Can people truely change?

Sorry guys, I know this is a fitness/health/weight loss site, but I have no-one else to ask!!!

I've met a guy with a fairly checkered past (not going to elaborate) but he's determined to change his life and has been working hard at doing just that for nearly two years...

Can a person truely change for good? Or are we destined to revert to past behavior?

I'd love to hear any life changing stories you have!

Replies

  • ktaqt3399
    ktaqt3399 Posts: 141 Member
    It is totally possible people can change. If they want it bad enough. We are all changing. Habits can be broken and learning from the past can help write a better future. Unfortunatly you also have to keep one eye open at all time until he has proven that he can change. Hope this helps
  • My eyes are wide open! lol
  • britterbrittney
    britterbrittney Posts: 256 Member
    I work in the domestic violence field. I think I'm too jaded to answer that question. :ohwell:

    But, in all reality yes. I've changed a bagillion times into the person I am today! But, I would wait to see some change before making a huge commitment!
  • dsjohndrow
    dsjohndrow Posts: 1,820 Member
    The truth is that many will try, and few will. Addicts go back out, ex-cons re-offend, and people on MFP who lose weight give up. There are a small percentage that do make life changes. I tell my daughters this: "Why don't you just pick someone without all the baggage of the past?" It's easier to do when you are young, than when you are middle-age.
  • djsupreme6
    djsupreme6 Posts: 1,210 Member
    I would say its according to what they're changing from really...lots of people on this very site are changing their lifestyles completely...it also depends on the person as we are all unique...hope it works for you but there is always the take it very slow option
  • ningggsm
    ningggsm Posts: 202
    I like this. I agree. If they're really willing to change, they'll make it happen. Bad habits are hard to break- but it's not impossible. We've all had pasts that we probably wished didn't exist- but they do. It's the past and people can grow to be a better individual. At least that's what I believe.
  • Williamj
    Williamj Posts: 199 Member
    Anyone can change, but a lot of people will drag you down before can you pick them up.
  • Starla_
    Starla_ Posts: 349
    It is totally possible people can change. If they want it bad enough. We are all changing. Habits can be broken and learning from the past can help write a better future. Unfortunatly you also have to keep one eye open at all time until he has proven that he can change. Hope this helps

    True.. but don't keep looking for what might happen and fail to see what is actually happening. The only person they need to actually prove it to is themselves, others just need to have faith :)
  • ningggsm
    ningggsm Posts: 202
    It is totally possible people can change. If they want it bad enough. We are all changing. Habits can be broken and learning from the past can help write a better future. Unfortunatly you also have to keep one eye open at all time until he has proven that he can change. Hope this helps

    I meant I like and agree to this one. Lol.
  • thebigcb
    thebigcb Posts: 2,210 Member
    Sorry guys, I know this is a fitness/health/weight loss site, but I have no-one else to ask!!!

    I've met a guy with a fairly checkered past (not going to elaborate) but he's determined to change his life and has been working hard at doing just that for nearly two years...

    Can a person truely change for good? Or are we destined to revert to past behavior?

    I'd love to hear any life changing stories you have!

    A leopard never changes spots. Stir well the f**k clear.
  • Sorry guys, I know this is a fitness/health/weight loss site, but I have no-one else to ask!!!

    I've met a guy with a fairly checkered past (not going to elaborate) but he's determined to change his life and has been working hard at doing just that for nearly two years...

    Can a person truely change for good? Or are we destined to revert to past behavior?

    I'd love to hear any life changing stories you have!

    A leopard never changes spots. Stir well the f**k clear.

    Is it really that black and white???
  • thebigcb
    thebigcb Posts: 2,210 Member
    Sorry guys, I know this is a fitness/health/weight loss site, but I have no-one else to ask!!!

    I've met a guy with a fairly checkered past (not going to elaborate) but he's determined to change his life and has been working hard at doing just that for nearly two years...

    Can a person truely change for good? Or are we destined to revert to past behavior?

    I'd love to hear any life changing stories you have!

    A leopard never changes spots. Stir well the f**k clear.

    Is it really that black and white???

    YES
  • thebigcb
    thebigcb Posts: 2,210 Member
    To be honest, I think she knows already, if she believed the person, and wasn't having doubts, she wouldn't be asking
  • scs143
    scs143 Posts: 2,190 Member
    You said for two years he's been making that change. I would think that's evidence right there.

    Someone else said that a small amount of people actually do change. Maybe he's one of them. What you need to decide is whether or not you want to take that chance.

    Go with your gut. Good luck.
  • toriaenator
    toriaenator Posts: 423 Member
    of course! im nothing like the person i used to be; life is about evolution and change, as long as you're open to it, its bound to happen :)
  • LaurasClimb
    LaurasClimb Posts: 211 Member
    To be honest, I think she knows already, if she believed the person, and wasn't having doubts, she wouldn't be asking
    Good point!

    Most of the men who have said those kind of things to me were all talk. Maybe they were trying to convince themselves the same time they were trying to convince me.
  • darrensurrey
    darrensurrey Posts: 3,942 Member
    It is totally possible people can change. If they want it bad enough. We are all changing. Habits can be broken and learning from the past can help write a better future. Unfortunatly you also have to keep one eye open at all time until he has proven that he can change. Hope this helps

    Agreed. If he really, really wants to change and is doing it because he feels it's the right thing to do then he will manage it. Just like anything really.
  • oregonzoo
    oregonzoo Posts: 4,251 Member
    People can change. But they have to want to.
  • IronSmasher
    IronSmasher Posts: 3,908 Member
    It's possible, but it's no fun being the guinea pig.
  • Skinny_minny_mo
    Skinny_minny_mo Posts: 1,272 Member
    depends on the change required. we under-estimate just how difficult it is to change.

    there is also the nature vs nurture challenge. our environments, our family, our life circumstances.

    give the person the benefit of the doubt but past performance is usually a good predictor for future performance...

    p.s i worked in mental health, drug abuse etc.
  • Have you changed? How long have you been on your weight loss journey? Have you made lifestyle changes? did it happen over night. Sure people can change if they have the right reasons and ability to stick to it. Do we all back slide into bad habits- yes we do, are we tempted by bad food, friends who are not encouraging- sure. Can a person change YES!
  • pixietoes
    pixietoes Posts: 1,591 Member
    I think it's important, especially early in a relationship, to recognize that people show their best qualities and that is great and fun and exciting. Is it possible for people to leave the worst of themselves in the past? Yes, it is. To do so requires great commitment and a willingness to do some tremendously deep work. Wanting to change is a good first step but it is far from what it takes to bring real osmosis. As a person close to someone changing you will have to accept the good with the bad because change does not happen overnight and it might not happen at all.

    We all have things we should change to make being in a relationship better, but some people have things they need to change that prevent a relationship at all. Think 10 years down the road and make your decision from that standpoint when neither of you are bring your "first date" manners to the game.
  • erickirb
    erickirb Posts: 12,294 Member
    I would say it can happen, but that would be more of the exception to the rule... You will have to ask yourself if you think he can, but be prepared that he wont.

    Here is a quote I hear quite often, and I think it probably fits the majority, but not all cases.
    "A woman marries a man hoping he will change and he never does, A man marries a woman hoping she doesn't change, and she usually does"

    I didn't make up the quote so no bashing me please :)
  • I think people can change, but I also think that we need to be totaly aware of what our problems are. That way we wont be tempted to repeat the same behaviors. I would watch very closely and have a policy of 'open and honest' about everything. its good to leave a bad past and make a new life, but if there are issues that could be putting you at risk medicaly, finacialy or a threat to your safety, you need to really think about what could happen in your future.
  • hbrittingham
    hbrittingham Posts: 2,518 Member
    I am married to a recovering addict. We've been together for 22 years. I won't say that there haven't been ups and downs because there definitely have been. But he has changed over the years and has learned and is still learning what things trigger the addictive behavior and he works very hard to stay clean. What you may find is that once one addiction is conquered, another one may take its place.

    After saying all that, I will say that I absolutely adore my husband and love him with all my heart and he feels the same about me. I wouldn't trade him (spots and all) for anyone. He is my best friend and soul mate.
  • honey_bee_keysha
    honey_bee_keysha Posts: 773 Member
    Do people truly change?

    My answer is no. People do not change unless there is a reason to change or something caused a change. Without that push then a person will not change.
  • diadojikohei
    diadojikohei Posts: 732 Member
    Yes but speaking from experience it is only temporary. I have spent 27 years with the same person and every 5 years or so things deteriorate, we fall apart he says it won't happen again, we are fine for a while and then something starts it off again.

    We have 4 children, two quite grown up now and his behaviour has become erratic again.so I spend my life walking on egg shells waiting for it to happen again. And to be fair, he might sort himself out this time, but the point is you are always waiting for it to happen.

    Is this what you want?
  • pixietoes
    pixietoes Posts: 1,591 Member
    I am married to a recovering addict. We've been together for 22 years. I won't say that there haven't been ups and downs because there definitely have been. But he has changed over the years and has learned and is still learning what things trigger the addictive behavior and he works very hard to stay clean. What you may find is that once one addiction is conquered, another one may take its place.

    After saying all that, I will say that I absolutely adore my husband and love him with all my heart and he feels the same about me. I wouldn't trade him (spots and all) for anyone. He is my best friend and soul mate.

    I think this is a great telling of a wonderful story. The question the OP needs to be asking herself is "Do I love him the way he is enough that if he never changes this can be a good relationship for me even if it never becomes the kind of relationship I'm sure we could have if he changed."