TDEE - need help with understanding.

My numbers on Calorie Line give me a TDEE of 1240 calories if I simply lay in bed all day in order to reach my goal of 130 lbs. The chart then provides a list of exercise expenditures with corresponding TDEE (calorie intake) numbers. MFP has me on 1200 cals, which increases depending on my added activity.

Two questions, does TDEE really work? Will I still lose weight if I add exercise and add calories according to the TDEE chart? Or should I only eat the extra (exercise) calories that I log above my original 1200 calorie baseline? I don't want to lose lean muscle mass, I just want to lose fat. Am I always supposed to eat back my exercise calories? I don't want my metabolism to slow down anymore than it is...I have an underactive thyroid (Hashimotos), and am on meds to control it.

Eventually, I want to be able to eat around 1500 cals a day with a more active life style to maintain my weight loss when I get to goal.

Any thoughts or clarity you could provide me would be appreciated! Thanks.

Replies

  • geekyjock76
    geekyjock76 Posts: 2,720 Member
    1240 is your Resting Metabolic Rate, or Resting Energy Expenditure. It wouldn't be considered your TDEE since you aren't going to be waking up and laying in bed literally all day, every day.

    Your RMR comprises of 60-75% of your daily energy expenditure. Additionally, the Thermic Effect of food (energy needed to absorb food) requires roughly an additional 10% for most people. The third variable in TDEE is planned exercise which you would estimate energy expenditure for each exercise and include that number to the previous two. The last variable, unplanned exercise, generally is not included in the equation since mundane activity can vary too greatly. So you'd basically be concerned with RMR, TEF, and exercise calories to create a rough estimate of your TDEE.

    To many people, MFP's methods are very confusing in setting the default deficit. The deficit, is the sum of calories reduced from TDEE according to eating less and upping exercise. So, a deficit involving eating 500 calories below TDEE is the same as a 500 calorie deficit where you eat 300 calories under TDEE and up activity by 200 calories. In fact, the latter scenario is the preferred option for various reasons, one of which is that being active leads to overall better well-being. Just make sure that if you include exercise as part of the deficit, that calorie restriction makes up the bulk of the sum deficit.

    Honestly, the best way to estimate your true, present TDEE is to log food intake and exercise calories and see if you're able to maintain weight for a few weeks before making any changes to diet and exercise. The reason I prefer that people do this is because RMR and TDEE equations are predictions and can be off by 100, 200 or more calories depending on the individual's actual RMR due to chronic under-eating or diseases that impact metabolic functioning. Once you find your actual TDEE, then you can establish your deficit. Another reason is that many people may make drastic dietary and exercise changes before even knowing how many calories they truly need to eat to remain in maintenance. Without knowing your maintenance range, it really makes calculating for fat loss a lot tougher than necessary.
  • rose313
    rose313 Posts: 1,146 Member
    I think you have your TDEE and your BMR mixed up, it sounds like your BMR is 1240, that's the amount of calories your body burns doing nothing. Your TDEE is the amount of calories your body burns in a regular day not including exercise.
  • wtlos4me
    wtlos4me Posts: 39 Member
    Thank you so much for taking the time to explain TDEE to me, I really appreciate it!