Amazon, ebay, or by going to: http://visalus.com/body-by-vi/90-day-challenge.
It's a little pricey, imo, but I've seen a few people able to get it at lower prices or free by getting a prescription for it from their doctor and submitting it thru their insurance.0 -
I've heard protien shakes help after working out to heal the muscles. I dont know how I feel about drinking them. I also heard they could be a bit pricey.... Any helpful info? Do you drink them? Only after a workout, or throughout the day??
Protein period helps you period. Most minimal recommendations for someone who is not exercising is .8g of protein/your weight in kg . I didn't know about them either but since I've been trying to keep my protein about 100g a day and I spend a lot of time in a university, I figured a shake would be beneficial. I drink them whenever I need protein.
There's different kinds of protein as well. I'd recommend one with a full amino acid profile like whey powder. If you're lactose intolerant get the isolate. Isolates absorb quicker while concentrates are slower. Some people mix these 2 up depending on what they're doing.0 -
I've heard protien shakes help after working out to heal the muscles. I dont know how I feel about drinking them. I also heard they could be a bit pricey.... Any helpful info? Do you drink them? Only after a workout, or throughout the day??
Protein period helps you period. Most minimal recommendations for someone who is not exercising is .8g of protein/your weight in kg . I didn't know about them either but since I've been trying to keep my protein about 100g a day and I spend a lot of time in a university, I figured a shake would be beneficial. I drink them whenever I need protein.
There's different kinds of protein as well. I'd recommend one with a full amino acid profile like whey powder. If you're lactose intolerant get the isolate. Isolates absorb quicker while concentrates are slower. Some people mix these 2 up depending on what they're doing.
This! Also, they are not relly that expensive depending on what brand you buy and how much you take. I use Gaspari Myofusion, I buy the 10 lb bag on the internet for about $72 and I get about 140 servings at 1 scoop. So that's a little over .50 per serving. I do 1 or 2 shakes per day of 2 scoops depending on how much protien I got from food that day. That makes it about $1 per shake. Pretty low cost if you ask me!0 -
I eat protein bars. I might get into shakes, but bars have kept me full for a while and taste delicious. Plus they come with other things I need like fiber and vitamins.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 394.3K Introduce Yourself
- 44K Getting Started
- 259.7K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.6K Food and Nutrition
- 47.3K Recipes
- 232.3K Fitness and Exercise
- 388 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.4K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153.1K Motivation and Support
- 8.1K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.2K MyFitnessPal Information
- 22 News and Announcements
- 916 Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.3K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions