Falling low on Calcium. I hate dairy. I hate leafy greens.
OK_Girl
Posts: 123 Member
An impossible question!
My diary is public- however I had a stomach bug Fri, Sat and Sunday so I didn't track. You will have to look prior to that.
I recently took a look at my calcium levels- and wasn't shocked to see them falling behind- but I was surprised to see that they are on average 50% below what I need.
I dislike dairy- apart from unsweetened yogurt. I don't eat cheese- I can tolerate milk in my cereal or coffee. I don't like cottage cheese, either. Which would seem logical- the next best source is leafy greens, right? Wrong. I HATE spinach, kale, etc. I love broccoli and asparagus, squash and beans but not much calcium in there.
Can you think of any other foods rich in calcium that would also fit into my calorie plan? Or should I just take a suppliment?
Thank you for your time!
My diary is public- however I had a stomach bug Fri, Sat and Sunday so I didn't track. You will have to look prior to that.
I recently took a look at my calcium levels- and wasn't shocked to see them falling behind- but I was surprised to see that they are on average 50% below what I need.
I dislike dairy- apart from unsweetened yogurt. I don't eat cheese- I can tolerate milk in my cereal or coffee. I don't like cottage cheese, either. Which would seem logical- the next best source is leafy greens, right? Wrong. I HATE spinach, kale, etc. I love broccoli and asparagus, squash and beans but not much calcium in there.
Can you think of any other foods rich in calcium that would also fit into my calorie plan? Or should I just take a suppliment?
Thank you for your time!
0
Replies
-
I'd vote for the supplement - along w/trying to find some things with calcium you do like.0
-
Sesame seeds. Yumm......
http://www.healthdiaries.com/eatthis/15-non-dairy-foods-high-in-calcium.html0 -
Try replacing regular yogurt with Greek yogurt, as it has twice the calcium of regular yogurt.
Fish you'd eat with the bones in them, like sardines, are also good calcium sources.
Most orange juices are calcium-fortified nowadays.
I don't understand this extreme dislike of dairy. Cottage cheese is pretty bland. If you buy the no-salt-added type, it doesn't taste like anything. You can flavor it in any way you like. I typically add a dab of pesto to it so it's savory.0 -
Have you tried milk alternatives like soy, almond, rice or coconut milk? Most have as much or more calcium as milk.
Some non-milk sources of calcium are beans, rhubarb, sardines, salmon, okra, tofu. Almonds, tomato products, shrimp, and rutabaga also have calcium.
Or, you could take a supplement. There is some evidence of supplements raising the risk of heart disease, though it is not conclusive. If you take a supplement I would suggest taking a low dose supplement twice a day, rather than one that give >= 100% RDA in one dose.0 -
Ha ha. Sorry you don't undesrtand. I don't understand it myself! I just can't eat it. It grosses me out. It always has. As a child I could eat cereal but I would never drink the milk out of the bowl. I just don't like it. Same as some people don't like onions, or liver. Or liver and onions! I've tried to like it- honestly. But I just don't like it- and forcing myself to try and eat it makes my stomach turn.
The thing with greens goes back to my childhood where my mom would try and force me to eat spinach, collard greens etc. She would spank me if I didn't finish them. Often I would eat them but they would not stay down- and I threw them up. I got into trouble for that too. I was abused as a child so there is probably a mental aspect to the greens thing.
Thank you for the tip of fish and sesame seeds. I love sardines.0 -
Sesame seeds. Yumm......
http://www.healthdiaries.com/eatthis/15-non-dairy-foods-high-in-calcium.html
Has any one told you you look like Gilda Radner, or are you too young to know who she is?0 -
Nope, never been told that before. I don't think I've been told I look like anyone famous before :-) I do know who she is though. Funny lady.0
-
until you find something that you like that is a good substitute for those more common sources, i would go with with a supplement (that has vitamin D added to it for absorption.) magnesium is also very important for calcium absorption, and some supplements do include it along with the vitamin D. usually calcium deficiency and vitamin D deficiency go hand in hand, but i don't know what your magnesium intake would be. that would be dependent upon if you eat good sources of it.
calcium is only as good as your absorption of it.0 -
Viactiv! My dr. told me to take those since I'm not a milk drinker and I have a family history of osteoporosis.0
-
One thing that helps with Calcium levels/absorption is Magnesium. From what I've researched and understand, the best form of Magnesium supplement (since it's not really in a lot of our foods) is Magnesium Citrate. Citrate refers to the Vitamin D that is in the supplement and helps the Magnesium to be absorbed which in turn helps with Calcium absorption. I believe it to be a huge factor in Osteoporosis since people often get plenty (or too much) Calcium in their diets but have no way to absorb it which causes Calcium buildup and does more harm than good. You may be getting plenty of Calcium but are simply unable to absorb the proper amounts.
I've been taking Magnesium either in Calm - Raspberry-Lemon is the best (http://www.calmnatural.com/) or a Mag-Citrate suppliment for years and it has helped me greatly. I like the Whole Foods brand of the Mag-Citrate (about $20 for 180 pills which is a 90 day supply - if you have Whole Foods where you live you can buy 5 store brand supplements for any price and get one free, up to $20 - I always make sure my free one counts and use it for the Mag-Citrate or Pro-biotics which usually run high). You can get the Calm at Whole Foods or your standard health foods store as well.
And just in case anyone thinks I'm blowing smoke, check out a couple of links here. Just do a little digging and you will find that magnesium is very key to the Calcium deficiency issue. Also, be sure if you are planning on taking a Calcium supplement that it is a good one - not some cheap Wal-Mart Calcium Carbonate.
http://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/magnesium-deficiency-linked-to-higher-risk-of-osteoporosis-says-doctor-126240433.html
http://integrativemed.kumc.edu/school-of-medicine/integrative-medicine/health-topics/the-benefits-of-magnesium.html
And if you are still interested, here is a blurb off of the Calm website about the importance of Magnesium:
Calcium—Too Much of a Good Thing?
Calcium deficiency can be a serious issue. It is an important nutrient your body needs every day, but too much calcium can also be a problem.
The recommended adequate intake of calcium according to the National Institutes of Health, Office of Dietary Supplements, is 1,000 mg for adults aged 19–50 and 1,200 mg for 51 plus. There are many adults who are taking 1,200–1,500 mg of supplemental calcium in addition to their dietary intake of calcium (an 8 oz cup of low-fat fruit yogurt contains 345 mg of calcium and one cup of nonfat milk contains 306 mg). Unassimilated calcium can end up in the soft tissues of the body where it deposits and hardens (calcifies) or in the urine where it may result in kidney stones.
Unless calcium and magnesium are properly balanced, magnesium becomes depleted (too much calcium can itself deplete magnesium levels). This can result in an inability to quickly recover from stress and can itself be a source of stress.
Hope that helps and is not too much info.0 -
If you aren't eating any dairy or leafy greens, then you best eat a supplement! Osteoporosis can kick in without adequate calcium.0
-
I didn't read all the responses, so sorry if I'm repeating. I just like to type.
If you have 1/2 cup milk in your coffee, and a portion of cheese, and some nuts, and fresh veggies and lean meats, you will be fine.
You can always make "green smoothies" - Google for recipes - adding kale or spinach to a smoothie doesn't change the flavor at all, just the color. And you get to sneak in the nutrients. Win.0 -
Nope, never been told that before. I don't think I've been told I look like anyone famous before :-) I do know who she is though. Funny lady.
She's right! You do look a bit like her!0 -
Will try a suppliment. I AM LOW on vit D, have been taking the 50K once a week for years. Thanks everyone.
PS almond milk gives me diareah every time. Soy milk gives me gas. Not trying to shoot down any ones responses- and not trying to be a picky eater- I really really appreciate all the advice and info!0 -
Try replacing regular yogurt with Greek yogurt, as it has twice the calcium of regular yogurt.
Fish you'd eat with the bones in them, like sardines, are also good calcium sources.
Most orange juices are calcium-fortified nowadays.
^^^^^^This^^^^^^^0 -
Have you tried sneaking greens into smoothies or burgers? I usually throw at least one or two handfuls of spinach into my smoothies and can not even taste it. I also had a recipe once upon a time that had veggies shredded into turkey burgers that was pretty good...back in the day.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 422 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions