We are pleased to announce that as of March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor has been introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

Pickle - zero calories?

Annette8479
Annette8479 Posts: 82 Member
in Food and Nutrition
Today I had a pre-packaged pickle in a plastic bag from 7-11. It's called Van Holten's dill pickle. Why am I not convinced this was ZERO CALORIES? I mean cucumbers are not zero calories. And what about the vinegar or whatever is used to make pickles into pickles. Then I definitely tasted some saltiness in the pickle. I don't know...does anyone have any input on the packaging of this pickle saying zaro calories?

Replies

  • thinnnnnnner
    thinnnnnnner Posts: 89
    Uh, all the pickles I've ever logged have been 3-5 cal/pickle... unless it's genetically modified or something... :|
  • SouffleBoy
    SouffleBoy Posts: 65 Member
    Today I had a pre-packaged pickle in a plastic bag from 7-11. It's called Van Holten's dill pickle. Why am I not convinced this was ZERO CALORIES? I mean cucumbers are not zero calories. And what about the vinegar or whatever is used to make pickles into pickles. Then I definitely tasted some saltiness in the pickle. I don't know...does anyone have any input on the packaging of this pickle saying zaro calories?

    Isn't this an american thing where if the food is less than 5 calories it can be marked as 0 calories? So its probably around 4-5 calories rather than 0 calories which is impossible for something which has substances your body can metabolise.
  • Silverkittycat
    Silverkittycat Posts: 1,997 Member
    Don't bother logging it unless you're watching sodium.
  • TexanThom
    TexanThom Posts: 778
    I have had some of these pickles where there are 5 servings in one bag. 4 or 5 calories per serving=20 to 25 calories. I am more worried about the sodium in that many servings.
  • Annette8479
    Annette8479 Posts: 82 Member
    But even 5 calories doesn't seem right for this yummy, salty, big pickle!
  • zyxst
    zyxst Posts: 9,150 Member
    Just poking around on other sites, they say Van Hoten's pickles are 0 cals and about 520mg of sodium per 1 oz. If these are the pickle-in-a-bag that I remember from childhood, they sure aren't 1 oz pickles.

    As SouffleBoy said, U.S. allows foods to be marked as 0 if they have less than a certain percentage of calories/sodium/whatever in them.
  • Ruthe8
    Ruthe8 Posts: 423 Member
    Today I had a pre-packaged pickle in a plastic bag from 7-11. It's called Van Holten's dill pickle. Why am I not convinced this was ZERO CALORIES? I mean cucumbers are not zero calories. And what about the vinegar or whatever is used to make pickles into pickles. Then I definitely tasted some saltiness in the pickle. I don't know...does anyone have any input on the packaging of this pickle saying zaro calories?

    Isn't this an american thing where if the food is less than 5 calories it can be marked as 0 calories? So its probably around 4-5 calories rather than 0 calories which is impossible for something which has substances your body can metabolise.
    Yes, zero calories actually means less than 5. You've probably burned off that many typing this post.
  • SouffleBoy
    SouffleBoy Posts: 65 Member
    But even 5 calories doesn't seem right for this yummy, salty, big pickle!

    Its mainly water.
  • drmerc
    drmerc Posts: 2,603 Member
    I don't log pickles. It says 0 because its less than 5 cal per serving
  • Onema2012
    Onema2012 Posts: 26
    Today I had a pre-packaged pickle in a plastic bag from 7-11. It's called Van Holten's dill pickle. Why am I not convinced this was ZERO CALORIES? I mean cucumbers are not zero calories. And what about the vinegar or whatever is used to make pickles into pickles. Then I definitely tasted some saltiness in the pickle. I don't know...does anyone have any input on the packaging of this pickle saying zaro calories?

    Isn't this an american thing where if the food is less than 5 calories it can be marked as 0 calories? So its probably around 4-5 calories rather than 0 calories which is impossible for something which has substances your body can metabolise.
    What he said.

    They're allowed to round 5calories down to zero.
  • jennifermaffei17
    jennifermaffei17 Posts: 158
    I have vlasic dill spears that a 0 calories
  • planetshark
    planetshark Posts: 37 Member
    Impossible. And worse, you got about 1/2 day's worth of salt there!
  • Annette8479
    Annette8479 Posts: 82 Member
    it does seem impossible. i could eat pickles all day!
  • ehju0901
    ehju0901 Posts: 396 Member
    I had this same question. I like to have a jar of pickles at my desk at work for a snack sometimes. I'd like to be able to log it since I like to be thorough. I'll just assume it is 5 calories per serving to be safe lol.
  • AnnPT77
    AnnPT77 Posts: 35,650 Member
    ehju0901 wrote: »
    I had this same question. I like to have a jar of pickles at my desk at work for a snack sometimes. I'd like to be able to log it since I like to be thorough. I'll just assume it is 5 calories per serving to be safe lol.

    This is a thread from 2012 (probably some spammer put a reply on it and woke it up again).

    Yes, count 5 calories per serving of a thing that says zero calories, like pickles, if you're eating enough of them to add up to a meaningful amount. It may be a small overestimate of the calories, but NBD.
  • lynn_glenmont
    lynn_glenmont Posts: 10,137 Member
    edited January 2022
    deleting because I just realized the OP posted this years ago.

Categories