low carb/high protein diet
spark409
Posts: 96
Hello
So i was wondering what are YOUR thoughts on a low carb/high protein diet.
by this i mean extremely low carb and extremely high protein. like a brocoli and grilled chicken meal for example.
one of my friends (a guy) eats like this, and hes really muscular and has really little body fat. he recommends this diet, but I want to know what you all think
So i was wondering what are YOUR thoughts on a low carb/high protein diet.
by this i mean extremely low carb and extremely high protein. like a brocoli and grilled chicken meal for example.
one of my friends (a guy) eats like this, and hes really muscular and has really little body fat. he recommends this diet, but I want to know what you all think
0
Replies
-
I don't think its necessary to go to extremes - for myself, I like to keep carbs under about 100g, and aim to get my protein up to near 100g per day.
Chicken with broccoli sounds pretty typical for what I might eat for dinner!0 -
i am low carb so of course i agree with this way of eating. many will bash it but its truely saved my life so i highly suggest it to anyone. it is honestly the way we were supposed to eat. Our bodies were not meant to handle the highly processed crap we have all around us.0
-
I've done low carb (15%) with both higher protein and higher fat (at different times, obviously).
I prefer the feeling and progress on the higher fat side of things (65% right now).
Pretty much what the LCHF thing is all about in Sweden.
Higher protein just seems to make me sluggish and, when it comes to regulating insulin (if this matters to you) then dietary fat will not trigger a response, whereas protein will (but to a lesser extent than carbohydrate). A fact that I missed for a long time.
Then again I do not do much 'working out' (some walking and push-ups is about my lot), I guess you'd need more protein if you are looking to build muscle or have some intensive exercise schedule.0 -
Here's how I figure it:
During the evolution of humans our brain size increased. The only NATURALLY OCCURRING source of food that provides the needed nutrients for the larger brains is meat. Now, nature is not going to design humans to eat food that will be bad for them. So, we can assume that our bodies are designed to digest meats and raw fruits and vegetables.
Also to know is that carbs turn into glucose in your body, triggering the release of insulin. Insulin promotes the storing of fat. So if you wish to burn your own fat and minimize the storing of more fat reducing carbs (especially starchy carbs) is a good thing.
Personally for me it's an issue of I want to say cleanness. Processed foods mess up my insides and studies show that they can lead to colon cancer. Even if they don't cause cancer, they still mess with me. So I try to eat foods where I can directly tell the plant or animal that they came from and reduce the processed foods. This means lots of meat and not a lot of carbs.0 -
For me it is the only way to go. I have more energy and less of the bloated feeling and just feel so much better all round. go for it. B.W. Lesley0
-
of course processed carbs are out of the question!
what do you mean though by starchy carbs? (i know these are potatoes etc...) but what are non-starchy carbs then?
also guys what % of my calories should come from carbs and protein on a LC/HP diet?0 -
I know that for me, limiting the carbs I ate really made a difference in weight loss. I didnt cut them out completely, because thats just silly. We need them as an energy source and eliminating them from our diet can cause the body to enter into a state of Ketoacidosis where the body is forced to use ketone bodies as an energy sourse, which, if utilized over a prolonged period of time can acutualy cause a coma. I veiw carbs a a purposful addition to my diet, the key is being aware of them. Measure them so that you know what a cup of pasta looks like. It may surprise you how small it is. Really the key is to cut out processed foods from the diet because thats where alot of sugar and carbs hide. As a general rule when grocery shoping, shop the perimeter of the store, thats where most unprocessed foods are sold in most stores. And while yes there is the bakery, you will atleast be aware of the carbs youre are eating.0
-
of course processed carbs are out of the question!
what do you mean though by starchy carbs? (i know these are potatoes etc...) but what are non-starchy carbs then?
also guys what % of my calories should come from carbs and protein on a LC/HP diet?
Starchy carbs (vegetables high in carb content) are foods like corn, potato, squash, beans, etc.
Other type carbs which come from vegetables with lower carb content are from foods like cucumber, brocolli, green leafy veggies (spinach, lettuce), celery, mushrooms, peppers, cabbage, radishes, avocado.
The % really depends on your goals. If your goals is to lower carb intake but not go super low I would say under 100g carbs. If you wanna go ultra low on carbs <50g, about 1g of protein per lean body mass pound, and the rest fat.
What the previous poster was talking about I agree that keto (<50 carbs a day) is not sustainable in the long run but is good for cutting fat over a span of a few months.
PS the whole 20 lb I lost was through low carb high protein diet.0 -
Limiting dietary carbohydrate will NOT cause ketoacidosis.
Ketoacidosis is way different from nutritional ketosis.
Using ketones for energy is a natural state and is NOT dangerous.
Ketoacidosis can result in coma but it sure as hell isn't happening through diet.0 -
I started using this application on my phone as it was recommended by my personal trainer as a way of keeping a track of my protein and carbs as she put me on a body building type high protein low carb diet programme. I am naturally muscular and dont necessarily want to use this as a way of bulking up but to cut the fat so I have some definition in my physique. I have only been following the programme around 90% and have been doing it for about 10 days. I have lost 4lbs since I started and I hope that I can keep up some slow reduction in fat without losing any muscle. I dont train too heavily, about 3-4 hours a week so I dont feel that I am doing this in a body building capacity, more an exercise in getting lean. I have found the high protein low carb system that I follow is simple and very very filling. In fact sometimes I struggle to eat the amount of meals I am suppose to have. And that is coming from someone with a big appetite. It can get boring and tedious but sometimes that makes it simpler in that I dont have the constant fight with my inner self arguing over portion sizes or what I am allowed to have to eat for dinner each day. It has all been worked out for me, I just need to measure and cook without thinking. Easy.......well so far anyway.0
-
DONT FORGET ABOUT YOUR FATS!!!0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 423 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions