I've come to the conclusion...

...that I went about this weight loss thing ALL WRONG. The majority of my weight loss was done without exercise. I am now "skinny fat". It feels hopeless and I feel that I'm obsessing. I like the number on the scale and want to stay there. However, I really need to tone up. What to do, what to do?

Replies

  • ninerbuff
    ninerbuff Posts: 49,029 Member
    Resistance training. Do understand that when you undertake this, there will be some weight gain because of fluid and glycogen retention.

    A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
    IDEA Fitness member
    Kickboxing Certified Instructor
    Been in fitness for 28+ years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition
  • YoungDoc2B
    YoungDoc2B Posts: 1,593 Member
    "Lift Heavy".
  • Yanicka1
    Yanicka1 Posts: 4,564 Member
    Resistance training. Do understand that when you undertake this, there will be some weight gain because of fluid and glycogen retention.

    A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
    IDEA Fitness member
    Kickboxing Certified Instructor
    Been in fitness for 28+ years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition

    This. There is no other way but exercise. The good news is that since you are new to exercise you should have muscle gain really easily. I recommend reading the book " the new rules of lifting for women" even if you do not do the workouts, the information are invaluable.

    Good luck
  • thin4life67
    thin4life67 Posts: 51 Member
    I just joined a small gym at work last week. I played around with a few machines last week including chest press, leg press and leg extenstion. I'm unsure of the weight settings though. I don't want to set the weight too high, but I don't want to waste my time either. Unfortunately they don't offer personal training...which is clearly what I need.
  • BerryH
    BerryH Posts: 4,698 Member
    Find exercise you enjoy, that fits with your lifestyle and you can keep up on a regular basis. It doesn't have to be the same thing week after week, enjoy trying new things and testing your body in different ways.

    If you're fairly inactive currently, start with walking - a fast walk quick enough to keep you slightly out of breath is fabulous exercise. You may want to gradually take it up to running through using a programme such as Couch To 5K (C25K) - I can send you links and beginner's running tips if you want.

    Mix up cardio with resistance training, or combine both with circuit-style classes or DVDs. Feel too hot to work out in summer? Get in the pool and swim. Don't fancy going out in the rain? Pop in a workout DVD.

    You've had lots of advice on resistance training. Though lifting heavy gives excellent results, as a beginner you will get outstanding results introducing any resistance training at the level that suits you. You can start with resistance bands or a pair of dumbbells. Google body-weight workouts - there are loads of moves you can do for free with zero equipment!

    Keep your eye out for second-hand exercise DVDs and equipment - keeping fit needn't cost much.
  • LorinaLynn
    LorinaLynn Posts: 13,247 Member
    Find what challenges you. "Heavy" depends on your abilities.

    I generally do three sets of 8 when lifting. If you're not struggling by the final lifts, it's too light.

    Don't be afraid of the number on the scale. http://www.myfitnesspal.com/blog/LorinaLynn/view/one-year-of-strength-training-367482
  • Have you ever tried cycling ? I started about a month and a half ago and WOW what a difference I see in my muscle tone in the lower half... and it's really fun too !! Find a friend and head out .... makes me feel like a kid again :tongue:
  • BerryH
    BerryH Posts: 4,698 Member
    I just joined a small gym at work last week. I played around with a few machines last week including chest press, leg press and leg extenstion. I'm unsure of the weight settings though. I don't want to set the weight too high, but I don't want to waste my time either. Unfortunately they don't offer personal training...which is clearly what I need.
    All gyms should offer you a basic programme as part of your membership showing you how to get the most out of the equipment and not injure yourself. Don't be afraid to take weight up as heavy as you can - a good rule of thumb is you should feel you can't do more than eight reps at the weight you set and aim for three sets.

    A word of caution - in the long run you'll be a lot better off using free weights - dumbbells, barbells, kettlebells etc. - rather than machines as you're using your muscles naturally and not isolating one at a time.
  • MessyLittlePanda
    MessyLittlePanda Posts: 213 Member
    If you are going to strength/resistance train, then try measuring yourself and tracking your body fat % rather than going just by the scale number.

    I had a point in my life where I did get very fit, I was doing kickboxing 3 times a week which involved strength training, circuits etc and mountain biking, I was a small UK size 10 (US size 6) but I weighed almost 11 stone. The doctor told me I was overweight, I thought that was pretty funny at the time!

    I wouldn't necessarily recommend going that crazy on your exercise and muscle building, but if you do start doing it, your body composition will change, and you have to find new ways of measuring your progress.
  • tennisbabe94
    tennisbabe94 Posts: 444 Member
    Hit those weights girl!
  • neverstray
    neverstray Posts: 3,845 Member
    I just joined a small gym at work last week. I played around with a few machines last week including chest press, leg press and leg extenstion. I'm unsure of the weight settings though. I don't want to set the weight too high, but I don't want to waste my time either. Unfortunately they don't offer personal training...which is clearly what I need.

    So, if you were to drive from New York to California, would you just get in the car and drive some random direction hoping to get there?

    Stop. Go read up, or consult with someone and figure out what to do, exactly. Find a plan you can live with and use it. Flying blind is not better than doing nothing.

    There are lots of books on the topic, lots of stuff on the web. The New Rules for Women seems to be pretty popular.
  • iRebel
    iRebel Posts: 378 Member
    ...that I went about this weight loss thing ALL WRONG. The majority of my weight loss was done without exercise. I am now "skinny fat". It feels hopeless and I feel that I'm obsessing. I like the number on the scale and want to stay there. However, I really need to tone up. What to do, what to do?

    Let me stress that IT IS NOT HOPELESS!!!! :happy: You have done at least 85% of the work by just losing the weight! If you want to build muscle, and firm up- I highly recommend Jillian Michael's 30 day shred followed by her Ripped in 30
  • Lift heavy and lift often, as long as your calories are at maintenance and not going over you will not get big and bulky, you need a surplus to gain weight and size. Try metabolic resistance training too, I use it with my clients, hope this helps!

    Jesse Short
    ISSA Certified Personal Trainer
  • thin4life67
    thin4life67 Posts: 51 Member
    Thanks everyone!! I have been walking for exercise for over a year now. I walk anywhere between 3-4 miles per day and a pace of 3.5 - 4.2. I plan on asking for "schooling" at the gym tomorrow.
  • They use to say, when lifting weights. If you can't lift it 8 times it's too heavy. If you can lift it more than 12 times it's too light. I think the most important thing to do is to stay active.
  • thin4life67
    thin4life67 Posts: 51 Member
    ...that I went about this weight loss thing ALL WRONG. The majority of my weight loss was done without exercise. I am now "skinny fat". It feels hopeless and I feel that I'm obsessing. I like the number on the scale and want to stay there. However, I really need to tone up. What to do, what to do?

    Let me stress that IT IS NOT HOPELESS!!!! :happy: You have done at least 85% of the work by just losing the weight! If you want to build muscle, and firm up- I highly recommend Jillian Michael's 30 day shred followed by her Ripped in 30


    I tried the 30 day shred but found it was too hard on my knees. It was recommended by my PT that I stop. I have given thought to doing it again but leaving out the jumping jacks. Jump rope and squats didn't seem to bother my knees.
  • thin4life67
    thin4life67 Posts: 51 Member
    They use to say, when lifting weights. If you can't lift it 8 times it's too heavy. If you can lift it more than 12 times it's too light. I think the most important thing to do is to stay active.

    Good to know...I will remember that!
  • neverstray
    neverstray Posts: 3,845 Member
    They use to say, when lifting weights. If you can't lift it 8 times it's too heavy. If you can lift it more than 12 times it's too light. I think the most important thing to do is to stay active.

    Good to know...I will remember that!

    Yeah, not so much. That's probably old school. 12 to 15 reps is good. You can shoot for less. I shoot for 10 reps. If I hit 11, I up the weight a notch. But, if you want to hit 15, that's fine.
  • thin4life67
    thin4life67 Posts: 51 Member
    I just joined a small gym at work last week. I played around with a few machines last week including chest press, leg press and leg extenstion. I'm unsure of the weight settings though. I don't want to set the weight too high, but I don't want to waste my time either. Unfortunately they don't offer personal training...which is clearly what I need.

    So, if you were to drive from New York to California, would you just get in the car and drive some random direction hoping to get there?

    Stop. Go read up, or consult with someone and figure out what to do, exactly. Find a plan you can live with and use it. Flying blind is not better than doing nothing.

    There are lots of books on the topic, lots of stuff on the web. The New Rules for Women seems to be pretty popular.

    Well I would have a general direction in mind...as I do with this. I'm one that needs alot of hand holding...LOL
  • wlkumpf
    wlkumpf Posts: 241 Member
    Do they have zumba or yoga there? I have been doing turbokick and zumba, aquazumba and p90x to tone and lose. I love the organized classes :) Training for a uphill 5k too! I would say just find something you enjoy doing and stick with it, just get moving however you can. Yesterday I took my kids and went hiking even.
    Take your measurements so you can see a different goal than the scale too. Remember, to be healthy and have a long term affect you do not want to lose your water weight, you want to lose your fat. As you define your muscles they will gain weight and you can still lose some fat to gain definition of those muscles. So, still keep calorie count going :) But you may want to up it a little, not even up for your workout calories, maybe add a protein shake after a workout.
  • katiejarr
    katiejarr Posts: 251 Member
    Have you tried Yoga? Im 51 and Ive been doing yoga for over a year now and I love it. Its a great work out for the body and mind...I have developed muscles in my arms and in my legs! It is a hard work out but its wonderful for muscle tone. I also highly recommend free weights, not the machines, use the computer and Google examples of using free weights and print it and bring it to the gym to guide you your first few times...and see if your town offers Yoga classes, you will love it!
  • DakotaKeogh
    DakotaKeogh Posts: 693 Member
    Lots of good advice posted already. You're in a tricky place. You want to keep the pounds where they are. But you want to tone up. What you need to do is shift your focus from what you weigh to what your percent of body fat is. As you exercise and tone up you'll be in a trade off between fat lost and muscle gained. I'd strongly recommend getting measured in an immersion tank, which is the most accurate method. Or you can just get a scale that measures it. Pick a body fat % goal with advice from a trainer or your doctor. Forget the pounds for now. When you reach the body fat goal, and if you think you look right, then you can look at the pounds. That's what you should weigh.

    Good luck! :smile:
  • ldrosophila
    ldrosophila Posts: 7,512 Member
    First congratulations on reaching your goal!! You should be so proud! Second time to start the next stage in your fitness getting that body toned and sleek! Congratulations if any one can do it you can. You've already accomplished something that many others fail at.
  • HappilyLifts
    HappilyLifts Posts: 429 Member
    I have done things the other way around. I am building muscle and looking better, but haven't really lost any weight because I put more effort into the gym than my eating habits. See pics below, evidence of what strength training can do I think.
    progress.jpg

    Changes in my body shape were achieved by a small amount of HIIT training and body weight or dumbbell exercises over a period of 6 months (just this year, I rarely exercised before, and when I did, it was for about one month prior to having to wear a bikini!), 3-5 days a week, for up to 45 minutes a session.

    With regard to knowing how much to lift, my trainer advises 3 sets of 12 reps. The first set should be managable, the second set should be a little harder, and by rep 8 of the third set I am struggling to keep good form. By the time I can accomplish all of that third set it is time to move on (usually about every 6 weeks).
    When I started out I was using 2 and 3kg dumbbells for tricep and bicep work and 40on the leg press machine. I also do alot of bodyweight exercises like planks, squats and lunges.

    One other thing, I have learnt to largely ignore the scales and use a tape measure to guage progress....my tummy has shrunk from 111cm to 97cm since February when I started doing more strength than cardio yet I have only lost 5-7 pounds in this time. That's my two pennies worth.

    You've done brilliantly with your loss. Go you, you'll soon be where you want to be! :smile:

    Sorry, no idea to make all three pics visible but you can right click and select View Image to see all three.
  • iRebel
    iRebel Posts: 378 Member
    ...that I went about this weight loss thing ALL WRONG. The majority of my weight loss was done without exercise. I am now "skinny fat". It feels hopeless and I feel that I'm obsessing. I like the number on the scale and want to stay there. However, I really need to tone up. What to do, what to do?

    Let me stress that IT IS NOT HOPELESS!!!! :happy: You have done at least 85% of the work by just losing the weight! If you want to build muscle, and firm up- I highly recommend Jillian Michael's 30 day shred followed by her Ripped in 30


    I tried the 30 day shred but found it was too hard on my knees. It was recommended by my PT that I stop. I have given thought to doing it again but leaving out the jumping jacks. Jump rope and squats didn't seem to bother my knees.
    yeah, I only use it for the weight lifting and abs part, sometimes. get your cardio however you want, but remember: muscle comes from lifting.