Potato confusion
Options
VeganBunny
Posts: 9 Member
Why do potatoes have more calories when you boil them compared to when you microwave them? Apparently the same size potato has 100 more cals if I boil it rather than microwave it. Of course it will weigh more because it will absorb the water, but it's just water...
0
Replies
-
It should be due to the way starch breaks down into material that is useable by the human body. Boiling integrates heat further into the potato and disperses better than microwaves, breaking down more of the starch; therefore, there are more calories for your body to utilize. Microwaving doesn't break down the starches as well. If it helps, think about how soft a boiled vs. microwaved potato is. Hope this helps.0
-
Some items here are user submitted. They won't all match. You can see on the little window whether it is user submitted information.0
-
It should be due to the way starch breaks down into material that is useable by the human body. Boiling integrates heat further into the potato and disperses better than microwaves, breaking down more of the starch; therefore, there are more calories for your body to utilize. Microwaving doesn't break down the starches as well. If it helps, think about how soft a boiled vs. microwaved potato is. Hope this helps.0
-
Why would that be a joke? I'm in food science, we learn about this. Potatoes technically have fewer calories raw vs. cooked because the human body can't break down those starches.0
-
If it helps, think about how soft a boiled vs. microwaved potato is.I'm in food science, we learn about this. Potatoes technically have fewer calories raw vs. cooked because the human body can't break down those starches.0
-
Why would that be a joke? I'm in food science, we learn about this. Potatoes technically have fewer calories raw vs. cooked because the human body can't break down those starches.0
-
just user entered differences. most likely different sized potatoes used0
-
User entered differences are probably a factor, but cooking does change the caloric availability. You're more than welcome to do your own research if you don't believe me.0
-
Bethanyclaire is 100% correct, its all to do with the glycocemic index of the potato cooked in different ways. depending on how the potato is cooked will mean it has more or less calories.
The human body is not able to process starch efficiently so cooking methods where less starch is broken down equal less calories.
For methods such as mash potato the starch is far more broken down to sugars which are processed far easier by the body as calories.0 -
User entered differences are probably a factor, but cooking does change the caloric availability. You're more than welcome to do your own research if you don't believe me.
Since you're a student, can you cite a source on this. I'm truly intrigued.0 -
Microwaves destroy the goodness and the nutrition in any food. I hate them and never use them.0
-
Why do potatoes have more calories when you boil them compared to when you microwave them? Apparently the same size potato has 100 more cals if I boil it rather than microwave it. Of course it will weigh more because it will absorb the water, but it's just water...
Just weigh it before cooking and use the raw calories.0 -
User entered differences are probably a factor, but cooking does change the caloric availability. You're more than welcome to do your own research if you don't believe me.
Since you're a student, can you cite a source on this. I'm truly intrigued.
When it is in a form which is not processable by the body. grazing animals will get far more calories out of eating grass then humans would purely for the reason that their body is designed to process this food type, whereas the human body is not so we would receive very little nutritional value from eating grass.0 -
Microwaves destroy the goodness and the nutrition in any food. I hate them and never use them.0
-
User entered differences are probably a factor, but cooking does change the caloric availability. You're more than welcome to do your own research if you don't believe me.
Since you're a student, can you cite a source on this. I'm truly intrigued.
When it is in a form which is not processable by the body. grazing animals will get far more calories out of eating grass then humans would purely for the reason that their body is designed to process this food type, whereas the human body is not so we would receive very little nutritional value from eating grass.0 -
Are you checking these calories on caloriecount.about.com? I just checked on there and I saw the 100 calorie difference but that is because the boiled option was a large and the baked/microwave choice was a medium.0
-
Microwaves destroy the goodness and the nutrition in any food. I hate them and never use them.
lol....I am scientist and have a BSc and MPhil in chemistry, as for more sources, just ''Google it''.
Good luck with your research.0 -
http://forum.lowcarber.org/archive/index.php/t-256437.html
http://www.andersenchiro.com/potatoes-and-the-variability-of-the-glycemic-index.shtml
http://journals.cambridge.org/download.php?file=/64680_2C8ED84B2D46A8EA900F8224DBBB5453_journals__BJN_BJN94_06_S0007114505002837a.pdf&cover=Y&code=b712abbe2196ff41be3d4e84592ebdd3
http://www.livestrong.com/article/430497-why-does-the-cooking-method-change-the-glycemic-index/
There's for sources for a start.0 -
Why do potatoes have more calories when you boil them compared to when you microwave them? Apparently the same size potato has 100 more cals if I boil it rather than microwave it. Of course it will weigh more because it will absorb the water, but it's just water...
Use common sense...They don't.0 -
If you want a very detailed article "The Energetic Significance of Cooking" in the Journal of Human Evolution is a good place to start.
RossChip gave a good example of how this happen. Starch digestibility increases with cooking because starches break down into simpler sugars that the human body can utilize. A lot of plant matter is made up of lignin, which humans cannot digest, but ruminant animals can due to their digestive enzymes. Cooking breaks down some lignin and other long-chain polysaccharides (starches). Some, however, do not fully break down, which is where fiber comes from. Fiber is generally composed of lignin, cellulose, and hemicellulose.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 391.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.5K Getting Started
- 259.7K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.6K Food and Nutrition
- 47.3K Recipes
- 232.3K Fitness and Exercise
- 393 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.4K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 152.7K Motivation and Support
- 7.8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.3K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 931 Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.3K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions