vegetarian in need of thanksgiving ideas!

Hey everyone!

I've been veggie for a few years now and most of the time I don't miss meat. But Thanksgiving is different. I DO miss the turkey and I miss even more the turkey sammies the next day! Last year, I tried a Tofurkey and it was.....in a word....AWFUL! Does anyone know of any good substitutes for a turkey day turkey?

Thanks in advance!
Laura
«1

Replies

  • JessicaBR0
    JessicaBR0 Posts: 256 Member
    These are vegan, she has some really good recipes. http://ohsheglows.com/vegan-thanksgiving-recipes/
  • laura328
    laura328 Posts: 136 Member
    These are vegan, she has some really good recipes. http://ohsheglows.com/vegan-thanksgiving-recipes/

    thanks! some of that stuff looks great!
    anyone else? anything that actually can pass for turkey?
  • laura328
    laura328 Posts: 136 Member
    bumping in hopes that i get more responses :smile:
  • godblessourhome
    godblessourhome Posts: 3,892 Member
    i don't know the reason you have turned vegetarian, but why not just eat the turkey you crave for 2 days (the day of and the day after) and then go back to eating normal after that? :)

    if that option isn't for you, i hope you find a solution that will work for you.
  • spisea
    spisea Posts: 41 Member
    Have you heard of post punk kitchen? They have great veg recipes. Here's one for a thanksgiving roast : http://www.theppk.com/2011/11/seitan-roast-stuffed-with-shiitakes-and-leeks/

    Thats theppk , just in case this site doesn't allow links. the recipe is called sietan roast stuffed with shiitakes and leeks.

    I made the Caramelized Onion Butternut Squash Roast with Chestnuts last year. Its more of a casserole than a traditional roast. It was a huge hit. Tasty for me and the omnivores at the table loved it too. I made a huge amount and it was all gone the next day. Everyone had gobbled up the left overs.
  • flechero
    flechero Posts: 260 Member
    Well, since "cheat" days are such a popular topic right now... why not schedule Thanksgiving as a "cheat day" and eat the turkey that you so dearly miss!?!?
  • spisea
    spisea Posts: 41 Member
    *repeat
  • spisea
    spisea Posts: 41 Member
    Well, since "cheat" days are such a popular topic right now... why not schedule Thanksgiving as a "cheat day" and eat the turkey that you so dearly miss!?!?

    Because there are broader spiritual and/or ethical considerations around being vegetarian. This isn't just about calories to which you could compensate for at a later date. When we restrain ourselves from killing (as much as possible) for our food, we commit to a path of compassion for all life, not just human life. If you violate that, its a bigger deal than just "oops! I slipped on my diet."

    Realistically, many vegetarians have slips, where they don't live up this path of compassion. Its not OK, but it is normal, and we need to have compassion for ourselves as well. If Thanksgiving is really a time when you aren't ready to let go of meat, then have compassion for yourself, too.

    But you do need to know that there are lots of tasty, filling alternatives to turkey for thanksgiving. Because of our national obsession with having this one meat at this one time of year, almost every household in the US at the same time, the living turkeys go through extra hell before and as they are slaughtered. Their natural growing-up is manipulated to fit our timetable, so that they will be ready for slaughter all at the same time of year. They are killed quickly and with little regard for making their deaths quick and painless. For these reasons and others, Thanksgiving is an especially important day for we vegetarians to take a stand and choose to consume products which don't involve such brutal practices.
  • szarlotka717
    szarlotka717 Posts: 85 Member
    If you like fake meats, then Fieldroast may have some good options. I find their products at Whole Foods. A couple years ago, I made roasted acorn squash halves stuffed with quinoa and cranberry stuffing as a vegetarian main dish. Of course, most traditional sides can be made vegetarian.
  • A few years ago for Thanksgiving, one of my invited guests was a vegetarian. I opted to make shepherd's pie as the main course for everyone, and found a really great recipe on Epicurious for "Vegetarian Shepherd's Pie". It was a hit. (Yes, I made my own vegetable stock - I cook a lot.)

    If one is ok with mushrooms, have learned that really good-quality, meaty mushrooms (more than one kind of mushroom is best, i.e., crimini, oyster, and shiitake, or wild mushrooms such as boletes, porcini, or chanterelles, if you know what to collect) do really well in vegetarian dishes where meat or poultry might be missed.
  • Oops, I meant to add that if you're looking for a turkey "substitute", try looking for mushroom recipes under "mushroom pate". Not vegan by any stretch, but qualify as vegetarian as long as you're using a vegetarian stock.
  • MrsT_2009
    MrsT_2009 Posts: 90 Member
    It's not a substitute for turkey but I plan on making Happy Herbivore's Hippie Loaf for Thanksgiving. I had it a few months ago and it just tastes like Thanksgiving comfort food to me. http://happyherbivore.com/recipe/hippie-loaf-gluten-free/

    Like some others have said, if you really like turkey maybe you want to eat it on Thanksgiving instead of feeling deprived, depending on your reasons for going veg. I personally never really liked turkey and found that I only ate it because "that's what you do on Thanksgiving" so eliminating it from my plate was not a big deal.
  • It made me laugh to think a serious vegeterian would eat meat.
  • spisea
    spisea Posts: 41 Member
    It made me laugh to think a serious vegeterian would eat meat.

    Life is rarely so black and white as we would have it be.
  • BroiledNotFried
    BroiledNotFried Posts: 446 Member
    www.cookinglight.com has veggie Thanksgiving dinners
  • LilacDreamer
    LilacDreamer Posts: 1,364 Member
    Hey everyone!

    I've been veggie for a few years now and most of the time I don't miss meat. But Thanksgiving is different. I DO miss the turkey and I miss even more the turkey sammies the next day! Last year, I tried a Tofurkey and it was.....in a word....AWFUL! Does anyone know of any good substitutes for a turkey day turkey?

    Thanks in advance!
    Laura

    one of my favorite things I used to make is butternut squash lasgna with a sage infused bechamel sauce. it's fab.
  • gkozub
    gkozub Posts: 22
    I too am a Vegetarian and I have a yummy option for you!
    First of all, I don't think you should take the advice of some people telling you to take a "cheat day" from your Vegetarian diet to eat some turkey on Thanksgiving, it my mind it simply does not work like that. You became vegetarian for a reason didn't you?

    Anyways, what I did this Thanksgiving (I am Canadian, so I celebrated it in October) was so simple yet delicious.
    It's not a turkey substitute, though, but it's a meal you can prepare to share with everybody and they will like it too! (I know my family did!)

    In my family, we call this meal "Rice in a Box" so I don't know the actual name for it, haha.
    You will need:
    - One package of faux-ground beef
    - Whole grain brown rice (about 1.5-2 cups cooked)
    - One whole grain/Whole wheat fresh baked bread (oval shaped is best)

    All you need to do it cut a hole at the top of the bread and scoop out the inside, making a sort of bowl with the bread. Then, add the ingredients into it (you can even add veggies if you like!), and wrap it in foil and put in the oven at 350 degrees celsius for 45 minutes.
    and voila! a yummy, crunchy meal for the family to share!
  • keem88
    keem88 Posts: 1,689 Member
    idk if they sell where you are, the brand quorn makes pretty good meatless products (they don't really taste like meat per say, which i love because i hate when there are meatless subsititutions that taste like meat. if you want the taste then just eat the damn animal). anyhoos, they make a turk'y roll which is decent if you make a vegetarian gravy to put on it.
    i would suggest using something like seitan, and adding seasonings and a meatless gravy to it.
    this website has a lot of good vegetarian and vegan recipes, they have a section for holiday ideas http://www.vegkitchen.com/recipes-galore/
    post punk kitchen also has a lot of different vegan/veg recipes you can prolly find something good there. if not then i would deff suggest the seitan or the quorn fake turkey roll
    http://www.theppk.com/
    usually i just eat mad sides because the houses i would go to for thanksgiving usually just had turkey and the usual sides unless i brought my own. maybe you can even try and make a lentil loaf with mushrooms?
    good luck!!
  • I basically LIVE on Happy Herbivore recipes. I think you need to get her book for it (I think it's the original Happy Herbivore cookbook) but she has a recipe called "Torkey" that is yummy. Made from tofu. She has MANY free recipes on happyherbivore.com that are all amazing.
  • cgale8
    cgale8 Posts: 34 Member
    We have several in our family that are vegetarian. Last year we had a vegetarian Thanksgiving and no one complained!! Stuffing/dressing became our main dish and it worked out well for the second day as the basis for sandwiches with cranberry sauce. We made gravy as well. There are many recipes for vegetarian turkey but we have never tried any of the seitan recipes but hae read many reviews that were positive.
  • spisea
    spisea Posts: 41 Member
    Hey everyone!

    I've been veggie for a few years now and most of the time I don't miss meat. But Thanksgiving is different. I DO miss the turkey and I miss even more the turkey sammies the next day! Last year, I tried a Tofurkey and it was.....in a word....AWFUL! Does anyone know of any good substitutes for a turkey day turkey?

    Thanks in advance!
    Laura

    one of my favorite things I used to make is butternut squash lasgna with a sage infused bechamel sauce. it's fab.

    OMG. That sounds amazing. Is the recipe online?
  • keem88
    keem88 Posts: 1,689 Member
    Hey everyone!

    I've been veggie for a few years now and most of the time I don't miss meat. But Thanksgiving is different. I DO miss the turkey and I miss even more the turkey sammies the next day! Last year, I tried a Tofurkey and it was.....in a word....AWFUL! Does anyone know of any good substitutes for a turkey day turkey?

    Thanks in advance!
    Laura

    one of my favorite things I used to make is butternut squash lasgna with a sage infused bechamel sauce. it's fab.

    OMG. That sounds amazing. Is the recipe online?

    holy hell that DOES sound amazing. i would love to get that recipe too, imma google it :bigsmile:
  • DawnEH612
    DawnEH612 Posts: 574 Member
    I have tried lots of things oer the years and for many years made a tofu potpie, whose original recipe was in a Peta magazine.. Delicious. Bt, i decided i needed more protein at the table. I tried a Quorn cranberry and goat cheese cutlet last year that not bad. My sister liked it more than i did. He are some links for ideas. I may actually try something new this year like one of the field roasts. I do, btw, like the tofurky deli slices. Yu could heat themm up and put them on your plate, simple idea... If you made a good gravy you could probably make a great post thanksgiving sandwich.. In fact they even have a recipe on the back of the box for that!
    http://www.fieldroast.com/
    http://kblog.lunchboxbunch.com/2009/11/vegan-thanksgiving-series-main-dish.html
  • LilacDreamer
    LilacDreamer Posts: 1,364 Member
    one of my favorite things I used to make is butternut squash lasgna with a sage infused bechamel sauce. it's fab.

    OMG. That sounds amazing. Is the recipe online?

    holy hell that DOES sound amazing. i would love to get that recipe too, imma google it :bigsmile:


    Sorry, it's not online...it's my own creation. I never use recipes, I just create from my head and it comes out amazing. so my "recipe" isn't something you'd find on google...sorry about that. :(
  • gingerveg
    gingerveg Posts: 748 Member
    Tofurkey meal it's delish!
  • Lift_hard_eat_big
    Lift_hard_eat_big Posts: 2,278 Member
    Hey everyone!

    I've been veggie for a few years now and most of the time I don't miss meat. But Thanksgiving is different. I DO miss the turkey and I miss even more the turkey sammies the next day! Last year, I tried a Tofurkey and it was.....in a word....AWFUL! Does anyone know of any good substitutes for a turkey day turkey?

    Thanks in advance!
    Laura

    Chicken is a decent substitute for turkey.
  • Sarauk2sf
    Sarauk2sf Posts: 28,072 Member
    Quorn is a decent substitute as is Gardein - they do a fake stuffed turkey thingy. Their products are surprisingly good (I do not like tofurky myself at all).
  • billsica
    billsica Posts: 4,741 Member
    Tofurkey meal it's delish!

    +1 to this.
  • ripemango
    ripemango Posts: 534 Member
    i think a beautiful roasted butternut squash as the main course on Thanksgiving is elegant and def feels special.

    btw, collards are very traditional on Thanksgiving and they are fantastic...taste and health wise.
  • hannahamay
    hannahamay Posts: 77 Member
    Well, since "cheat" days are such a popular topic right now... why not schedule Thanksgiving as a "cheat day" and eat the turkey that you so dearly miss!?!?

    Because there are broader spiritual and/or ethical considerations around being vegetarian. This isn't just about calories to which you could compensate for at a later date. When we restrain ourselves from killing (as much as possible) for our food, we commit to a path of compassion for all life, not just human life. If you violate that, its a bigger deal than just "oops! I slipped on my diet."

    Realistically, many vegetarians have slips, where they don't live up this path of compassion. Its not OK, but it is normal, and we need to have compassion for ourselves as well. If Thanksgiving is really a time when you aren't ready to let go of meat, then have compassion for yourself, too.

    But you do need to know that there are lots of tasty, filling alternatives to turkey for thanksgiving. Because of our national obsession with having this one meat at this one time of year, almost every household in the US at the same time, the living turkeys go through extra hell before and as they are slaughtered. Their natural growing-up is manipulated to fit our timetable, so that they will be ready for slaughter all at the same time of year. They are killed quickly and with little regard for making their deaths quick and painless. For these reasons and others, Thanksgiving is an especially important day for we vegetarians to take a stand and choose to consume products which don't involve such brutal practices.

    THANK YOU. I'm so tired of people thinking it's perfectly normal for vegans and vegetarians to eat meat on occasion. My mother always tells me "oh just have one bite of this burger it's not going to hurt you." Maybe not, but it is going to make me feel like I just killed an animal and that would make me feel like a terrible person.