Eating to you blood type!
pixelsurgeon88
Posts: 39 Member
Hi
Is anyone following a diet plan that goes with their blood type? if so has it worked for weightless?
Allie xo
Is anyone following a diet plan that goes with their blood type? if so has it worked for weightless?
Allie xo
0
Replies
-
I just started it. My friend has been following it for about 6 months and lost almost 50lbs.
I am not a big fan of fad diets but I read it over and its all healthy food and their is no talk about keeping my calories dangerously low. So, I figured I'd try it.0 -
I've never heard of this...what's it about?0
-
I want to hear about this, too. Sounds like it's probably a sham, though.0
-
I've got red blood, so I eat food.0
-
it makes sense for me (i eat low carb anyway). but i'm sure it doesn't make sense for everyone.0
-
I've got red blood, so I eat food.
^^^This^^^0 -
I've got red blood, so I eat food.0
-
I suspect this has already been debunked...
...but if it hasn't , I'm almost certain it will be.
Any of the three diets, if at a calorie deficit, will result in weight loss. There is no magic here...(unless you're a wizard, and then I guess different rules apply).0 -
Eating to your blood type.... so if I have O Neg... does that mean, I eat nothing?0
-
Eating to your blood type.... so if I have O Neg... does that mean, I eat nothing?
Created by MyFitnessPal.com - Nutrition Facts For Foods0 -
Eating to your blood type.... so if I have O Neg... does that mean, I eat nothing?
I'm an O neg too...apparently we are Aliens or something0 -
Oh, so far I love this blood type diet. It's like reading your daily horoscope. May or may not apply to anyone.0
-
No offense to anyone here who might believe in this nonsense, but... it's ironic I stumbled across this thread, because we were just discussing the dumbest fad diets we've heard of at the nurses' station today while charting, and the blood type diet was brought up.
The nurse said she had an obese patient who dropped 25 lbs from it and swore by it. Of course it works. No matter what your blood type is, exercise is encouraged. And you're restricting certain types of food. So if you're restricting grains (like in a low carb diet), of course you're going to lose weight. You're eating less period. Even if you're eating more of a certain other types, you're completely cutting out others. Enjoy that ham, cheese, and mayo without a slice of bread to put it on. Chances are, you're going to skip it altogether. The principle behind this fad diet is stupidly easy to see through.
That being said, if you're into fad diets, go for it. Nothing wrong with just about anything that limits calorie intake. That IS the principle behind losing weight, after all. Just make sure you're getting the minimum of everything required to keep you healthy!
If you're cutting calories, everything else is just an easy way to trick yourself into doing so.
(But good to mention that if you're not exercising and cutting total calories, you're not going to lose weight, no matter which fad diet principle you live by )
Edit: Also, you O- people aren't even in the smallest blood type groups, so hush up. lol.0 -
Edit: Also, you O- people aren't even in the smallest blood type groups, so hush up. lol.
Never said I was in the smallest blood group... :P lol0 -
I'm O positive and positively love my nom noms, so there.0
-
http://www.kimberlysnyder.net/blog/2012/06/19/busting-the-blood-type-diet/One of the claims in the blood type diet is that Type O is the very first blood type that existed, present among early hunters. Microbiological research, on the other hand, suggests that the original blood type was A. Since the blood type diet begins with such a flawed premise, it is not surprising that its hypotheses and recommendations are flawed, as well.
The blood type diet is about as scientific as palm reading or astrology.0 -
A family member lost a lot of weight doing this, but I'm pretty sure it had more to do with the fact that brownies, cookies, cheesecakes and candy bars were on the nono list than anything else.0
-
It is pseudoscience which isn't backed by research but it seems that if you follow it, you will end up restricting calories and thus should lose weight.0
-
Ok seriously though what is it all about. I am curious to see what they say not because I want to try it. I would say maybe it helps boost certain nutrients some people lack except I've never heard that say A pos people need more iron or whatever.0
-
I'm AB ---- All Bacon!!!0
-
It is pseudoscience which isn't backed by research but it seems that if you follow it, you will end up restricting calories and thus should lose weight.
So what I said verbatim...0 -
I've never fad dieted, but will try this for my blood type, mostly because I AM cutting calories back and exercising daily, and don't see much change, so I am willing to see if tweaking my diet towards my blood type will help.
Different body types, ethnicities, ages, genders, etc, process food and gain or lose fat differently - that's undeniable. If I cut out some foods, add in other foods, using my Blood Type as my guide, AND I start to lose weight, that will be scientific evidence enough for me!0 -
PS: Ann Louise Gittleman wrote a book about it - pretty easy read:
"Your Body Knows Best"
http://www.amazon.com/Your-Body-Knows-Louise-Gittleman/dp/06718759140 -
It is pseudoscience which isn't backed by research but it seems that if you follow it, you will end up restricting calories and thus should lose weight.
So what I said verbatim...
Who is Verbatim?
Also, we're not the rarest blood type, but we are the best. Not the best to be, just the best because we're heroes.0 -
Hi. I read 'Eat Right for Your Blood Type' some years ago. As someone else mentioned here, Type O are said to be the first 'official' humans - hunter-gatherers, and Type A came out of the farming communities that came later, who lived in settled groups and grew loads of crops. Type O are supposed to be more naturally carnivore and Type A more naturally vegetarian. I'm type A. I've never really followed the book as I already eat a lot of vegetarian food by choice - but I suppose it would work in that all the diets suggested for each blood type is probably 100 times better than the average Westerner's diet.
The book does give a lot of really interesting info on the kinds of diseases different blood types are susceptible too. It could be a load of twaddle, but I'm supposed to be prone to viruses, which is true for me, but have higher resistance to other illnesses. Worth a read at any rate. :happy:0 -
C'mon guys... B positive...0
-
C'mon guys... B positive...
Haha I'm B positive
I get to eat all the bacon!0 -
I've got red blood, so I eat food.
That's why i eat it'll be the Red Blood i have i knew their was a reason :laugh: :laugh: :laugh:0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions