TDEE vs. MFP Calc?
leelee0623
Posts: 17
Hello everyone!
I am hoping someone can clarify something for me...
I found a Newbie user link to calculate TDEE from the Fat 2 Fit Radio's calculators. My TDEE is higher than what MFP calculated, so which should I go by? I am pretty new but have been tracking consistently for about 3 weeks and lost 3.5 lbs with MFP, but I could definitely eat more! I've had headaches more frequently lately and I'm wondering if I just need to eat some more. I am also trying to work out at 3x per week and would enter my exercise into MFP, then eat back the calories. My goal is lose 1-1.5 pounds per week. TDEE is 2,041 (less 20% is 1,630) and MFP is 1,410.
I am hoping someone can clarify something for me...
I found a Newbie user link to calculate TDEE from the Fat 2 Fit Radio's calculators. My TDEE is higher than what MFP calculated, so which should I go by? I am pretty new but have been tracking consistently for about 3 weeks and lost 3.5 lbs with MFP, but I could definitely eat more! I've had headaches more frequently lately and I'm wondering if I just need to eat some more. I am also trying to work out at 3x per week and would enter my exercise into MFP, then eat back the calories. My goal is lose 1-1.5 pounds per week. TDEE is 2,041 (less 20% is 1,630) and MFP is 1,410.
0
Replies
-
MFP does not include calories for exercise. TDEE does. MFP gives you a lower target calorie goal, with the expectation that you will eat extra calories to fuel your workouts.
So, either go with MFP calculations for NET calories, 1410 + calories earned through exercise.
Or, set your own goal as TDEE - 20% and do not eat any extra calories for exercise.0 -
Also, the calculator you used at Fat2Fit radio website, did it say "eating for the future you"? That is not your TDEE now, that is your TDEE for your goal weight.0
-
I entered my current and goal weight as the same to find my current TDEE and then took that number and deducted 20% for a a deficit.0
-
Hello everyone!
I am hoping someone can clarify something for me...
I found a Newbie user link to calculate TDEE from the Fat 2 Fit Radio's calculators. My TDEE is higher than what MFP calculated, so which should I go by? I am pretty new but have been tracking consistently for about 3 weeks and lost 3.5 lbs with MFP, but I could definitely eat more! I've had headaches more frequently lately and I'm wondering if I just need to eat some more. I am also trying to work out at 3x per week and would enter my exercise into MFP, then eat back the calories. My goal is lose 1-1.5 pounds per week. TDEE is 2,041 (less 20% is 1,630) and MFP is 1,410.
What you've been doing is getting you the 1-1.5 lbs/week you want... so keep doing it. Don't worry about what the actual numbers may be.0 -
Okay thanks, I will stick to what MFP says!
It's just confusing because when you would customize your calories by using the TDEE and 20% deficit method when MFP does it for you? Couldn't you also change your goals and have MFP calc calories based on your goals?0 -
I entered my current and goal weight as the same to find my current TDEE and then took that number and deducted 20% for a a deficit.
On fat to fit radio, your do not put your goal weight in, you put your current weight for both. Got this info from dan who posted the thread and there is a group, In Place of a Road Map.
Check it out and see if your doing it correctly, can be confusing!0 -
TDEE = Total Daily Energy Expenditure - TDEE is the amount of energy (in calories) that your body is using each day. (BMR plus the additional energy used in your daily activities including exercise.) To lose weight, you generally want to eat under your TDEE, but over your BMR. To gain weight, eat over your TDEE. (See calculators to figure out good targets within that range.)
BMR = Basal Metabolic Rate - BMR is the minimum energy that your body needs to sustain itself at rest. This amount, measured in calories, would be necessary for basic functions like breathing, heart beats, renewing tissue, etc. Eat above your BMR except under very special conditions and with medical supervision.
Since MFP doesn't have a TDEE calculator, I think you may be getting the two numbers confused.
Headaches can be caused by low blood sugar. I used to get them in the early afternoon, if I hadn't eaten by then. You may be right that you aren't eating enough or maybe you need to eat at different times. Headaches can also be caused by other changes in your diet. Are you eating things you didn't eat before? You may be mildly allergic or having a reaction to them. Many "diet" foods have artificial sweeteners or MSG; both of which can trigger headaches for many people. Or it could be something you dropped from your diet. Rapid drops in caffeine intake can cause headaches; they'll go away after a few days or you can slowly have less and less caffeine to lower the level your body is used to having. If you're tracking what you eat, it may help to track when you have headaches in the notes, then look for patterns.
Congratulations on the weight loss so far. Good luck figuring out what works best for you long-term!
Edited to add this link to other terms and the links to calculators: http://www.myfitnesspal.com/blog/Robin_Bin/view/mfp-terms-introductory-274185
Also, the TDEE-% or MFP calculation with deficit based on your goals and then adding back calories for exercise as you record it (many other sites add calories based on what you say you will be doing) are both good ways to calculate an initial target. Don't go under 1,200/day without medical supervision. Try to eat healthier than you were before. Either method of calculation gives you a starting calorie target and then you can adjust after you see how well it works for you. (Try it at least 1 month first, because there may be some initial changes based on water weight, time of the month or other temporary factors.) Since you're on the MFP site, I recommend starting with the MFP guidelines based on your entries here. As you learn more and see how your body reacts, you may switch plans or mix and match. Oh, and whichever plan you use, make sure you eat healthy, including fiber and drink plenty.0 -
Yes I am referencing Dan’s post and I did put in my current weight for both goal and current weight. I think my headaches could be part allergies and part diet. I think I wait too long to eat in the afternoon . Thank you guys so much for your help! i really appreciate the responses!0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 423 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions