I need some help with a book I'm writing....

clairyfairy247
clairyfairy247 Posts: 425 Member
Part of the story involves the protagonist and her husband. He's an a**hole and can at times be emotionally abusive (never physical!)

My main character is a strong woman who tolerates her husbands bad behaviour but I'm struggling to think why.
I need to make it clear what her motivation is for staying with someone who is a d*ck.

She has a 5 year old son so that is one reason to stay.
Can anyone identify any reasons why a strong woman would stay with an emotionally abusive man?

Also, I need reasons why she fell in love with him in the first place. He is charismatic and charming but I need to give him some more appeal or the story won't sound believable.

All suggestions welcome!

Thanks :-) x

Replies

  • gingerjen7
    gingerjen7 Posts: 821 Member
    Part of the story involves the protagonist and her husband. He's an a**hole and can at times be emotionally abusive (never physical!)

    My main character is a strong woman who tolerates her husbands bad behaviour but I'm struggling to think why.
    I need to make it clear what her motivation is for staying with someone who is a d*ck.

    She has a 5 year old son so that is one reason to stay.
    Can anyone identify any reasons why a strong woman would stay with an emotionally abusive man?

    Also, I need reasons why she fell in love with him in the first place. He is charismatic and charming but I need to give him some more appeal or the story won't sound believable.

    All suggestions welcome!

    Thanks :-) x
    Do we get to share writing credit?
  • blushingmama
    blushingmama Posts: 111 Member
    fear, codependency, insecurities. it's possible to be strong in one area of your life and weak in another.

    she was left by her true love and her heart never healed. so she wants someone that needs her more than she needs him.
  • jenbcz
    jenbcz Posts: 17 Member
    maybe she's the maternal type who figures she can fix him and help him get over his issues. Maybe she figures he's actually a really great guy under all his insecurities that cause him to act out . . . . Maybe he's super hot and and maybe she thinks the good, charming, charasmatic side of him, out weighs the annoying, whiny, hurtful side of him. Maybe she's the type of person who loves drama, addicted to the emotional roller coaster that is her life, and if she's not feeling big giant emotions, good or bad, she doesn't really feel alive. None of the above are healthy places to be . . .
  • MimiCro
    MimiCro Posts: 96 Member
    maybe her dad was like that to her mom
  • magj0y
    magj0y Posts: 1,911 Member
    Part of the story involves the protagonist and her husband. He's an a**hole and can at times be emotionally abusive (never physical!)

    My main character is a strong woman who tolerates her husbands bad behaviour but I'm struggling to think why.
    I need to make it clear what her motivation is for staying with someone who is a d*ck.

    She has a 5 year old son so that is one reason to stay.
    Can anyone identify any reasons why a strong woman would stay with an emotionally abusive man?

    Also, I need reasons why she fell in love with him in the first place. He is charismatic and charming but I need to give him some more appeal or the story won't sound believable.

    All suggestions welcome!

    Thanks :-) x

    "strong" women who stay with emotionally abusive husbands are not strong. They may appear to be strong, but they're not.
    They typically stay for a few reasons;
    1; This is how their daddy was, so it's what they're used to. It's normal behavior, and they don't even realize it's abuse.
    2;They're in denial about the humiliation and what not
    2B; "It's not like he HITS me or anything" mentality
    2C "It's somehow better than being a single mom
    3; the humiliation of a divorce is worse than the divorce
    4; staying for "the sake of the kids"
    5; Low self-esteem and self worth

    "Never physical" it's still abuse and can be equally as hurtful. There may be no broken bones or bruises, but there is no self respect or self esteem, either.

    Why she fell in love with him in the first place;
    1; he's a lot like her daddy.
    2; He wasn't like this when they first met.
    3; no one taught her about "red flags" growing up.
    4; she was young and naive, he was a bit older and more experienced and easily manipulated.
    5; she has little self esteem, which he encourages, and plays on.

    Having a son is a reason to leave, not stay! Quickest way to teach your son to be an abusive adult, or to teach your daughter
    to put up with this is to stay.

    You can't really have a "strong" character stay married to an emotionally abusive husband, it doesn't work that way. If she was strong, she would have left years ago. Or she became stronger in the course of the marriage despite what was going on, and this can be an on-going tangent on the story with a side character of a mentor.

    I really do dislike the whole "But he doesn't hit me"

    Forgot the age old reason to put up with bullsh!t; $$$$. but strong women don't go that route
  • cmeade20
    cmeade20 Posts: 1,238 Member
    Speaking from personal experience, I dated a guy for four years who was an @ss in that manner. However when we first got together he was a nice guy, genuinely for about 2 years. Life took its toll on him, he didnt handle it well and he slowlymorphed into a miserable *kitten* and began to become emotionally abusive. Why did I put up with it? Not because Im weak or have poor self esteem but because at first I thought it was just a phase because he has been such a different person when we started dating. Eventually it became obvious this is who he had become and things ended but that might give you some ideas.
  • clairyfairy247
    clairyfairy247 Posts: 425 Member
    Do we get to share writing credit?

    It's for a novel writing project called NaNoWriMo (National Novel Writing Month).

    "Participants begin writing on November 1. The goal is to write a 50,000-word (approximately 175-page) novel by 11:59:59 PM on November 30.
    Valuing enthusiasm and perseverance over painstaking craft, NaNoWriMo is a novel-writing program for everyone who has thought fleetingly about writing a novel but has been scared away by the time and effort involved.
    As you spend November writing, you can draw comfort from the fact that, all around the world, other National Novel Writing Month participants are going through the same joys and sorrows of producing the Great Frantic Novel. Wrimos meet throughout the month to offer encouragement, commiseration, and—when the thing is done—the kind of raucous celebrations that tend to frighten animals and small children."

    http://www.nanowrimo.org/ if you're interested and I'll give you a thank you in the acknowledgements :-)
  • SeaRunner26
    SeaRunner26 Posts: 5,143 Member
    She has a 5 year old son so that is one reason to stay.

    Having children is not reason to stay in an abusive relationship. In fact it's on of the best reasons to get out of one.

    By staying in the relationship, it implies to the child that it's okay for one parent to abuse the other. Second, it increases the chances that the child will grow up with the same bad habits of one of the parents, either the abuser or the abused.
  • jackibailey
    jackibailey Posts: 206 Member
    In my own experience it is because I keep waiting for the man I married to magically reappear again. Do get glimpses of him at times. Def for the kids and because financially I can't make it on my own. And I am a strong person too in so many areas of my life, but weak when it comes to leaving him. I am on disability for bipolar disorder and can't work right now. I have no immediate family around. Live 1000 miles away. And in 2 1/2 years my youngest will turn 18. I always tell myself I can hold on till then.
  • SageGoddess320
    SageGoddess320 Posts: 2,589 Member
    She has a 5 year old son so that is one reason to stay.

    Having children is not reason to stay in an abusive relationship. In fact it's on of the best reasons to get out of one.

    By staying in the relationship, it implies to the child that it's okay for one parent to abuse the other. Second, it increases the chances that the child will grow up with the same bad habits of one of the parents, either the abuser or the abused.

    Couldn't agree more!
  • nikilis
    nikilis Posts: 2,305 Member
    addiction to peanut butter even though she's allergic to nuts....

    he has the last supplies of antidote left after the quickening, a time where bees gained a collective consciousness and attempted to exterminate the human race, and in doing so disrupted the natural balance due to their mass suicide / holy war - causing the collapse of human civilisation due to food scarcity.

    honey is the most valuable substance on the planet as it is so rare due to the extinction of bees.

    the time after the quickening is known as AB.... After Bees.

    "I could't leave. the butter was like a drug to me. It made me weak and giddy. in this new world this was my only reprise. in the old world a man like this would not have been tolerated... but here... in the second year of AB there was no kindness. Here a woman needs a man"

    wanna write a different book now? yep. bet ya do. lool.
  • DaniKenmir
    DaniKenmir Posts: 387 Member
    Many women find men who need to be 'helped' They think they can 'fix' them and when it doesn't work they simply try harder not understanding that no one is going to change for someone else, they'll only do it for themselves
  • Antlady69
    Antlady69 Posts: 204 Member
    Have you already fully developed the male character and the whole story? If yes, don't read on and ignore this comment.

    If not: she may have fallen in love with him because he used to be different, a nice, strong, reliable character. He may have changed because of an illness, for example a brain tumour. That could also be a reason why she's staying with him, because she knows that it's not really HE who is so abusive, but it's because of the tumour changing him.
  • BernadetteChurch
    BernadetteChurch Posts: 2,210 Member
    Surely the sex has something to do with it?
  • melaniecheeks
    melaniecheeks Posts: 6,349 Member
    She knows she's strong and smart, so she thinks - I can fix this, I can make it better, I just need to keep trying different things, reading different books, work on my communication with him....
  • MichelleLaree13
    MichelleLaree13 Posts: 865 Member
    So I am a nurse and do not condone staying in abusive relations for any reasons. :noway:

    That being said... there is a huge problem with men coming back from the war with PTSD. They leave as loving wonderful caring husbands and fathers. They come back damaged. They see stuff they are not allowed to talk about. How are they suppose to learn to cope with their feelings (sometimes children have to be killed in war/friends are captured and the family is told they are dead) if they are not allowed to talk about it? I would twist the story a little to make her "strong" to stick by her husband even though he has this internal struggle.

    This is a huge issue with nurses as well because we are not allowed to talk about what we do. For nurses, we call it burnout. There is a lot of research on how to fix burnout. The issue with PTSD and burnout are very similar so you may find researching burnout useful. :flowerforyou:
  • MichelleLaree13
    MichelleLaree13 Posts: 865 Member
    Have you already fully developed the male character and the whole story? If yes, don't read on and ignore this comment.

    If not: she may have fallen in love with him because he used to be different, a nice, strong, reliable character. He may have changed because of an illness, for example a brain tumour. That could also be a reason why she's staying with him, because she knows that it's not really HE who is so abusive, but it's because of the tumour changing him.

    Great idea! It sounds like your character is younger but dementia does it to.
  • jarrettd
    jarrettd Posts: 872 Member
    >Her family/friends/social circle believe the burden of a successful marriage falls to the woman. To walk away for any reason would not only mark her as a failure, but leave a black mark on the family name.
    >She may have married him against her family's advice and pride won't let her admit her mistake.
  • MiSo_SeXy
    MiSo_SeXy Posts: 210 Member
    Codependency? Perhaps it's how she grew up.. as much as it's a hardship
    Perhaps it's also a comfort because it's so familiar..
  • Jeneba
    Jeneba Posts: 699 Member
    There are always episodes within such a relationship where things APPEAR to be improving. The abused partner feels validated and cherished during the honeymoon period and it is like a drug.
  • sydneytomunich
    sydneytomunich Posts: 25 Member
    She has a 5 year old son so that is one reason to stay.

    Having children is not reason to stay in an abusive relationship. In fact it's on of the best reasons to get out of one.

    By staying in the relationship, it implies to the child that it's okay for one parent to abuse the other. Second, it increases the chances that the child will grow up with the same bad habits of one of the parents, either the abuser or the abused.

    I completely, completely agree with this statement!!

    I know it doesn't help the OP with her story dilemma, but it's such an important thing for people to know. Staying together for the kids, staying in a bad relationship for the kids...its the worst thing you can ever do.

    I was brought up by two amazing people who did NOT belong together, but stayed together "for the kids." All it taught me was not to believe in marriage, and to get the idea, via osmosis, that your own happiness should be subjugated for someone else's, and that it is ok to waste a life being unhappy if you think you are helping someone else.

    Would you really want your kid to live like that? Is that really the message you want to send?

    Again, apologies to the OP for hacking this. Just needs to be said more often!!
  • LooseWheel
    LooseWheel Posts: 211 Member
    You could look at the domestic violence cycle. its the part where he has to do the making up/sorry part that gets aw oman back into the relationship. maybe his 'sorry make up' part involves fantastic sex. maybe sex that allows her to be dominate and thats something she gets a lot out of?
  • nikilis
    nikilis Posts: 2,305 Member
    Have you already fully developed the male character and the whole story? If yes, don't read on and ignore this comment.

    If not: she may have fallen in love with him because he used to be different, a nice, strong, reliable character. He may have changed because of an illness, for example a brain tumour. That could also be a reason why she's staying with him, because she knows that it's not really HE who is so abusive, but it's because of the tumour changing him.

    Great idea! It sounds like your character is younger but dementia does it to.

    are you nicholas sparks?
  • jfinnivan
    jfinnivan Posts: 360 Member
    Maybe he's terminally ill, and only has a year to live. She doesn't have the heart to walk out on him. Also, she will inherit the 200 million trust fund he has...
  • brevislux
    brevislux Posts: 1,093 Member
    Maybe she's afraid she wouldn't be able to support her son and herself on her own or end up in the street. Maybe she thinks they can work on his problems and things would get better. Maybe she doesn't want her son to grow up without a dad. Maybe she's worried he might turn violent if she leaves him.
    Probably that man isn't evil and it's not black and white since life doesn't go that way - he's a man with some serious issues who is sometimes hurtful and, probably, sometimes compassionate, like people are. I think that in order to understand why she stays, you have to first work on his character and make sure he's complex and that you can use many more words to describe him rather than "abusive". Why does he act the way he does? What's his background and what lead him down this road? Is he aware that what he's doing is hurtful, does he want or try to change? I think all those things will get you closer.

    Good luck, I hope this helped. :)
  • She feels guilty about the affair she had six years ago and can't bring herself to tell him. This is her punishment unto herself. This is a woman running from the truth. She understands his abusiveness comes from his own insecurities that we will not able to keep her, so he tries to instill fear. Problem is, she is not afraid of his threatening behavior, she pities him.