Cardio and weights, which order.
readthat
Posts: 136
What is the theory on cardio and weights. Should cardio be done before or after weight lifting? When I lift weights first, then run, my run is much harder. I am not sure if this is a good thing, sometimes I can't run as far on those days.
0
Replies
-
I always do cardio first. One I feel more energenic if I do cardio first and I also feel like it loosens the muscles up ( warms them up) for the lifting.0
-
Which is more important to you?
Depending on what kind of weight training you do, do you think it is safer to be already tired out when running or already tired out when lifting heavy things with/on top of/over you body?0 -
Id like to know the anwser to that also. I switch it up sometimes as to keep confuzing the body. I find that after a run, I dont have as much to give on the weights.0
-
Might want to consider doing them on separate days so you have an intense day followed by a more resting/recovery day. Another combination may be cardio warm up upper body next day cardio warm up lower body. JMO0
-
Depending on what kind of weight training you do, do you think it is safer to be already tired out when running or already tired out when lifting heavy things with/on top of/over you body?
^^^^^^This.
While it is sometimes harder to do cardio after lifting, cardio isn't as complicated. No matter how tired I am, I can safely put one foot in front of the other. But if I'm exhausted from cardio and then try to squat, bench or OHP, bad things can happen if I'm not fully aware of my form, surroundings and energy reserves.
Doing it on separate days is an option, but sometimes people don't have the time or inclination to get dressed to workout 6 days a week. It's fine to do cardio and lifting the same day, but the way I strongly prefer is lifting first.0 -
I do weights first so I have more energy to spend on lifting heavy.0
-
Weights before cardio0
-
Thanks for the advice. I do have one day for weights only and two days run only, so I will keep the days I do both weights first!0
-
My trainer has me doing 10 minutes before and 20 minutes after.0
-
My trainer told me to start with cardio and then do weights (as the cardio warms up your muscles and allows for better burning of fat in your muscles) and then end with cardio.0
-
I am pro-lifting, with only a bit of cardio, but I think it really depends on how much of each you are doing. Are you talking about doing a hard core cardio exercise (for me, that would be over 30 mins of intervals) or just 10 mins as a warmup? Also, what type of weights are you doing? Are you lifting heavy with free weights or using the machines?
My ideal is a brief, but brisk cardio warmup (say 5 mins to get my heart rate up), followed by my heavy lifting program (NROLFW), followed by 15 minutes of intense interval training. This varies for me depending on which day/workout I am doing, but this is a pretty good average of what I do. My heart rate is up the entire time!
Before I started weight lifting I had always heard the opposite- cardio first and then weights, but I have found that I get in a much better workout (and feel better afterwards) when I do it this way.0 -
Best option is do them on different days
If you have to do the same day, then weights first0 -
It definitely feels like if I do cardio first, I am "running hotter" for the weights, in that my heart rate/breathing are more elevated throughout than they would be if I lifted first. Which seems like it should be a good thing. Subjective, but that's just my 2 cents.0
-
I couldn't imagine jumping into a weights routine without at least SOME cardio. It sounds dumb but I do 10 minutes elliptical, 20 minutes weights (legs), 10 minutes treadmill, 20 minutes weights (arms), 10 minutes elliptical, 20 minutes weights (core). It's a long work out but it keeps me going. By going back and forth to the cardio machines, I keep my heart rate up higher overall.0
-
Weights then cardio. With a lower body work out I swim earlier in the day as too tired to do cardio after, but with upper body, I can still fit in cardio. Strength training takes priority for me.0
-
the point of strength training is to get stronger. not "run hotter" or "burn more calories'.0
-
if you are doing enough weights to matter, then you wouldn't be bracketing them with cardio0
-
Weights before cardio
^^ this0 -
My preference is strength training first, then cardio on days that I do both. I start out getting my heart rate up with some brisk walking and/or jumping jacks, but not enough minutes to consider it a "cardio session". I do feel more tired when it's time to do the cardio after weights, but I don't care because I really like the stacking that occurs when I lift then do cardio. It seems like my heart rate stays up in a higher range for longer with the cardio after strength judging by my HRM. With the same exact cardio workout, my HR stays in a higher range on average when it follows strength training than when I do the cardio alone. It seems like my body has to work harder nd that's what I want since I'm trying to lose weight without exercising half of my day.0
-
I do them on separate days, but if I were to do them both on the same, I'd lift first. I'd rather run slower... lifting when I'm pooped sounds dangerous.0
-
My trainer has me doing 10 minutes before and 20 minutes after.
Yep, agree.
Warm up a little then weights.
I do my "easy cardio" on weights days... Eg cycling and cross trainer. On the other days I run and do no weights at all.0 -
I'm addicted to my cardio, so I always do it first for at least an hour, then I do my strength for another 30 minutes. When I was only doing cardio (running), I was really getting thin, but it was when I started strength training that I saw amazing results in my body, so I'm trying to convince myself to spend more time lifting weights.0
-
Yeah, I agree with short period of cardio (30 minutes of low impact or 10 minutes of high impact), then strength, then do more cardio if you want. I may be doing the 30 day shred, as opposed to weights, but I have been doing a 30 minute low impact video beforehand. It energizes me for the more intense workout, and I find I get way more out of the hard workout after doing the light workout. If I went any harder or further, though, it would have the opposite effect.
Think of it this way: Do enough cardio to get your blood moving, so you're nice and warm and get the most out of your lifting, and then when you're finished lifting, do any cardio you intend to do for fat loss.
I think doing it on different days is probably more ideal though.0 -
My trainer told me to start with cardio and then do weights (as the cardio warms up your muscles and allows for better burning of fat in your muscles) and then end with cardio.
This ^^. My trainer told me the same thing. I do about 10 mins of cardio to get warmed up, then weights, then another round of cardio. Per my HRM, I burn a lot more calories this way than if I skip the first round of cardio.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions